I'm trying to decide which shield to get and how to configure it with my armor to maximize resisitances, but no matter which I choose, the final configuration is going to be weighted more towards piercing or elemental, so one is gonna have to take a back-seat to the other, so I wanna ask you guys -
which is a bigger/more common threat, piercing damage or elemental damage?
Thanks for any help!
It depends on which stratum you're planning for.
For the midgame, piercing is more common. Wolvers are a significant threat when massed up in danger rooms and arenas, and the midgame boss stratum is Jelly based.
Toward the endgame, I would say elemental is the bigger threat. Without defense, a stray retrode beam or gun puppy bullet/missile can consume massive amounts of your health. Obviously, wolvers are more powerful in tier 3 as well, but I would guard first against the projectiles. Lagging into the missiles is a common issue.