I currently play with a Pepperbox and am unsure whether to get the Attack Speed Increase of the Justifier or the Damage Bonus of the Sundown.
I tried to look around the forums but no avail.
I have heard some people say that the damage bonus is standard for every weapon, meaning it will add 10 dmg to every weapon but I have also heard others say its a percentage increase.
I was wondering, how does Damage bonus (against all) work and whether i should get the Justifier or Sundown for my Pepperbox.
For the Pepperbox, Attack Speed is way better than a damage boost, in my opinion. Why? Because when you fire the Pepperbox, you can't move, you can't re-aim, you can't shield. If there are enemies nearby who aren't getting hit by your shots when you fire (and even something the targets you're hitting, if there are enough people in your party) that are going to be able to attack you in return while you're standing there. The faster you complete your attack, the faster you can take a step back, or pop your shield to block incoming attacks.
Just as an example, I have IAS maximum from my gear- and when I fire my Volcanic Pepperbox, I can fire both shots in the time it takes to fire one burst without any Attack Speed boosts. That's a pretty big difference. And in Tier 3, if I fire both bursts immediately in sequence in most situations, standing still that long means I take damage from something. But with one burst, I fire it off fast enough I can pop my shield, block any counter attacks, and step back and prepare to fire again. Being rooted to the ground is what makes the Pepperbox a non-viable gun for most players, so if you can reduce that limitation I think you'll find it to be a more effective weapon.