Forums › English Language Forums › General › General Discussion

Search

OOO, I am disapoint (And may quit SK because of this)

57 replies [Last post]
Wed, 02/29/2012 - 18:43
Allunova

I remember joining SK due to its nice art style and action-based gameplay.and have had many good moments playing SK over the months.

Leveling the gear
Getting to the core
fighting bosses
getting my mercurial demo suit
playing lockdown
doing all of the above with my guildmates

Now however, the state of SK has been in a steady decline.

CE prices have risen greatly since I began and material prices (once my main source of income) started to drop like rocks just as I started to get into tier 3.

I have sunk about $15 of real money into SK and at the time, I did not regret it. However I cannot continue if the playerbase of SK allows the current situation of expansion missions and p2p exclusive weapons to remain unchecked. OOO has made quiet a few bad choices in the business model of spiral knights but the introduction of this new premium-only content has made "crossing the line" look like an Olympic long-jump competition.

In short (TL;DR)

We need: Occupy haven: episode 2

This is the first batch of content COMPLETELY inaccessible to f2p players.

The exclusive weapons are EXTREMELY overpowered and inaccessible to f2p players. (Lockdown now officially ruined)

The recent patches (mission rewards and the supply depot as they are now) will begin to unravel SK's player based economy.

It will only get worse for all but the most active P2p'er unless OOO makes ALL content accessible to EVERYONE without having to DIRECTLY pay real money.

This is the second time OOO has attempted to destroy the f2p model of this game (shadow keys were the first) that made it so attractive (that you could potentially experience all the content in the game while being f2p). While one could say that they need cash, there are better ways to run a f2p MMO than what OOO has now done. If there is not a strong enough backlash, this issue will only get worse with the release of future premium content and I will quit playing SK (and give no more money to OOO as a result).

I have done everything I have wanted to do.

If there is little or no new AND accessible content in development, then there is not much else to do.

It has been fun, farewell SK.

Wed, 02/29/2012 - 18:50
#1
Wuvvums's picture
Wuvvums
Just want to say I think

Just want to say I think Occupy Haven is an insult to the Occupy Wallstreet. There's a difference between social and economic inequality, and having to pay for a game's DLC. These two situations just can't even begin to compare.

I also don't know if any of the staff would even be considered in the 1% given how small the company is. Definitely in Sega, but I'm not sure with Three Rings at all.

Wed, 02/29/2012 - 19:04
#2
Aumir's picture
Aumir
Also, the day after Occupy

Also, the day after Occupy Haven the spokeperson and its comrades were wearing Snarbolax set. Quite the idealism!

Wed, 02/29/2012 - 19:14
#3
Xylka-Mkii's picture
Xylka-Mkii
"CE prices have ri" I read

"CE prices have ri"

I read until that, then I stopped reading, looked at the comments, and posted this one. Then I went and read a little more on the OP, and still see no difference

I completely Disagree.
Ignoring the facts, and knowing that over 9000 complaints on CE prices and P2P vs F2P, FYI if you are really struggling with the game then just pay 5 dollars and support OOO, and knowing that this thread is no different, I will support the opposite of what you assume is happening because, just like in the past, my opinion will not change on this matter.

On the other hand I like the new mission system and am planning on getting an expansion pack later this week.

And claiming that all players require and deserve all the content, i.e expansion packs, in the game is not the best argument, since I can say that there are many players who have made a negative impact on the game's community and do not deserve everything they wish to aquire in the game.

So now that my post is finished, I wish you have a good day here on out and bid you goodnight from where I live.

Wed, 02/29/2012 - 19:24
#4
Zephyrgon's picture
Zephyrgon
Well wait

The problem here is that SK has too much hyper-inflated stuff. I actually like the fact that people who pay get more from the game, and believe me that's the way it should be. However, it's very disappointing to see that SK has degenerated to this. When I first started playing, I was pulled in immediately by the graphics, the gameplay, and the game beguiled me so much I logged in and out whenever I could. Now, it's all about the profits. I really hate it when OOO only has profits in mind. Want my advice? Stop putting too much hyper inflated stuff. The updates only cater to the higher ups. What OOO really fails to realize is that people will not blow lotsa money in this game. If they like the game, they do, I mean if they are seriously addicted to this game, then they will blow lotsa money. But OOO, not everyone is like this. I've personally spent more that $50 in this game, and I'm not going to spend anymore. I'm happy with what I got with this game, I played with no regrets. But sadly, OOO please just stop these types of updates. Give us arsenal expansions, new monsters, new bosses, new content and more. I know you guys are pretty busy implementing these ideas so for once can't you listen to the consumer?
Like they say, "the customer knows best". Give us what we want OOO, and we will give you what you want.

Wed, 02/29/2012 - 19:49
#5
Wolfkit's picture
Wolfkit
I honestly wouldn't even have

I honestly wouldn't even have complained about this expansion mission if we had gotten f2p content along with it.
The only new content in the mission update was Blades of the Fallen, battlepods, and knockers.
Blades of the Fallen is so short it barely counts, after the new factor wore off to me knockers became about as interesting to fight as scuttlebots, and battlepods just take time.

The gremlins that look more interesting at a glance are p2p, the new levels have way more content than Blades of the Fallen, and have an actual boss.
Then there's new weapon and a new armor piece, both p2p.

With this major skew of content towards p2p, OOO has managed to make the mission system have one purpose only: to allow p2p expansion missions to be distributed.
In other words, OOO has spent quite some time now preparing for major p2p aspects and almost no time on f2p. This offends me.

I was going to buy a new elevator pass when my current one expires in a week, but now I'm just not sure I'll get my money's worth put of it without spending even more.
For now, you have lost my $6 a month, OOO.

Wed, 02/29/2012 - 20:30
#6
Redmania's picture
Redmania
Compromise to allow content for F2P players

I think they should allow players to purchase the content pack using energy.
The pack costs $3.95 and 1600 energy can be bought for 4.95 (cheaper $ to energy ratio if you buy more). Perhaps, 3000 or 3500 energy for the pack? It would certainly be easier to just sink the money in, but at least the F2P players have an option, albeit far more expensive.

Wed, 02/29/2012 - 21:07
#7
Zephyrgon's picture
Zephyrgon
UMMM

F2P means you don't sink money into the system. I think that OOO might have a trick up their sleeve, so I don't want to assume yet. The new update has some cool things, so I believe that it is worth the $3.95. You get new content, plus new equips. Pretty good deal if you ask me.

Wed, 02/29/2012 - 21:17
#8
Mejezfeld's picture
Mejezfeld
Okay

I'm strongly considering that maybe we should do something...

The idea is all the F2Pers and their sympathizers gotta agree to not log into SK for a while. OOO has put out a clear message they don't want to be 100% F2P anymore, and from this point on anyone who doesn't pay is a deadly gangster communist and is not welcome anymore. It's only fair that we listen to this and pack up and find something else to do for a while.

Wed, 02/29/2012 - 21:23
#9
Sniperjoe's picture
Sniperjoe
Zeph: The "deal" is what's

Zeph: The "deal" is what's bugging a lot of people. Many players, especially those who do not buy large amounts of CE, like to earn their rewards, rather than buy them outright. When developers separate players from content unless they pay an entry fee, that annoys many people, but isn't a big problem overall...usually. Spiral Knights is a special case, in that a large proportion of its player base has come to expect that everyone will always be able to access all of the content with enough CE, especially new content. The usual tolerance for extra missions found in many games' DLC packs these days doesn't seem to apply to SK.

Not only that, but there are many new rewards that are only accessible to paying players. Those rewards are not just cosmetic in nature, but actually impact gameplay mechanics and are unobtainable by players who do not want to fork over "premium" payment. (Quotes because it's only four dollars, but it's the principle of the thing)

I reiterate my hunch that the reason OOO has made this expansion cash-only instead of following their usual game design model of a steep, yet achievable CE price tag comes as a business decision, possibly influenced by their relationship to Steam, without regard for a large (and apparently vocal) portion of the player base.

Wed, 02/29/2012 - 21:25
#10
Allunova
Linking this for great

Linking this for great justice!

http://penny-arcade.com/patv/episode/microtransactions

Please, OOO take notes

Wed, 02/29/2012 - 21:28
#11
Iron-Volvametal's picture
Iron-Volvametal
I swear, if I see another Penny Arcade Link...

I'm going to lose it.

Wed, 02/29/2012 - 21:32
#12
Isisdelltion's picture
Isisdelltion
-

If Iron loses it...
Expect memes.
Lots of memes.

Wed, 02/29/2012 - 21:51
#13
Tenkii's picture
Tenkii
lol

@Allunova:
Eh, CE isn't 7.5k right now, is it? I remember CE prices like that before the Steam 'release' of Spiral Knights.
If it's lower than 7k, I'm fine with the prices.

I don't think there will be as significant of a backlash - a lot of murmuring, but unless you can convince a significant portion of the frequent CE-buying players and prospective CE-buying players to boycott, I doubt you'll garner attention. I'm a little bothered by the patch, but in all honesty since I've started playing again (I stopped from August - January for school), the only new things I've touched have been Lockdown and accessories. For now, the majority of the game can still be played F2P/ignoring the CE-heavy content, and I will still continue to stay F2P until circumstances change and I lose significant blocks of free time.

---
But lol @ this premium content.

I really think the following quote sums up the feeling:
"When developers separate players from content unless they pay an entry fee, that annoys many people, but isn't a big problem overall...usually. Spiral Knights is a special case, in that a large proportion of its player base has come to expect that everyone will always be able to access all of the content with enough CE, especially new content. The usual tolerance for extra missions found in many games' DLC packs these days doesn't seem to apply to SK.

Not only that, but there are many new rewards that are only accessible to paying players. Those rewards are not just cosmetic in nature, but actually impact gameplay mechanics and are unobtainable by players who do not want to fork over "premium" payment. (Quotes because it's only four dollars, but it's the principle of the thing)"

Wed, 02/29/2012 - 23:05
#14
Stelli's picture
Stelli
I think the problem with most

I think the problem with most players is that they try to pay the least possible amount to access the most content in this game.

I've been to a new bar down the town hall once, they had this special promotion on Wednesday, where you can "Sit for free" so literally you can just sit there all night without paying for a drink.

Then those who sat for free sees the bar owner giving more service and nuts to those who have paid for drinks.

Eventually, the bar got better seats and a separate area for those who have the decency to pay.

The problem with a part of the community is that they try to pay for a drink and sit for a whole night taking sips without ordering anything else, and I apologize if I offend anyone that can not have access to pay for 3.95$ online.

The Pay to play population wants something exclusive, they want to be spending their money for value.

The Free to play population wants everything public, they want to be not spending a dime in exchange for equal treatment.

The game developers will piss off one of these sides anyway no matter which side they chose.

If your not prepared to pay for a game, prepare the game developers to release features that will attract you to pay and prepare to not have access to the full content.

Not only does it apply to SK, but it applies to real life as well. You just can't be a cheap skate and asking for free meals where ever you go.

Wed, 02/29/2012 - 23:08
#15
Heavy-Duty's picture
Heavy-Duty
...

@Stelli
It's not the price. It's how the content was released. It's awesome, but this time you MUST pay to play for it. It's a huge change in the player economy.

Wed, 02/29/2012 - 23:14
#16
Stelli's picture
Stelli
@heavy-duty

I thought that Nick has mentioned in another post that they can be traded on steam? or given as gifts.

So if you have a friend who uses steam, you can have access to the content paying CE with the same value as 3.95$ which is not alot.

Wed, 02/29/2012 - 23:20
#17
Heavy-Duty's picture
Heavy-Duty
...

@Stelli
That fixes stuff for Steam, but what about nonSteam? (I don't use Steam) If this can be transfered via gifting w/ purchase, that would be a little better, but still someone must pay or the Expansion. It's still a new dent in the economy.

Wed, 02/29/2012 - 23:32
#18
Knightrails's picture
Knightrails
Non-steam players have no

Non-steam players have no access to the new content, so it doesn't matter if you are P2P or not. I believe Nick has said something about exploring some kind of fix for that though.

Thu, 03/01/2012 - 00:32
#19
Stelli's picture
Stelli
@knightrails you are

@knightrails

you are obviously wrong, i'm non steam and i paid with paypal to open up my expansion right when it was released.

I think you mean that non-steam F2Pers have no chance of access to the new content.

Thu, 03/01/2012 - 00:35
#20
Knightrails's picture
Knightrails
Is that so? Ah, I was under

Is that so? Ah, I was under the impression that Steam was the only form of distribution. That's good to know. So there's a smaller group then I thought without access to the new content.

Thu, 03/01/2012 - 01:05
#21
Pawn's picture
Pawn
Be patient

Likely there will come a time in the future where u can get the content via ce instead of $$$.
If it is just a delay until you can play it, then surely (altho alienating) you can understand the validity of that.

Just for a point of reference, IMO it should have been ce purchasable for like 5k ce or even 10k. That way friends could help friends etc. Also, that ce came from all the money paid in for wings, auras, etc. But...it is what it is.

Thu, 03/01/2012 - 02:01
#22
Blitzwingoo's picture
Blitzwingoo
I keep seeing the same

I keep seeing the same confused counter-points come up from people okay with the Expansion Missions accessible only by real money.....F2P vs P2P, Expansion Missions are Great Value, it does't cost that much. Those aren't the real issues here. The point is they're not accepting CE for entry, they're only accepting real money. What's wrong with CE which only comes into the game when somebody buys it with real money? Until now, CE has always been understood and implied to represent real money in game. Everything was obtainable with CE in game....until now. When a F2P player obtains CE by whatever means, it's supposed to still represent money that was paid for it. When a P2P player buys CE, it was still obtained by real money. So why can't a F2P use CE to purchase access? Why can't a P2P player use CE to purchase access?

Essentially OOO is now saying CE is not worth money. Money you have given in the past, they will not accept. They're trying to devalue our money which we've given them before.....they're trying to rob us. I mean why don't they just now do away with CE and institute Expanded Mission Currency for real money, and then do away with that and implement The Core Currency....and so on.

OOO expecting us to use the Steam Trade is a joke. Person A pays OOO real money for the Expanded Missions. Person B trades Person A CE for the Expanded Missions. So why don't Person B just trade CE for real money from Person A then? Getting pretty shady there.

With our trust in CE being good as money being shaken like this, I don't know how OOO can expect us to pay any real money for CE anymore knowing that CE may not get us access to things in the future.

I would recommend anybody who's quitting (temporarily or permanently) to sell all your CE on the CE market before you leave. Why? Because it will make CE more available so it'll take longer for people to want to buy CE from OOO directly to show them your displeasure. If you ever decide to come back, you can buy your CE back with the crowns. Otherwise your CE and it's represented real money value goes to waste on your abandoned account.

Thu, 03/01/2012 - 02:44
#23
Knightrails's picture
Knightrails
I don't really see your

I don't really see your point. CE is functional as a currency so long as it functions in the way it was promised to function. It still functions in the same manner as it used to function. It does not function for the new content, but that does not invalidate it's previous functions. So long as it's functions exist, it has value. It has no value in relation to the purchase of new content (Which through steam trade it does, but let's not get into that.), but it still has value for the functions that the CE was purchased for.

Hell, the simplest way to prove your point would be if everyone stopped using CE as currency in Bazaar because it's now worthless. So go ahead and prove me wrong. Because if it's still functioning as trade currency, then it still has value and hasn't become worthless.

Thu, 03/01/2012 - 03:19
#24
Metagenic's picture
Metagenic
SCREW occupy haven

The first time it happened, it was over in a day and the guys from Guild who started the whole thing were bragging about their snarby sets.

Thu, 03/01/2012 - 03:22
#25
Derpules's picture
Derpules
What Knightrails said.

Worried that your CE isn't worth anything any more? Please, let me take that worthless pseudo-currency off your hands.

Thu, 03/01/2012 - 03:29
#26
Sirenblue's picture
Sirenblue
Here's your "goodbye" you asked for

Bye.

Thu, 03/01/2012 - 04:11
#27
Blitzwingoo's picture
Blitzwingoo
@Knightrails

"I don't really see your point."

CE is purchased with real money, right?

Before the Expansion Missions there's nothing really that couldn't be bought with CE, right?

But now the Expansion Missions cannot be bought with CE, the first real time something can't be bought with CE, right?

Which is it better to have now to purchase things with, CE or real money?

CE has been devalued. Sure it has not been made completely worthless, but it's not as strong as it was before the Expansion Missions. Will it get devalued more in the future? If they continue to release things you have to pay real money for, then yes....CE will continue to become more devalued.

-------------------

Now separate issue. Depending on the player, the player maybe an endgame player who doesn't need to craft gear anymore and all the other stuff CE can buy pre-expansion missions. Now their CE just sits there.....worth the real money paid for it but nothing to spend it on. Out comes the new Expansion Missions.....oh sorry can't buy it with CE even though that CE is supposed to represent real money. What would this player think about their CE?

Any unused CE in the game is un-earned money by OOO in my opinion.

But hey if you think CE is still so valuable.....why don't you trade me some real money for it at the same exchange rate as the energy depot? (Hypothetically speaking of course).

Thu, 03/01/2012 - 04:43
#28
Wuvvums's picture
Wuvvums
Now that I think of it, you

Now that I think of it, you couldn't really use CE to buy anything that did require money. Dragon wings? Elevator passes? Promotions? Exclusive items? They were always selling content that AT LEAST needed a cash payment. And still, there was always the possibility that the item could end up in the hands of a free player. Then again we could say that about crystal energy itself. There's really no such thing as a free lunch, and the free players do sort of progress off the backs of -someone- out there that had to spend money. This isn't a bad thing, I'm just saying that somewhere money was spent.

But I never saw anything from the energy depot that could be bought with energy. And energy was never a substitute for currency. Of course they don't have to use this model, but the content itself is more like an elevator pass you're buying than say a shadow key that you buy in-game for CE.

Thu, 03/01/2012 - 17:53
#29
Blitzwingoo's picture
Blitzwingoo
@Wuvvums

Now that I think of it, you couldn't really use CE to buy anything that did require money. Dragon wings? Elevator passes? Promotions? Exclusive items?

With the exception of the Elevator Pass, Dragon Wings and such could be bought in a round about way in-game with CE. Somebody puts the Dragon Wings up in the AH, I sell my CE for crowns and buy it from the AH with crowns. So essentially CE bought with money can be used to obtain the item in-game.

The Elevator Pass is a grey area. It can't be bought by CE, but it does the same job as CE for elevators. Regardless, the Elevator Pass can't really be seen as Content like the Expansion Missions or Accessories. It's like a heat booster or Krogmo Token Booster.

Since the Expansion Missions cannot be traded in-game, I can't buy it with CE in-game. Sure there's the Steam Trade, but that's outside of the game and seen more as a private arrangement outside the game. You cannot call that private arrangement as being able to buy the Expansion Missions with CE. If you did, then if somebody traded somebody else for the Expansion Missions with Drugs in real life....then you could say SK supports a Drug Market Currency.

Thu, 03/01/2012 - 18:34
#30
Wuvvums's picture
Wuvvums
"With the exception of the

"With the exception of the Elevator Pass, Dragon Wings and such could be bought in a round about way in-game with CE."

I think the same could be said with this new DLC, then. I sold 6 today to people who couldn't buy it with cash, and they bought it with CE instead. That's how it had to work for the dragon wings, so it did for the DLC too.

Thu, 03/01/2012 - 19:26
#31
Typical-Guy's picture
Typical-Guy
But there are still people

But there are still people being excluded who don't want to use Steam, and shouldn't have to. That argument's been used before Wuvvums, and it doesn't work.

Thu, 03/01/2012 - 19:39
#32
Blitzwingoo's picture
Blitzwingoo
@Wuvvums

"I think the same could be said with this new DLC, then. I sold 6 today to people who couldn't buy it with cash, and they bought it with CE instead. That's how it had to work for the dragon wings, so it did for the DLC too."

Did you fully read my post? There's no way to trade the DLC in-game. What you did is a private arrangement outside the game. Dragon Wings were able to be obtained in-game through the Auction House or player-to-player trade in-game.

Thu, 03/01/2012 - 19:40
#33
Clueless-Inferno's picture
Clueless-Inferno
I really think the DLC should

I really think the DLC should be in some way available to all players. It would make people happy again.

If this were some random game I picked up, and this happened, I would have quit already. The main reason I stay is because of the players. They consist of funny, smart, cool, cocky, modest, helpful, overall fun to be with people. All of these types of people are necessary to a great game, such as this (even including the cocky ones :). The social aspect was so well made too, being able to chat and/or voice chat, secret message, mail, and other ways of communication. I enjoy everyone's presence here. 

Second are the community managers, mods, and game developers, Eurydice, Atalanta, Hyperion, and so many more (no less important then the ones named) who are just so helpful and put up with a lot of BS, as well as taking part in some player discussions/activities. I don't think I know of any other game with such a close bond between GM's and players. I <3 both players and GM's alike (No homo).

I know some people are going to say I am some random loser suck-up who has no life, or just some fa**** with nothing better to do with his time, a troll, a loser trying to get attention, or something else. There will always be people like that, and you can't really blame them. 

No matter what happens, I'll play this game whenever I feel like it, and I won't quit just because of one insignificant reason. 

Thu, 03/01/2012 - 19:53
#34
Wuvvums's picture
Wuvvums
The developers said they may

The developers said they may try a way to implement the trading on the client's side. Until then, I don't think the steam argument is a poor one. Can you claim it's not free when it can be done through another program that's free? While it may inconvenience you to get it and to link your account (also free, mind you), I don't think it's right to say that there are absolutely no options for free players and that it's impossible for them to get.

Thu, 03/01/2012 - 20:29
#35
Njthug's picture
Njthug
Occupy Wall Street worked so

Occupy Wall Street worked so well in NYC...oh wait it didn't...unless failure = success

Thu, 03/01/2012 - 20:28
#36
Njthug's picture
Njthug
Occupy Wall Street worked so

Occupy Wall Street worked so well in NYC...oh wait it didn't

Fri, 03/02/2012 - 00:52
#37
Blitzwingoo's picture
Blitzwingoo
@Wuvvums I feel you're still

@Wuvvums

I feel you're still not understanding the concept here. I have Steam, a lot of other people against the real money only for the DLC has Steam too. Using the Steam Trade is outside the game, it's a private arrangement made outside the game.

For example, if I was to trade some CE and one million dollars to a SK programmer outside the game for him to delete somebody else's character in the game.....could we say "Character Assassination now available for Purchase with CE in SK"? Granted people Steam Trading for the DLC are only asking for CE, but since it's a private arrangement outside the game they could pretty much ask for anything they want.

If they had a way to make in-game trading of the DLC, I would not have as much of a problem with the DLC. If they allowed in-game purchase of the DLC with CE, I would have no problems with the DLC. To me it's not that I want the DLC, it's the fact they're putting up a "Pay Wall" and they're devaluing CE by saying "your previous money you gave us is not valid to buy this DLC". Unacceptable!

@Purgion

"...I won't quit just because of one insignificant reason. "

DLC purchase with real money only is not insignificant. It's probably the most significant thing to happen to date.

Fri, 03/02/2012 - 04:55
#38
Asukalan's picture
Asukalan
It even dont have to be an

It even dont have to be an in-game trading of the DLC. Of course making us able to do it will be good for future.

But as the expansion missions, they could make whole thing work just like shadow laris! You can acces to lobby of expansion mission but elevators are locked, in order to unlock them you need to buy from vendor an item that unlock them, it cost CE and its bound on purchase, after use dissapreads and elevators are open forever.

They could do it from very beginning, make it work like shadow laris, obtainable both with purchase and with CE. They could, but they didnt want to? So why now they are telling us 'we are workign on it...' and EVEN mentioning an possiblity of this ability to be IMPOSSIBLE to implement into game?

Fri, 03/02/2012 - 05:11
#39
Wuvvums's picture
Wuvvums
Excuses. The content CAN be

Excuses. The content CAN be obtained for free but obviously people don't want to have to exhaust their options for it. And yet they'll link around the micro-transactions model, which says something along the lines of that money should buy -convenience-, and in this case it does. It can buy you the convenience of not having to get steam and hunt down a player making an offer. It buys you the convenience of not having to -wait- until a new trading system is implemented (something they ARE considering, but not sure if possible yet. And you know what? They probably didn't want to push back the new content until this is ready). So once again you're buying the convenience of not having to wait to get it. But still, after looking at all this, I just can't see people saying there's absolutely no way this content can't end up in the hands of a free player.

And that's what it boils down to: people claiming that this cuts off free players, when there ARE options for free players. If the free players don't like it, well, they'll just have to wait. And isn't that what they were doing when playing this game for free? Waiting for their mist to recharge, waiting to save up the crowns, and waiting until they had all the right gear and the right amount of energy? But NOW it's apparently too much that they can't have this content off the bat, and they might just have to wait for it because they don't have the cash? I just don't get that they apparently had the time to build up a free character in this game, but can't seem to wait for the developers to place in a system for trade client-side, and can't use the other options in the mean time because Steam is Satan, third-party program, trading takes outside the game, etc. All these arguments are -ideological- arguments but when it boils down to the reality, there are ways for it to work and players don't want to have to go through that and complain anyways that this company is greedy and corrupt for doing what companies do.

Fri, 03/02/2012 - 09:38
#40
Allunova
I would have been happy if

I would have been happy if OOO would have just required players to spend an amount of CE to unlock the missions and the weapons where not insultingly overpowered.

Steam trading is not a good argument. If OOO had intended steam trading to be a way of f2p'ers accessing the content, then why did they not just require CE-to-unlock directly from the game client?

Fri, 03/02/2012 - 10:10
#41
Tengu's picture
Tengu
CE =/= money spent by YOU. CE

CE =/= money spent by YOU. CE = money spent by SOMEONE.

consider it an act of sacrifice to access more game. If anything, I have to jeer OOO for not enacting P2P early on like other successful MMOs.

Realization has got to hit you F2Pers sometime that ya'll have been playing a very fun game for almost a year...and have personally contributed nothing to OOO's financial success. You've clogged their servers, whined and complained about every little issue, and..heh..protested patches.

This bears mentioning again. CE does mean your personal money. CE means SOMEONE'S money that you're now in control of. Smacks of welfare fraud or spoiled children to me.

Fri, 03/02/2012 - 12:48
#42
Redredredguy's picture
Redredredguy
I'll add my simple 2 cents to

I'll add my simple 2 cents to all of this, being that I'm a pure F2P player...

I don't mind there being expansion content that I can't access. That's fine. That's their trick to wave something in the face of free players to get them to finally spend money on stuff. My paying friends do it all the time. Waving their nice armors and now, new P2P only weapons in my face. That's fine. ( I spend weeks just fully upgrading a single line of equipment, where my friends just buy CE deals and suddenly have 20 different sets of equipment to use.)

The issue I have is that with this start in making P2P only content, they will heavily focus on the P2P content, and leave all the F2P players in the dust. Sure, we F2P players got the mission update as well as P2P. But it kinda feels like it stops there. Since the missions stopped with the cruddy Roarmulus Twins. I was going in expecting to be taken through the hellish depths of Tier 3 missions, and even get a chance to go through the FSC in a mission set up. Nope. All of that stuff, along with new bosses to come, will seemingly get put into a P2P box.... sealed by chains of money.

All the things like the Metal Sonic suit, and the Dragon wings..... sure you needed money to buy those, but those that bought them, and didn't want them anymore were allowed to sell them in the AH for free players to buy. With these new OP weapons (especially that annoying, blinding bomb), you can't sell them to free players, giving paying players access to more content, AND they're able to crush the free competition(in LD). This is only the 1st step. No doubt there is more P2P only content to come, in the future, that will completely shift the balance of this game. Be it in the clockworks, or in the PVP modes. (speaking of which, we need a new PVP mode. LD and BN get boring after so long.)

Only time will tell when, or if all this will happen. Maybe... just MAYBE some day this P2P only content will become accessible to F2P users who invest insane amounts of CE into it... Who knows? I hope OOO knows what they're doing. We all understand business is money, but consumers are business. If you lose your consumers due to stupid moves, your business will begin to fall. And as much as I've grown to like you guys through SK... I don't want that to happen.

EDIT:
I don't know if someone will point out the deal with elevator passes, but if you have a buddy with one, they can always tab you, so you use Their mist. Which they don't exactly need for much of anything. So you get the best of that as well.

Fri, 03/02/2012 - 12:57
#43
Pseudonewb
Consuming CE is just as

Consuming CE is just as important as buying it. Anyone who understands supply and demand knows that.
CE is not traded for free, the market price is around 6500 CR for 100 CE. Trades made willingly.
Non monetary transactions are as legitimate as monetary ones. And I doubt that all CE sellers are trading out of goodness in their hearts.

Don't say F2P are getting stuff for free or dare to suggest that they are stealing.
It isn't a very good argument and for the most part, it is counter productive, and it is more or less being condescending.
So it is pretty silly argument to put up.

I think Three Rings has a brilliant model for F2P and find it sad that they would shy away from it.
But I guess that, while CE can pay for the servers it doesn't bring in enough money to support ambitious projects.
I guess they have to take their risks. They are game developers, not server operators, so they need to take on the bigger projects.
The community won't last without continuing content and they want more and faster, so they need to take on the bigger projects.
Their hands are tied, and perhaps they really wan't to do something with this little game.
And perhaps that realization can put my thoughts about this game at ease.

But one simple fact must be noted.
Three Rings, Nick, you kind of did pull a fast one on everybody changing the terms on how to buy the expansion.
Next time, you should really be open about what you are doing, and if you aren't sure how you want to do something, try to manage people expectations better.

Fri, 03/02/2012 - 13:27
#44
Nodocchi's picture
Nodocchi
@AllunovaFirst you complain

@Allunova
First you complain about how CE prices have risen to be more than you can afford then you complain about how OOO made it so that it isn't possible to buy the expansion pack with CE. You are aware what releasing the expansion pack as something purchasable by CE would do to the CE market right? The price of CE would skyrocket. Based on what you have stated, there is literally no way for OOO to please you and still be able to release the expansion pack.

Sat, 03/03/2012 - 00:41
#45
Blitzwingoo's picture
Blitzwingoo
@Wuvvums If your argument of

@Wuvvums

If your argument of the DLC, which is only obtainable by real money, is obtainable through steam trade by a private arrangement makes it free-to-play is true....then why don't they advertise the DLC as Free-to-Play on the DLC's Steam Game Info?
Spiral Knights: Operation Crimson Hammer

Because I'm pretty sure if they did, it would be False Advertisement! It would also be particularly comical to see them try to say it's F2P when there's a price tag there too.

And stop trying to make this about Free-to-Play vs Pay-to-Play.....I spent money on SK before, I'm a P2P player. Why can't I use the CE which I bought with real money to buy the DLC? A lot of other P2P players are asking this too, so when you bring up F2P vs P2P it's a moot point and you're just distracting from the real problem.

@Tengu

"CE means SOMEONE'S money that you're now in control of. "

What if I bought that CE with real money....how is it somebody else's money that I'm in control of if I bought it? Why can't I use the CE which I bought with real money to buy the DLC?

"Realization has got to hit you F2Pers sometime that ya'll have been playing a very fun game for almost a year...and have personally contributed nothing to OOO's financial success. You've clogged their servers, whined and complained about every little issue, and..heh..protested patches."

I'm not a Free-to-Play Player, but you've obviously underestimated what the F2Pers contribute so much that I have to pull out this video again.
Penny Arcade explains Microtransactions

@Nodocchi

Somebody can be upset about the skyrocketing CE prices and also be upset with the DLC not being purchasable with CE. Why does it have to be one or the other? They're two separate issues. You're also making an "All or Nothing" argument here, like "If OOO can't do it totally right, then it's okay for them to do it totally wrong". It's a false dichotomy, there's more than two options here.

Sat, 03/03/2012 - 05:19
#46
Wuvvums's picture
Wuvvums
I really don't feel like

I really don't feel like arguing about this anymore. I will say this though: can you guys stop posting that damn penny arcade link? Yes, it gives a bit of good advice, yes, it makes some good arguments, but I've seen it all over the damn place since this was posted and it's getting pretty redundant. You guys are clearly capable of formulating your own arguments without having to point us to a video (which some of us may not want to load, or care about having to sit through a lecture).

Sat, 03/03/2012 - 06:06
#47
Twiddle's picture
Twiddle
I like the expansion

I like the expansion. It's everything the shadow lair update should have been. Sure, you must pay real money for it, but the game is not asking you to pay that much money. If you combine the amount of money for an energy pass and the expansion you'll find it's less than a normal subscription for most pay to play MMORPGs. What's best about the expansion: pay once, get continuous access, unlike the shadow lairs, where you have to keep burning energy every time you use it.

Sat, 03/03/2012 - 08:07
#48
Nodocchi's picture
Nodocchi
@BlitzwingooIt doesn't seem

@Blitzwingoo
It doesn't seem like you understoof my argument, let me break it down for you.

1. If OOO released the expansion mission as purchasable by CE, then people would buy it using CE, thus decreasing the amount of CE in the game and increasing overall demand for CE. This will cause CE to rise in price, which is something Allunova has stated that he/she does not want.

2. By releasing the expansion pack as only purchasable using real money, OOO mitigates the increase in CE demand and keeps CE prices under control.

There are valid reasons for OOO to release the expansion pack as only purchasable using real money. It is not "totally wrong" and no matter how OOO released it, they would have upset some segment of the population.

Sat, 03/03/2012 - 08:29
#49
Lordnamechange's picture
Lordnamechange
its 4 dollers

is it so bad its 4 dollars get off sk for 2 hours and mow you neighbors lawn ask for 5 buck congrats ohh wait its raising in price right to 6 dollars hopefully you have more than 1 neighbor

Sat, 03/03/2012 - 08:29
#50
Lordnamechange's picture
Lordnamechange
its 4 dollers

is it so bad its 4 dollars get off sk for 2 hours and mow you neighbors lawn ask for 5 buck congrats ohh wait its raising in price right to 6 dollars hopefully you have more than 1 neighbor

  • 1
  • 2
  • next ›
  • last »
Powered by Drupal, an open source content management system