Personally, I would rather play Wakfu.

The fighting is completely strategy/intelligence based, they have production skills to literally make your own equipment and cook restorative and buffing foods, probably the best compensation and customer support I have experienced, they want their classes to be balanced and take suggestions from the players directly to the table, thirteen classes (one is in preview, another is on its way in another few months), wide variation in players (people play different classes, not all in one or certain classes; nearly all classes are well represented in population), huge incentives to play in teams; I could go on for a while.

Not saying anything is wrong with those games, never played any of them and have no reason to judge, but since the thread is about recommending games I thought people should at least know.