Forums › English Language Forums › General › New Recruits

Search

Why isn't the Winmillion popular? What is bad about it?

34 replies [Last post]
Sat, 04/30/2011 - 14:57
Jalok's picture
Jalok

I don't understand why people dislike the Winmillion so much? Is it because they don't know how to use it? They don't like the looks of it? They don't play enough Twitchy-Based shooters to enjoy it properly? What?!

What is with players always go with the slow swords of the "nooby" Avenger and Faust? How come they are so popular? Yeah, they are powerful. But they are very slow and maneuverability is very bad.

The reason why I brought this topic up is because I want to sell my 2nd winmillion. It was dumb of me to buy another Winmillion thinking there would be a duel wielding option at some point in Spiral Knights. But I have doubts, and I don't think its going to happen. But that is not the point here! Even if I can't sell my 2nd Winmillion. I just want to understand why people always goes with the "slow" Sealed-Sword series, and why its so popular?

Also, I used the Sealed-Sword series before. It is awful because of maneuverability. Bad investment on my part. =( That is why I wanted to got rid of that Faust and I sold it for 19k! Not only I made a bad investment, but I sold the sword with a low price not thinking! I had to get rid of that awful sword so badly, that I didn't want to think of the profit! That is how much I absolutely hate the sealed-sword series.

.....

Sat, 04/30/2011 - 15:10
#1
SimularMine
Legacy Username
People like the sealed-sword

People like the sealed-sword series (try saying that five times fast!) is that, not only does it do excellent damage and wide reach, it also does either elemental or shadow damage, depending on which one you choose (also; keep in mind that until the update, Faust and Gran Faust were the only swords in the game to do good shadow damage (also also; Curse is nice, Gran Faust has it in spades)).

And by the way, maneuverability is not horrible with the series, just don't use the 3-hit combo _all_ the time. As a Leviathan Blade user currently, I'm personally not a fan of the slow combo, but I can see why people do like the swords.

And to answer your first question, Winmillion only goes up to 4-star range, some enemies go into guard-mode due to the projectile if you're out of slash range, it's charge attack is just plain awful, and a good amount of people are not fans of the forward momentum the Winmillion's combo grants it.

Sat, 04/30/2011 - 16:08
#2
Jalok's picture
Jalok
See! I knew it! Most people

See! I knew it! Most people doesn't know how to properly and effectively use a Winmillion!

- When enemies dodge (Like the wolves), you have to treat them like they are sheep! Herd them to a corner and take them out! Plus the best thing about it, is that you can scare the wolfys and prevent them from attacking you when you swing those projectiles at them in sticky situations.
- As for the Special attack, I think it is pretty decent. Not awesome, but decent. It is just that the animations are a little too slow. I think if it was sped up a bit. It would work. But so far, I use the special attack every now and then.
+ If 3-Rings ever makes a 5* Spur Sword, maybe the power up attack could be a tornado that suck up enemies and then knock them back with the strike of the sword, and 4 projectiles fly out of the tornado in all different directions! (The Mecha Nights has something similar to this. When they spin around, they drop 4 bombs or shoot 4 projectiles.)

Sat, 04/30/2011 - 21:32
#3
Senshi
Legacy Username
Yeah... uh...

In T3 wolves don't herd into the corner, they teleport behind you. Pop-pop-growl-bite.

The special is terrible compared to Leviathan or Avenger. Faust's special has its own problems, but is powerful... if you have remedy caps onhand for when the power hits back.

If a spur sword had a 360 charge attack that'd be a lot better, with or without the 4 projectiles, but I don't see it happening. 360 is a calibur-line specialty so far.

And my particular peeve about the movement of spur swords is that the -first slash- moves you. This is very annoying in spike-grids and thornbush mazes, places where you really do want to hold still as you slash.

Sat, 04/30/2011 - 21:51
#4
Hazel's picture
Hazel
Posting in a Matoro thread

Posting in a Matoro thread where no one is familiar with Matoro.

Sat, 04/30/2011 - 22:57
#5
SimularMine
Legacy Username
Matoro be trollan? Probably,

Matoro be trollan?

Probably, but Winmillion still remains pretty garbage in comparison to the big boys (Sealed-Swords, Levi, Dread Venom etc)

Sat, 04/30/2011 - 23:05
#6
Hazel's picture
Hazel
Matoro is either a troll or

Matoro is either a troll or just someone that is unfortunately slow.

Either way, best to disregard his posts. The Winmillion and its entire family is tragically useless. It's fun to use up until Winmillion, but the projectiles make it worthless; if the 5-star(should it ever exist) ditches the projectiles and adds something else in their place, it could be a viable weapon.

Sun, 05/01/2011 - 22:43
#7
Ecliptic's picture
Ecliptic
Are people just completely

Are people just completely forgetting Winmillion's bonus v. blocks and minerals? Take out minerals and stone blocks in 2 swings! That kind of convenience and time-saving is worth anything in my book.

But seriously I use a Winmillion, because I am only up to T2 and the weapon hasn't become useless to me yet. I understand perfectly well that other weapons are better, and that I will need them come T3, but for now I have fun with my quirky Link-with-full-health sword powers.

I must say though, that even in the peaceful realm that is floors 9-17, that damn special attack is utterly worthless.

Mon, 05/02/2011 - 13:36
#8
Jalok's picture
Jalok
@ Ecliptic

The special attack takes some time in getting used to. You need the right timing and right position, and it'll be good.

When you charge up your attack and release your large disc projectile, quickly slash 2 times! But don't slash quick too early or the projectile wouldn't fly out of the sword (uh, that was worded weird! Lol!). It would do really massive damage!

Mon, 05/02/2011 - 14:56
#9
Kawaii_Desu
Legacy Username
Winmillion is awful. And this

Winmillion is awful.

And this is coming from someone that's used it and has more experience with it than Mataro could ever hope to accomplish.

1. Its lunge combo is a GREAT way to get yourself killed if used wrong, and several Spur users happen to get themselves killed alot because of this.
2. Its charge attack is godawful. The projectile is slow, the windup speed is slow, enemies will dodge, damage output is mediocre.
3. Its damage output is somewhat similar to a Vile Striker, but VS has a superior charge and poison status. Plus it goes to 5*.
4. The projectiles shot out EVERY slash makes enemies use their defensive maneuvers. Slimes, most fiends and construct, and Chromalisks lack such defenses, but the damage from the projectile does not make constant dodging from enemies worth it. As a result, Winmillion lacks cornering abilities.
5. It was nerfed. At one point it was the absolute king of DPS (when the Cutter series was severly nerfed) because the damage bar was comparable to that of a Troika and even the Leviathan Blade. It is totally biased but the damage output now is just meh.

Tue, 05/03/2011 - 16:57
#10
fireflower22
Legacy Username
A quick question...

This is only semi-related, but as someone who's been playing casually and hasn't gotten into T3 yet, I thought I'd ask anyway.

Is it necessary to use charge attacks in the later floors? Up until now, I haven't really cared about charge attacks and how good/bad they are, because I never use them. Either I'm too busy shielding/dodging to bother charging, or I'm worried about staying alive and don't think about charge attacks at all. I use the Calibur line primarily, and a lot of my playstyle is due to spending 99% of my Clockworks time as part of a duo. (other person uses the Cutter line) So running around in circles long enough to charge isn't something I generally do. Is that going to be a problem in Tier 3? Are charge attacks a 'depends on playstyle' thing, or a 'master it if you want to live' sort of thing? (For Sword/Gun users, anyway)

Also, on a slightly different note: For a sword user who would like a change of pace from 'Calibur-style all day everyday', even if it could only be used in T1-T2, what options are out there? I'd like an alternate sword to have fun with on non-boss runs in the earlier levels. Is the Flourish line decent? Brandish? I never hear about anything on the forums other than Sealed Sword, Cutter, and Calibur families...is it possible that they're the only swords that are enjoyable to use? (I still plan to use my Calibur, but the idea of using it non-stop all the way to the core when I've used it so long without a break...it just doesn't sound like fun to me. And it kills any hopes of having collecting/experimenting with other weapons as something to do once I hit the current content wall.)

Tue, 05/03/2011 - 19:24
#11
Espeonage's picture
Espeonage
@fireflower

Charge attacks.
In Tier 1, arguably not so useful, maybe too time-consuming for that difficulty.
Tier 2, they have good use, can be great for getting that first attack/burst damage when that switch is activated, and may have viable utility now.
Tier 3; almost entirely useful.

Most, if not all things, should be doable without charge attacks.
But in Tier 3, you could say it's more the latter.

The Calibur series has a great utility of a charge, having a strong 360 slash with great knockback.
Perhaps you might not need it now, but it will prove true an asset later.
___________________________

Brandish is similar to the Calibur line, but the series now has explosive charge attacks, akin to a Retrode beam. Damage is well, and does Elemental/Shadow along with Normal, depending on your upgrade path.

Flourish is about average pre-4*, but the charge attack gives nice damage. The swordplay complements its strengths, 'catching' those its damage-type is good against, since Wolvers and Devilites move about much. It's also well for pushing out Silkwings.
I enjoy using the charge against Gremlins.
Could be fun.

Sealed Sword series is like the Troika line - slower swing speeds and a 2-hit combo. This can be made into one of what are agreeably the two strongest/best swords in the game, Divine Avenger and Gran Faust. Could be a thing, but more of a bring-to-endgame.

Cutter series can be fun. You've been seeing the swordplay, so I won't describe it. Just go with Vile Striker if you ever carry one further.

Wed, 05/04/2011 - 13:50
#12
King-Tinkinzar's picture
King-Tinkinzar
Because it sucks in Tier 3.

Because it sucks in Tier 3. Teleporting Wolvers....

Wed, 05/04/2011 - 19:09
#13
Jalok's picture
Jalok
Don't dis the Winmillion

Actually I find it really useful in Tier 3, even if there is teleporting wolvers regardless. The trick in killing the wolvers efficiently with a winmillion is by 3 things.
1.) Wait till they start to bark. Hit them!!
2.) Herd the wolfys in a corner by throwing random projectiles accordingly. If you do it right, the wolvers should get caught in the corner and would be stuck there. Not only they would be stuck on a corner teleporting at the same place, but they wouldn't be able to bite you!
3.) Throw a couple of projectiles (with the winmillion or gun) to tease them. When the time is right, STRIKE!

Jeeze! Really? I am guessing that you guys never really tried out the winmillion! You probably tried it out once and said, "Oh, this is to hard! I'm going to give up! I hate this weapon!" If you couldn't kill wolfys using projectiles, that means you couldn't kill devil-its too! They actually throw projectiles at YOU! Also one little tip. Turn off Auto-Target Lock! It would make things whole lot easier!
The game can't hold your hands all the time! The whole point of a game is to make it challenging and fun! (Maybe that is why I find a couple of threads where Faust/Avenger users find this game boring and shallow after a month of playing it. Because they don't challenge themselves with alien weapons!) Personally, I am still waiting for a Tier 4 difficulty! What I like about the Winmillion is that it is not only beastly if you use it the right way, but at the time it makes the game more challenging! It is a great mix between difficulty and a sense of accomplishment. :)

For Example:
If you played a lot of Twitchy-Based shooters, it is all about predicting where your enemy is going to be running too so you can shoot them ahead of time since the projectiles on the guns are so slow! When you carry over this tactic in SK using the winmillion, it makes a whole lot easier! (Tip repeated again:)You throw a couple of projectiles to tease the dodging enemies, and when the time is right you go strike them!

---

I really hope someday, 3-Rings would release a 5* sword in the spur line.

---

Wed, 05/04/2011 - 21:42
#14
Espeonage's picture
Espeonage
The 'herding' tactic is great and all,

and can be done in Tier 2,

but Tier 3 is a different.
The Wolvers will try to teleport to your flank, behind you, rather than constantly strafe to the sides. You can't really "tease" them with projectiles, since they will stay on the offensive and poof about.

Wed, 05/04/2011 - 22:03
#15
Crawdaunt
Legacy Username
I don't understand why people

I don't understand why people dislike the Proto Sword so much? Is it because they don't know how to use it? They don't like the looks of it? They don't play enough Korean MMOs to enjoy it properly? What?!

What is with players always go with the fast swords of the "nooby" Winmillion series? How come they are so popular? Yeah, they are fast. But they are terrible with combos and the forward momentum is very bad.

The reason why I brought this topic up is because I want to delete my 2nd character. It was dumb of me to create another character thinking there would be an option to use all your characters' Proto Swords simultaneously at some point in Spiral Knights. But I have doubts, and I don't think its going to happen. But that is not the point here! Even if I can't delete my 2nd character. I just want to understand why people always goes with the "fast" Winmillion series, and why its so popular?

Also, I used the Winmillion series before. It is awful because of its derpy projectile. Bad investment on my part. =( That is why I wanted to got rid of that Arc Razor and I sold it for absolutely nothing! Not only I made a bad investment, but I sold the sword with no price not thinking! I had to get rid of that awful sword so badly, that I didn't want to think of the profit! That is the story of how I became a Super Saiyan.

Wed, 05/04/2011 - 23:22
#16
Jalok's picture
Jalok
I miss the proto swords too!

Come to think about it! I need a new challenge! Time to downgrade! ^_^

Thu, 05/05/2011 - 02:15
#17
Njthug's picture
Njthug
Hope this helps

I don't understand why people dislike the Winmillion so much? Is it because they don't know how to use it? They don't like the looks of it? They don't play enough Twitchy-Based shooters to enjoy it properly? What?!

What is with players always go with the slow swords of the "nooby" Avenger and Faust? How come they are so popular? Yeah, they are powerful. But they are very slow and maneuverability is very bad.

The reason why I brought this topic up is because I want to sell my 2nd winmillion. It was dumb of me to buy another Winmillion thinking there would be a duel wielding option at some point in Spiral Knights. But I have doubts, and I don't think its going to happen. But that is not the point here! Even if I can't sell my 2nd Winmillion. I just want to understand why people always goes with the "slow" Sealed-Sword series, and why its so popular?

Also, I used the Sealed-Sword series before. It is awful because of maneuverability. Bad investment on my part. =( That is why I wanted to got rid of that Faust and I sold it for 19k! Not only I made a bad investment, but I sold the sword with a low price not thinking! I had to get rid of that awful sword so badly, that I didn't want to think of the profit! That is how much I absolutely hate the sealed-sword series.

^Thats what you posted since its many questions in one I will try to break it down question by question best I can.

I don't understand why people dislike the Winmillion so much? This question is well honestly hard to answer many people have dislikes such as the stats, does not come with given bonus they like ( Damage vs undead) it only goes up to 4*. The speed factor may make it hard to control does push you up a little (Extra step or two when using it). Like I said from the start everyone has his or her dislikes and likes hard to pin-point them all.

Is it because they don't know how to use it? I do think its not because of this most players may tend to not use a weapon they dont feel comfortable with thats my whole view. I hate the whole cutter series since well its hard for me to use it in mob-controlling thus I tend not to use my wild hunting blade.

They don't like the looks of it? This may be another reason which goes with your first question...like I said players are all different hard to pin-point it.

They don't play enough Twitchy-Based shooters to enjoy it properly? Not sure...you can try to take a random sample of about 200 to 500 players and ask them to find out I guess.

What is with players always go with the slow swords of the "nooby" Avenger and Faust? Well, lets break this down in my view why people pick these two swords are the following:

1. The Look
2. The Power they have
3. Graun Faust - Works well against Slimes and Gremlins
4. Divine Avenger - Works well construct and undead
5. The Divine Avenger - has a great charge attack
6. Graun Faust - can curse opponents which is handy
7. Most players are able to control this sword line easily (easy to use)
8. Many more...

Basically in my view these two swords are slow, but can get the job done and well covers you against 4 types of monsters which is pretty handy.

These swords are slower, but you can always fix that by wearing certain armors and obtaining certain uv's on the swords, and well its worth the price to some to have an avenger or faust series sword only because it makes solo'ing pretty easy.

Also, I used the Sealed-Sword series before. It is awful because of maneuverability. Bad investment on my part. =( That is why I wanted to got rid of that Faust and I sold it for 19k! Not only I made a bad investment, but I sold the sword with a low price not thinking! I had to get rid of that awful sword so badly, that I didn't want to think of the profit! That is how much I absolutely hate the sealed-sword series.
^ With this said:

Like I tell many players the challenge is to find the set-up what works for you. Not every player is alike. The best example I can think of is how I have friends who can not handle gremlins, but can handle slime, fiends, and beasts class monsters so easily. So what they do is have great defense stats against gremlins and well make sure their weapons are strong against them as well. Many of the players from preview saw or attempted to play with the gear in game and already have an idea what armor set (or mix) works for them which swords, guns, and bombs they work well with. The Sealed sword line was horrible for you, but it just does not match your playing style...so I guess you just need to figure out a sword that does thats the most I can suggest. Just keep in mind what works for you may not work for everyone else (Vice-Versa)

Well I hope that helps you =)

Thu, 05/05/2011 - 14:24
#18
DragnHntr
Legacy Username
hmmm

Winmillion...

Thu, 05/05/2011 - 16:57
#19
Jalok's picture
Jalok
Thanks Njthug

Thank you for a reasonable honest answer that actually answers my question about why many people doesn't like the Winmillion. Unlike these other idiots who posted on this topic.

*Matoro makes a rude gesture towards Hazel, SimularMine, Kawaii_Desu, DarthLOL and Crawdaunt* <_<

Sat, 05/07/2011 - 14:10
#20
bodines1
Legacy Username
" Also, I used the

"
Also, I used the Sealed-Sword series before. It is awful because of maneuverability. Bad investment on my part. =( That is why I wanted to got rid of that Faust and I sold it for 19k! Not only I made a bad investment, but I sold the sword with a low price not thinking! I had to get rid of that awful sword so badly, that I didn't want to think of the profit! That is how much I absolutely hate the sealed-sword series.
"

So you got the faust, used it, and then sold it? Nice trick. Also, if you think that the DA and GA are incredibly slow, you probably aren't using them right.

Oh, and Crawdaunt, LOL

Sun, 05/15/2011 - 10:40
#21
SubXer0
Legacy Username
Possible Level 5*?

What i think that would make it more popular is a five star version of the Winmillion.
If it could pack a better punch with the same cool look i think it would be a great sword.

It seems they could update alot of other swords and handguns.

Tue, 07/12/2011 - 18:27
#22
Olajdzija
i use the khorovod

khorovod's speed may be the lowest sword speed in all the game but the reach and damage are great

Sat, 08/13/2011 - 04:55
#23
yjun73
Legacy Username
its awesome!!

just look at it the only sword that does ranged damage while using normal attacks!!!!!!!!!

Sat, 08/13/2011 - 14:44
#24
RayND
Legacy Username
I demand elemental, piercing,

I demand elemental, piercing, and shadow damage Proto Swords!

Sat, 08/13/2011 - 14:59
#25
Bigfootm's picture
Bigfootm
Why did you bump this dead

Why did you bump this dead thread...

Mon, 08/15/2011 - 08:54
#26
Memento
Legacy Username
it has no 5* version.

it has no 5* version.

Tue, 08/16/2011 - 16:59
#27
Thirdmotion's picture
Thirdmotion
*Face Palm*

We know it has no 5* version, people mentioned it in this very thread ... 5 months ago!
Although reading Crawdaunt's post, made reading this old thread worthwhile.

Tue, 08/16/2011 - 19:02
#28
Zxeroadvent's picture
Zxeroadvent
I actually have to disagree

I actually have to disagree with the first statement you said about the Faust. i am a faust user (gran faust that is) and i am actually looked down on by some Divine avenger Users. from my experience, Faust isnt all that popular. but i still love it. however, the only reason i can think why winmillion may not be popular is its 4* limit. other than that, it looks like a good sword, but its just not my type. also, with the "bad manuver" i have to say ive grown used to my fausts speed, and i still love it. i do just fine. as far as DA, its much slower than Faust (based on statistics). TBH i cant see myself trading in my Faust for a DA or any ol' sword. it has a throne next to my cold iron Vanquisher. and as much as id love to see a tornado suck in enemies, i still think that it wouldnt be that awesome, because thats what the Gravitron bomb and electron bomb is for... (i also use electron charge lol) cool idea, but i still think Gran faust is one of the best swords in the game.

Thu, 08/18/2011 - 02:11
#29
Selenthon's picture
Selenthon
@Njthug

For the low attack speeds of DA/Gf just use ASI trinkets from Krogomo crafting thing

Thu, 08/18/2011 - 09:08
#30
Thirdmotion's picture
Thirdmotion
@selenthon

*Double Face Palm*

His post was before krogmo was even implemented...

Sat, 08/20/2011 - 13:13
#31
Twiddle's picture
Twiddle
Four reasons

There are four reasons why people don't like the Winmillion:

1) The Winmillion moves you forward on every attack. You can use this to your advantage, but it can also land you in traps or in a bad position if you are not careful.

2) The Winmillion shoots bullets on every swing. This causes some enemies (like wolvers and develites) to dodge whenever you attack, and that makes it harder for any sword specialists in your group.

3) People like 5* equipment, and the Winmillion has no 5* form (yet.)

4) The Winmillion's charge attack is not that great. It shoots a large bullet in front of you. The bullet can go though enemies. But if you really want to shoot bullets then you should take a gun. When using swords you are better off with an attack that will knock the enemy back or knock the enemy down, and the Winmillion does neither.

I've never used the Winmilliion myself, but I plan to eventually. I have used lower * versions of the Winmillion. After using the spur for a while, I got used to the playstyle. I enjoy it. It's easier to dance around the room when every attack makes you move. It took me some time to readjust to using regular swords again. Still, I can see why people don't like the sword line. In my opinion the line's biggest weakness is it's charge attack. It looks cool, but its not as useful as the charge attacks from other sword lines.

Sat, 08/20/2011 - 13:15
#32
Twiddle's picture
Twiddle
His post was before krogmo

His post was before krogmo was even implemented...

Lol whoops. Oh well, live and learn. (=

Sun, 08/21/2011 - 11:24
#33
Orangeo's picture
Orangeo
CLEAR -BZZT- the only good

CLEAR -BZZT-
the only good thing about winmillion is that full wolver set players can use it instead of a gun to make better use of their bonuses. like how bombers use crystal bomb. that is all.
(thread dies)

Mon, 08/22/2011 - 11:29
#34
Random-Thing
erm... fail OP

1) Heavy swords have some technique to using them well, and if you do they have the highest DPS of any weapon in the game, not to mention the enhanced defensive ability due to attack-canceling opponents, I made it through a T2 arena solo without even being hit using just a GF and DA, so if you think manoverability is bad then an eye test may be needed.

2) Winmillion has the lowest DPS of any sword of its tier in the game unless the projectile and slash both hit, in which case it still has low DPS for it's tier.... much lower than the equivalent heavy swords :P

*EDIT* sorry to keep this pathetic thread alive :P

Powered by Drupal, an open source content management system