hmmmmm

I was moderately skeptical until the last line of your first post.
That dropped your post's legitimacy to an absolute zero.

I'm sorry, but I'm fine with you telling us not to comment on freshly spawned ideas on weapons and such.
I'm not fine with you pushing for a complete overhaul to gameplay mechanics and telling us to listen to you AND shut up.

Some times you offer legitamate advice on Suggestions, whilst other times you are just striaght up Trolling. What are you Desouler?

@Desouler: I have no idea whether you're being productive or counterproductive.
The last statement doesn't seem to help much, as it's just a challenge for us to tear your idea down to shreds (which, at the moment, isn't a very plausible one).
I don't know if you're really trying to help out with the game or just trolling us to no end, but seriously, who do you think you are?
"Comments and questions are not welcome and will probably be ignored. You may use your brain instead."
Seriously?

@Spyash: And think your thoughts through before you post them in a string of capital letters.
I know you have some good responses, but just looking at it makes my eyes hurt.
Plus it makes you seem like you're no less rude than he is.

I think shared party health would be INTERESTING but something you should opt in to, like tick off as a box on the menu. I could imagine playing in tier 1 or 2 with a bunch of guys and sharing my excess health so they are allowed to take a little more risk and maybe have fun with it instead of dropping like flies.

ya sorry if i seemed rude umm also i wont use capitals that much for that i can see why it might be irratating.i thought them through though.

@desouler girls can play the game 2 and some guys like the plume and flower heck one of my best friends would love to get his hands on one of those.

OP... you forgot the releasing monsters into Haven that can kill us (CE rev required) but we can't kill due to not having our weapons out, giving Gwenyvier rum so she sings pirate songs, and making the servers reboot when ANY player hits Alt+F4.

~Newg

For those that can't tell when I'm being a dumbass/stupid... look at the signature. :p

Oh, and don't ^&%ing tell us where not to post. "Comments and questions are not welcome and will probably be ignored" indeed. That's a pretty surefire mark that you've just typed out a slab of drivel but have mysteriously decided not to nuke the post from orbit.

it's in the suggestions board; it's legit.

I'd like to call troll, but a handful of people on this board (a handful too many) genuinely are this stupid.

If their was a bridge in game you would be under it @Desouler, Wouldn't you? And if some one tried to cross it you'd jump out and spout off some really annoying riddles.

I don't have to explain all of them for OOO employees, because simply mentioning them will indicate to them what they address.

It's official. I think everyone can stop listening to this guy now.

1) Cancel trading? Some people want to NOT waste Cr using AH, so they trade.
2) Removing monsters is messed up. Look what happened to the Tortodrone! People are furious!
3) Removing shields? What is it?! They're too tough?!
4) Party wide health pool?!!?!? (Kick noobs out IMMEDITALEY!?!?!?)
5) Individual pickups? Meh. That'll be cool I guess, but I think some players would see that as OP.
6) REMOVE PLOOM AND FLOWERS!?!?!? Totally against accessories, ain't ye? (I do not own a ploom or flower, but I personally like the flowers)
7) Again why remove plumes? Why you hating on them? Why do you hate plooms?!
8) Timeouts of 20 seconds? You must really go on solo, I heard no players could join if you pressed a few buttons!
9) Knockback rocks. Except when I do it, then I team kill my whole squad if it's not Sealed family. Keeps enemies Faaaaaar away (especially those meddling mechaknights!) WHY ARE YOU HATING ON THE TIDBITS?!
10) Transparency animation? I don't get it. Please elaborate.
11) Make alpha wolvers not teleport? Swing at em!
12) No comments? Well, welcome to the forums!!!! Please, elaborate WHY you want antisocial elements to the game? You know, you can easily join an empty server, then go solo right after that? Why are you trying to desocialize a social game, with an online community? It's like removing a brick's durability. Or removing blue from cyan. And removing all posts that seem irrelevant? Then WHY put it in a PUBLIC post?! Now please explain all what you mean!!!! Man, Suggestions are a public group of threads, and suggestions could be added to suggestions! People here are just trying to know what you mean by all this and the reasons behind everything here! This change, if OOO were to adopt it, WILL effect all players in every way known to man. We as a community try to edit a suggestion to fit the owner's idea into our own, to be fair for everyone. If you would just explain IN DETAIL and the reasons, then you would have proper feedback. So far, it's all Xs on this thread. again, welcome to the Public Suggestions THREAD (not a ticket/bug reporter, or else your thread wouldn't even be here. Plus, meh. Not very happy players) And then, you argument is to help those "other" players. What other players? Please explain what kind of players you are talking about! And then, you're hurting these players on your thread. EXPLAIN. EXPLAIN. EXPLAIN.
PS: You don't have to sacrifice any team mates versus the Trojan. Shield when he attacks, or just get out of the way. Super simple, especially when he charges!

...So please justify your claims. All of them.
P.S. We have laws for Stop Signs. Common sense, but removing social activity from a social game is like removing wheels from a freeway. That's why you explain.

Yes, I'm condescending to you. Problem?

"Instead, I put them here, where they are expected to be and where OOO will look for them, when they need inspiration."
News flash. How many of the suggestions in this board have actually been implemented by OOO?
And of all people, YOU? Inspiration? Why not run along and work for OOO then? You can give them inspiration, minus the 'trolling' you receive from us. Win-win, eh? You get rid of us, we get rid of you.
Please, I doubt you're actually a game designer. Do you have credentials? Educational background?

"It's just people like you overreacting and sometimes I find this funny and comment on it, but usually I don't even read."
Well that's harsh. Sorry for offending you by posting legitimate comments, hmm?

"Someone shows up at the booth of a famous car brand at a car fair. An official representative of the company asks if someone has suggestions. Someone raises his hand and says "You should build a plane, too.""
See, your attempt to guilt trip me might actually work, except I was giving suggestions about the car and the representative tells me, "No, I don't want to hear it because I want suggestions from car manufacturers. Ergo, shut up."
Now you tell me who's being unfair.

When you read a sign saying "STOP", do you intentionally not stop whatever you are doing, complain about how this sign is totally telling you what to do and do you start protesting publicly because it can't forbid you to continue?
Inappropriate analogy. If something is fundamentally wrong, wouldn't your instincts dictate that you speak up to rectify it, or ignore it altogether?
And don't give me the usual claptrap that "oh, you don't know what is wrong." If you want to engage in a debate over epistemological relativism, feel free to do so somewhere else - may I suggest the general forums?

I don't know what the hell you are trying to do here, but honestly, if you want to post comments on the forum, you'd better learn to deal with whatever's coming next.
You use a forum, you'd better get used to the fact that there are other users here, and you're not the only one with legitimate feedback. And you are no better than any other forum user. Don't think that showing off your creative flair or intellect makes you any better than the rest of us.

And like I said, if you only want OOO to listen to you, then you're in the wrong place.

If you are trolling (mind you this is only a speculation on my part), grow up. I've trolled longer than you have, and I've given up. You should too, if you are currently doing so.

I have never seen that sort of behaviour fighting Trojans! Who does that? It's pretty counterproductive play in a team game, particularly at higher Tiers. I can't imagine these players doing terribly well generally, and removing what is for the overwhelming majority of players a fun and interesting fight is no solution at all.

Desouler, if you don't want people commenting on your ideas, if you only care what Three Rings think, if you only want Three Rings reading them - I suggest you keep them off the forums. You'd be better off e-mailing the developers instead.

Anti-social behavior?
So much for making the suggestion to admin about making a "poke them in the eye" option for when other users are annoying us.

This is one of the best real trolls I have seen in a good while.
Quality trolling like this doesn't come around often.

Leave this Thread alone. Don't post on it. Don't link anyone to it. Just let it rot to the Nether Pages.

Succesfull troll is succesfull.

Replace forums by bug tracking/ticket system
- where would you post your "brilliant" ideas if there would be no forum?
Remove Trojans from Tier 2 and 3
- someone got his butt kicked and raged out?
Remove Trade (trading is still possible via Auction House)
- trade is actually encouraging players to interact with other players
Remove Shields from Mecha Knight enemies
- look at Trojans suggestion
Add a timeout of 25 seconds to the revive dialog, that will make people automatically go solo (while keeping the timeout that makes players automatically go to Haven on a party wipe)
- plain stupid, sometimes its better to finish off enemies and then revieve someone, it can take more than 25 seconds and during time you may not want someone to get kicked just becouse he died
Replace individual health by a party wide health pool
- that would make big space between good players and bad players. Good players would kick bad from party and they wont have chance to learn. but somehow that would encourage players to develop skills by themselfs. Kinda want, need moar to decide.
Remove all Pick-Ups or make them be present for all players individually like hearts
- dont like it, pick-ups for first to get make party have more diffrent pickups in the end
Remove all Plume and Flower Accessories (and give Players already owning them a proper compensation)
- yea, very social encouraging, lmao
Remove plumes of Spiral Tailed Helm, Firebreak Helm, Emberbreak Helm, the Cobalt Helm serias, etc.
- look answer above
Add a timeout of 20 seconds of idling that makes players go solo
- same as people before me, people do have life, they need to go to eat, answer phone, do something else,
Remove Knockback of all weapons (or lower it a lot)
- yea, i bet from monsters too? look at trojan answer, someone got butt kicked?
Add 70% transparency to all weapon and explosion animations
- yea, this game lags enough for some people already, adding even more transparency will make files bigger and make game lag even more
Add option to disable display of chat and /tell messages
- yea, blocking all chats will make people more social, lmao.
Replace "Remove from party" by invite checkboxes in a "Go solo" dialog, similar to the checkboxes on subtown elevators, but make it free to join a party created that way
- not sure what it meant
Add a delay of 2 or 3 seconds to all linked/grouped switches, that blocks switching them again (a visual indicator could be helpful, during the delay)
- more social behaviour? how is that so?
Remove screen shaking effects or add an option to disable it
- yea, some people get lags from it

To sum up.

Total of ideas 16
Ideas plain pointles, sometimes related to social behaviour but not to improve it 14
Good ideas but not related to social behaviour 1
I dont even know what he meant 1

And about you forbitting us to comment and post suggestions. This is FORUM, forum is for comments and suggestions. If you dont want comments on your opinions keep them for yourself instad of posting them at forum (which you dont really want as you stated in first suggestion).

Well so you can mabey get some people to understand this thread, ill do this because nobody else has.

May you please explain your reasoning for these suggestions?

The making planes suggestion example was hilarious because it's so true.

Anyways, you're not going to get much interest from OOO unless you actually take the time to explain your ideas. Though most players may not have much knowledge of what goes on in the game behind the hood, they have a very solid grasp of game mechanics and what makes the game fun for them; probably better than OOO staff themselves. After all, the inventor of the game of basketball wasn't the best basketball player of all time so don't expect OOO to suddenly understand your cryptic suggestions when the people who actually play the game cannot. If you cannot even make these players understand why your ideas are good, then any OOO employee reading this thread probably won't understand either and hence probably will not contact you for further clarification.

All us idiots must let this genius plan go to rest. :/ Don't we LOVE being called idiots? (AKA stop posting for those idiots, including me) Please, man, if you ARE going to type something, one more thing, at least say something that will boost gunners without impacting the difficulty? And use the ignore button for beggars? And dude, sometimes it's the heat of battle that keeps others from healing you, or the lack of health. I see some suggestions that probably won't count as the several items others may hate on. Like the kicking portion, try to elaborate on that, or drop on transparency and screen shaking (there should be an option for that). As for the health pool, dude then all are dead and no one could revive another or one revs all with energy (another energy crisis problem). WE play this game and respond only if we see something wrong. How are you to change a game (if implemented-on-sight option was added) and anger the players, only to benefit the few? Why not suggest something like, oh I don't know, gunner-friendly items?! If players don't like it, then only the few players would continue to play. Please, if you're not going to solve these issues the "IDIOTS" have problems with, then stop typing and let the negative bulwark of posts die out. ADD what others are saying, while trying to build upon your own idea, don't just ignorantly fight off those who don't agree. There's plenty of space for subtle changes THAT WOULD NOT ANGER THOSE ON THE FORUM. And stop calling us idiots.