Forums › English Language Forums › General › General Discussion

Search

Costume Theory (and 'appreciation thread')

8 replies [Last post]
Wed, 10/24/2018 - 19:58
Fehzors-Forum-Alt's picture
Fehzors-Forum-Alt

There exists a dialectic between "good" costumes and "bad" ones that coincides with the dialectic between paid costumes like surge that hold rarity and free ones like hallow that are generated en mass. This dialectic is demonstrated no better than with the prismatic bolted vee- what was at one point a valued paid commodity was reduced to a free commodity- the result was that it went from seen as interesting to seen as trashy. Further, there exists a continuum of rarity that can be roughly broken down into what is attainable via grinding vs what is attainable via paying money. Since this is a continuum and not a true dialectic I have included a middle stage.

Figure One

As with many dialectics, the free inferior side of the dialectic can be combined with the rare dominant side to topple the dialectic as a whole. Doing so transcends the typical concept of sets, which present the player as banal, and creates interesting and balanced costumes.

Figure Two

  • Diamond Hood (med-paid tier)
  • Guardian Armor (med-paid tier)
  • Divine Valk Wings (med-paid tier)
  • Figure Two shows what happens when using all on-level costume accessories while still matching. This modern yet respectable look is at first blush a decent costume, but fails to be interesting on a meaningful level.

    Figure Three

  • Hallow Accessories (low free tier)
  • Citrine Helmet (high free tier)
  • Dragon Scale (med free tier)
  • Figure Three is overall a cheap costume designed to topple the free-rare continuum dialectic from the F2P perspective.

    Figure Four

  • Fencing/cyclops (low free tier)
  • Prismatic wings/snipe perch/cat tail (med-paid tier)
  • Prismatic gear halo/snipe aura (high-paid tier)
  • Dusky book (low-paid tier)
  • This costume overthrows the dynamic completely by way of ignoring paid costumes and tying in lower and higher tiered accessories. This creates a meaningful and interesting dynamic, as it destroys the dialectic presented above rather thoroughly.

    Figure Five

  • Dread Skelly (med free tier)
  • Magmatic accessories (high paid tier)
  • While this costume is certainly interesting and cohesive with the theory presented, more traditional art structures do still exist, and simply combining random high and med/low pieces is not enough to create a pleasing look.

    Wed, 10/24/2018 - 21:02
    #1
    Mayaura's picture
    Mayaura
    and gear

    I like how you took the time to match the shield and weapon to the costume. I think that's important for loitering in Townsquare.

    Thu, 10/25/2018 - 03:31
    #2
    Ewbte's picture
    Ewbte
    /derp

    /derp

    Thu, 10/25/2018 - 07:38
    #3
    Lyrose's picture
    Lyrose
    Omg, so many fashion experts

    Omg, so many fashion experts in sk.
    I have both high paid and low paid almost free costumes. And i admit it looks more pleasing to me a balanced costume all around than just vomiting high end prismatics and stuff in one armor just like my pearl. But i did that on purpose.
    For me a solid original costume has to have at least 1 hard to get piece so there won't be many copies of it.
    And by solid i mean matching color schemes but not all have to be the same style as base armor. That's a basic on how to costume.All same color makes it monotonous looking if there aren't a bit of contrasts from possible color combinations.

    Thu, 10/25/2018 - 20:31
    #4
    Bopp's picture
    Bopp
    some insight

    This gives me some insight into why other knights are always insulting my costumes: My costumes are bad.

    Thu, 10/25/2018 - 22:45
    #5
    Traevelliath's picture
    Traevelliath

    I always hate seeing costumes that are basically just money duct taped together. Yeah it can work, but often they descend into showy displays of wealth. Also, I personally see it as a challenge to create costumes without using full sets, so to speak. Essentially, making costumes like Figure 3, and avoiding costumes like Figure 5. Forces a bit more creativity out of me.

    Also, I'm a fan of clever uses of pre-existing pieces of equipment for costumes, rather than traditional promo costumes. Some of my favorites off the top of my head are the Fractured Mask of Seerus, the Demo Helms (including the Anti-Sleep Demo Helm), Dread Skelly Helm, Grey Feather, Ash Tail Coat, and Sunset Duster.

    Mon, 10/29/2018 - 08:18
    #6
    Ommelette's picture
    Ommelette
    This is on point with how

    This is on point with how great costumes become great, specifically by using the spectrum of costumes available. It's like the perfect bite which isn't a homogenized mush, rather a combination of interesting textures.

    I hope more great costumes will pop out, wasn't there a fashion show thread somewhere which costumes were judged and such? It would be great to resurrect that and have a competition.

    Mon, 10/29/2018 - 16:18
    #7
    Fehzors-Forum-Alt's picture
    Fehzors-Forum-Alt

    Entry One

    Here we can see a blossom aura put onto... hallow? At first sight, this seems to be an outrage. Perhaps the most expensive aura in the game is on trashy hallow! Many of us have chased blossom aura in the past, but few have managed to get one without sacrificing an arm and a leg to trade in. It's maddening, to see it wasted.

    ...but it is this outrage that makes this costume great, and a great example of toppling the duality between paid objects and free objects-- great art is known to provoke the viewer, to generate this kind of discourse and this outfit hits that nail on the head.

    Not only that, but it IS aesthetically pleasing- the green "vine" goes well with the pumpkin coloured armor, and the trail of wildlife gives off a pumpkin patch sort of aesthetic.

    Thu, 11/01/2018 - 19:59
    #8
    Fehzors-Forum-Alt's picture
    Fehzors-Forum-Alt

    The Bicolor Principle

    In Spiral Knights there is a tendency to throw together everything that has the same color and call it a costume. Imagine that you are an artist choosing which colors to use when you paint... while certainly plausible to create an all blue work of art, an all green work of art, and an all orange work of art, these things tend to be less pleasing and are used to exhibit that sort of emotion.

    In Spiral Knights however, these types of costumes tend to exhibit emotions such as "I like the color green, and collected all of the green things." There is nothing innately wrong with this emotion, but there is something innately right about mixing a multitude of colors in a way that pleases the eye.

    Figure One- I see that you are feeling quite yellow today....

    This is not necessarily a bad look, just a rather trite one. We've all done it.

    Figure Two

    This is one of my tech costumes that I use for heart of ice since it jives well with my shield and gun there. It's generally a positive example of the bicolor principle, so I thought I'd start with it.

    Figure Three

    This costume builds upon the oranges and darker navies of the toasty color scheme with a bright green color. The default scheme for the venomous promo was largely green with a smidgeon of purple, similar to deadly virulisk.

    Figure Four
    Figure Five

    It's unsurprising that the "default" sets make use of this via the prismatic element.. whereas ashtail set is grey and so jives well with its more vibrant prismatic aspects, vog cub set mutes this with even more vibrant yellow aspects that go well with its darkened red portions.

    Figure Six

    Today I took a bit of a risk and used contrasting colors to create a relatively jarring look. Rather than appearing pleasant, this use of color draws in the eye in a rather major way. If the purpose of costumes is to appear unique and draw in attention, then this hits the nail on the head.

    Figure Seven

    Lastly we arrive at peak Spiral Knights. There is no essence to anything- that is to say there is nothing innately snipe about snipes, or brandish about brandishes.

    Figure Eight

    This can be escalated to pure emotion. When you see my hallow + verdant costume, this is what you feel.

    Powered by Drupal, an open source content management system