Forums › English Language Forums › Off-Topic › Gremlin Chatter

Search

Parent shaming gone wrong

9 replies [Last post]
Sun, 08/30/2015 - 11:10
Fight-Beetle's picture
Fight-Beetle

A 13-year-old girl from Tacoma, Washington, jumped from a bridge onto a busy interstate after her father shamed her on social media. The girl’s father cut off her long locks of black hair and filmed the young teen’s reaction. The man then posted the video to social media. However, new reports indicate that the public shaming didn’t end there. In fact, students at Giaudrone Middle School say that the young girl was also humiliated publicly at school by administration.

Izabel Laxamana was a 13-year-old girl who died in a tragic suicide this past weekend. The girl’s father had posted a public shaming video to Instagram of the girl being punished for “getting messed up” twice. The video showed the girl standing next to a pile of hair that her father had cut off as punishment for disobeying him. Now, many are questioning if social media shaming should be utilized by parents as an effective means of discipline. However, it seems that there may be more to the girl’s suicide than just the Instagram video.

Since the story was posted, a number of comments have been made regarding the incident with students at the school, noting that the day of Lizzy’s suicide, she was humiliated at school by the principal.

“After he cut off her hair he burned her clothes and smashed her guitar. He made her go to school the next day and in front of the entire school, dressed in boys clothes, at what should have been a happy day for her. He had the principal announce during the assembly that she had to withdraw from running for student council president because she disobeyed her father. She should have been giving her speech on why she should be president. She was crying and asked him to stop and was told to wait in the hallway.”

Another student’s parent notes that Izabel was forced to drop out of the running for student body president the day of the suicide and was crying in the hall during the announcement.

“There’s more to this story. I talked to her teacher. She was shamed in front of her peers by the principal and forced to withdraw her running for ASB Student Body President. She begged him to stop and he said wait in the hallway … She was getting bullied by family, peers, and administrator at school. No wonder she saw no way out.”

A parent that was helping in Izabel’s science class says the girl was crying the entire class.

“If I had know what izzy was crying about in scicence class when I was there, I would of taken her home with me and called police. Her beautiful hair looked like it had be cut off with a weed whacker. [sic]”

Another parent claims that the young girl told some of her classmates that she was going to jump off the bridge and that they reported her threats to teachers.

“She had told some of her friends that she was going to jump off the bridge also. Some Students said they informed some teachers about it. This is such a terrible tragedy if she only knew how much people cared for her.”

With so many allegations of various adults knowing there was an issue with Izabel Laxamana leading up to her tragic suicide, we are left to ask ourselves what can be done to prevent this type of tragedy in the future? What more could teachers or administrators done for this child on the day of her death? Should she have been referred to counseling after teachers witnessed her crying all day?

Opinions?

Sun, 08/30/2015 - 13:32
#1
Spetsam's picture
Spetsam
Sadly...

In the past to punish a person was to hit/beat up/kill that person,now it's getting old fashion and most of the laws in most countries forbid that.As she was a citisen of the U.S a highly developed country in most aspects,that was "the only" punishment.Basically you hit it where it bleeds.
"Now your friends are going to laugh at you for doing this/that etc."
To prevent it:
The suffering isn't ended with suicide,because with suicide you make your loved ones suffer.
Again:That's my opinion,everyone has theirs and I respect them even if they're providing an opposite one.

Mon, 08/31/2015 - 13:46
#2
Holy-Nightmare's picture
Holy-Nightmare
...

Punishment shouldn't have been so severe, and should have stayed at home..... not been spread to school.

BTW what did she do to make her dad do that?

Tue, 09/01/2015 - 07:31
#3
Fight-Beetle's picture
Fight-Beetle
Oh come on.

@spetsam and @holy-nightmare, you have obviously havent held out in an intelligent discussion for a while.
Okay, now for counterpointing:

@spetssy&nighty You seemingly only heard "A 13-year-old girl from Tacoma, Washington, jumped from a bridge onto a busy interstate after her father shamed her on social media. The girl’s father cut off her long locks of black hair and filmed the young teen’s reaction. The man then posted the video to social media. However, new reports indicate that the public shaming didn’t end there. In fact, students at Giaudrone Middle School say that the young girl was also humiliated publicly at school by administration.". You obviously flimmered through and did not read and peruse thoroughly and that's a bit despicable. Her name was Izabel Laxamana, which by it's nature is not a fully american name. Furthermore, she was asian, implying she's probably malasian or some other weird breed of azn.
People don't kill themselves because of facebook. They kill themselves because there's something wrong with them and they need help. Or, to put it in a media-friendly way: LEGISLATORS CALL FOR BAN OF PEOPLE WITH MENTAL HEALTH PROBLEMS
Also, in case you did not read her father WAS MENTALLY ILL HIMSELF. He MOCKED HIS DAUGHTER THE DAY SHE WAS TO GO TO SPEAK AS CLASS PRESIDENT. HER PRINCIPAL FORBID HER FROM SPEAKING AND MOCKED HER IN THE HALL. SHE CRIED IN CLASS. But you people never pay attention.

Diaub F. Beetel signing off.

Tue, 09/01/2015 - 10:29
#4
Deleted-Knight's picture
Deleted-Knight
Well this is depressing

I think a good parent should always punish with the intent of reinforcing a lesson to be learned. Ideally, they should deal punishment when they are not angry. This also makes it more clear that they are not doing it to be mean or cruel, but to make a point.
Most likely this girl suffers is insecure and suffers from peer pressure. Her parent probably didn't actually explain to her the importance of not being afraid of who you are and making smart decisions. He just punished her thinking that's what good parents should do.

Tue, 09/01/2015 - 12:59
#5
Midnight-Dj's picture
Midnight-Dj
:/

I don't know whether or not I should be more surprised at the fact that the three replies above me are some of the most half baked reply I have seen or the fact that some teenage girl's suicide in a first world country is made into a news headline when thousands of other teenagers are dying (or worse, committing suicide) across the world due to war, disease and famine.

Wed, 09/02/2015 - 11:21
#6
Spetsam's picture
Spetsam
My bad...

Yes...what you said is true,but you just gave an answer to your own question:People don't kill themselves because of Facebook.That's true because in some countries it's banned so it's mearly a tool.(Yes I did read the whole thing but one part was more appealing than the other so I commented on that specific part).
The part about her father being mentally ill was self explanitory so I mearly let it slide.If she cried in class then hypothetically she "wasn't paying attention" so basically someone had to calm her down,when you say "Hey I'm gonna kill myself" wait...you don't say that.It's the emotions in the specific moment that make you say it.As for how to prevent it:Calm her down and make her throw out all the anger and when you keep saying what happened it becomes less tense,at least that's all I can think of.
I'm new to the game,and overall new to forums of every kind so I tried my best ;)

Wed, 09/02/2015 - 17:17
#7
Holy-Nightmare's picture
Holy-Nightmare
.......

My question is still unanswered.......

Tue, 09/22/2015 - 11:28
#8
Spring-At-Peace's picture
Spring-At-Peace
@ HN

"For "getting messed up" twice"...

I am not sure myself, though I do hope that the man is not implying on what I think he's implying...

Tue, 09/22/2015 - 18:34
#9
Fight-Beetle's picture
Fight-Beetle
@SAP

Possibly alchohol. Maybe something worse, but who knows.

Powered by Drupal, an open source content management system