Forums › English Language Forums › General › Suggestions

Search

Secure Asynchronous Trading Board (a bit anti scam)

4 replies [Last post]
Sat, 03/24/2018 - 19:05
Zosu's picture
Zosu

It would be nice to have a board, kinda like a reverse AH, for buyers to post offers in crowns or energy to, with an exact item name and a quantity of an item. Maybe even with up to 3 UVs from 9 dropdowns (like [damage bonus vs gremlins][medium][or higher]). The crowns or energy will be charged when posting (like an item in AH) and refunded via mail, if the buyer cancels the offer or it times out.

Sellers can see a list of all offers and search/sort it. To trade their item, they can turn it in (with an input box like in some missions or AH) and submit it. The seler can not turn in an item that doesnt match the name or the UVs exactly as specified. (Therefore a spelling error makes the trade impossible; but I think we shouldnt have a complete list of all items in the game. That woulld be some weird kind of spoiler thing.) The seller will then receive the crowns/energy and the buyer the item; both via mail.

To prevent ppl from flooding the board with offers, there can be a limit per account. So one would cancel an older offer if he already reached the limi, but has a more urgent desire.

This would enable players from different timezones to trade (rare) items.

It could also help to trade anonymously (if the design doesnt say who posted or agreed to an offer), so even players who dont ge along or put each other on ignore could trade, even though they normally would not be able to communicate and agree on a deal with each other.

Also this would be a secure method to do an asynchronous trade, which is currently done insecruely via mail. At the moment a scammer could pretend to want to trade an item by in game mail outside of the games (maybe via forums or some other form of communication), but then refuse to send his part of the deal. This Trading Board would prevent that, because the game makes sure all parts of the deal are submitted, completing the deal.

Sat, 03/24/2018 - 22:10
#1
Zero-Chill's picture
Zero-Chill
meow

Reverse AH is an awesome idea. Can also have a bid and buyout for example if 2 sellers have the same item the one who offers the lower price wins. In this case the bid has to be equal to or more than the buyout.

Sat, 03/24/2018 - 22:03
#2
Falminar's picture
Falminar
I could see this being

I could see this being convenient, even for items that aren't that rare.

The seler can not turn in an item that doesnt match the name or the UVs exactly as specified. (Therefore a spelling error makes the trade impossible; but I think we shouldnt have a complete list of all items in the game. That woulld be some weird kind of spoiler thing.)

If this is done, then just prevent an offer from being listed if it has an invalid spelling rather than keeping it up as an impossible request.

Side-note: Maybe this could be integrated into the Auction House system so that compatible Auction House and Trading Board listings will auto-complete each-other (as though the highest-offering buyer had purchased the lowest-requesting seller's item; a partial refund on the buyer's end would be given if the buyout price was lower than the offer). Alternatively, the buy offer could be applied as a bid in this case instead.

Thu, 03/29/2018 - 18:18
#3
Sir-Sappy
Keep in mind that this is a

Keep in mind that this is a company that is managing a game rather than a group of people doing a community project. I'm sure if they were going to implement any more trading systems they would've done it already.
We're already able to communicate with each other easily enough in-game and on these forums, and trades require both parties to accept and it gets un-ready-ed, for lack of a better phrase, if you don't follow in with how trading is supposed to work and that tight system, then you're giving away yourself to be scammed which is left to be your own problem for trying to make up your own solutions that don't involve the full trading or auction house systems.
If some one is looking to buy or sell something, all the basic mechanical stuff is here given to them.
The auction house is created as it is by a company who created a free-to-play game. If they believe they could modify it without giving more negative affects to the game itself and to whatever else they may have in mind, and keeping it user-friendly, I'm sure they'll decide to do something about it, if not... then that's just too bad for us and we'll just have to keep dreaming.

i hate the ah with all my being but i can't really say much towards wanting to change it in any way
I didn't really target anything as a whole with typing this and only picked out puny things to reply to and I don't know how jumbled/repeating I'm being, I really don't have the mind for English.

Tue, 04/03/2018 - 23:56
#4
Zosu's picture
Zosu
@Spharin

You're making a lot of assumptions. I am getting a negative vibe. Are you okay?

Also: https://imgur.com/8ThJwWC That's what I do anyways.

Powered by Drupal, an open source content management system