Forums › English Language Forums › General › Suggestions

Search

Constructive Criticism

2 replies [Last post]
Thu, 08/09/2012 - 18:39
Purpureum's picture
Purpureum

GENERAL

ENERGY
An economy based entirely off of micro-transactions, yeah, can't tell why that isn't working.

LOCKDOWN
PROBLEM: There is virtually no balancing whatsoever, only a few weapons can even be used if one has ANY hope of beating the opposing team. As it stands, the game might as well automatically provide them with a Divine Avenger, Gran Faust, Final Flourish along with full Skolver, Vog Cub, Snarbolax. Because if you want to have any hope of winning, that's what you NEED to use.
SOLUTION: I really would like to see the player be able to choose their equipment, but unless some weapons are temporarily nerfed for the duration of a Lockdown match, that is simply not possible.

LOCKDOWN CLASSES
PROBLEM: Striker completely outclasses both Guardian and Recon. Strikers are able to practically 1-hit any other class, and pursue someone from across the map without breaking their shield. Guardians shields are as thick as paper, and the healing ability is negligible at best. Recons invisibility is given away by the constant pulsing of the cloak, and the death mark is practically unnoticeable.
SOLUTION: Lower the damage bonus and speed increase to low on Strikers. On Guardians, Make their shields actually worthy of being called shields, and speed up the healing effect. On Recons, add the ability to turn off the pulses, and have the death mark truly act as though it is the mark of death.

MISSIONS
PROBLEM: These have completely rendered the Arcade obsolete, and give players no reason to do random elevators in the arcade.
SOLUTION: Perhaps the Arcade and Missions could be combined. Say, if one were to have a mission where they needed to do a particular floor (let us use candlestick keep as an example) then one will have all the candlestick keeps in a particular stratum glow (or something) on the gate map, telling that person that they would need to get to that floor and complete it.

HALL OF HEROES
PROBLEM: The recipe economy has been driven into the ground.
SOLUTION: Unfortunately, the damage has already been done. The only way I see of reversing this, is to delete everyone's learned recipes, and getting rid of the Hall of Heroes altogether. Maybe change it to a “weapon/armor-demonstrations” area instead of an “economic calamity.”

TREASURE VAULTS / GRAVEYARDS
Problem: Treasure Vaults really don't give very much, whereas Graveyards give significantly more.
Solution: Make people WANT to get a Treasure Vault, and make them FEAR Graveyards. Try using the danger room reward rooms as a basis for Treasure Vaults, and have Graveyards' difficulty buffed, while also reducing the crown and heat output.

WEAPONS

STATUS EFFECTS
PROBLEM: For the most part, only elemental weapons cause status effects.
SOLUTION: Make more shadow weapons inflict curse, and maybe poison. Then give piercing weapons something.

SWORDS

SPUR SERIES
PROBLEM: The weapon is virtually useless.
SOLUTION: Maybe have each regular swing send out a flurry of disks, then just buff the charge to a reasonable point.
NOTE: This could also use a 5*.

TROIKA SERIES
PROBLEM: There is not much incentive to use the regular combo, and the charge leaves the player incredibly vulnerable, still without much incentive.
SOLUTION: Have all attacks do MUCH more damage, and maybe give the charge attack a 100% chance of causing its respective status effect.
NOTE: The other variants could do different forms of damage.

FAUST SERIES
PROBLEM: Charge attack can self-inflict Curse
SOLUTION: Get rid of that. Having the charge attack self-inflict anything doesn't nerf the weapon, it just makes the charge attack worthless. Maybe just lower the frequency of cursing enemies if you want to nerf it THAT badly.

FLAME OF VOG – See, faust and replace “curse” with “fire.”

HANDGUNS

BLACKHAWN SERIES
PROBLEM: The damage bonus seems a little misplaced, as guns are almost completely useless versus any type of gremlin.
SOLUTION: Change it to jellies instead.

MAGNUS SERIES
PROBLEM: The combination of; recoil, not being able to move, and a 2-shot clip make this a very bad gun type.
SOLUTION: Get rid of the “not able to move,” and make it say, a 3-shot clip with a slow rate of fire.

BOMBS

CRYSTAL BOMB SERIES
Pretty solid work OOO, I didn't really have a solution to the old crystal bombs, but they definitely did have a problem. As it stands, the update was incredibly good for the status of these bombs.

GRAVITON / ELECTRON SERIES
PROBLEM: When charging up the bomb, it slows the player down to a snails-pace.
SOLUTION: There really is no reason to have that, so get rid of it. If you really want to slow something down, maybe just increase the fuse time or something.

ARMOR

WOLVER SERIES
PROBLEM: The incredible defensive capabilities and offensive bonuses completely out-class any other types of armor.
SOLUTION: Toning down the offensive bonuses is a must. Along with that, the defensive capabilities must also be toned down. If someone wants to have a sword damage bonus, they better be prepared to risk a lot of health.

DRAKE SCALE / CHROMA / VALKYRIE SERIES
PROBLEM: These armor sets' bonuses are completely eclipsed by the wolver sets.
SOLUTION: Make the set bonuses for the 5* sets a damage bonus maximum.

CIRCUIT BREAKER / EMBERBREAK / FROSTBREAKER SERIES
These armor sets definitely need 4* and 5* sets

QUICKSILVER SERIES – ***BIAS ALERT***
I believe this should have an attack speed increase added, and for the movement speed increase set bonus for mercurial armor raised to maximum (medium only adds 8%, which might sound nice, but it is almost unnoticeable).

SHIELDS

BRISTLING SERIES
PROBLEM: The shields have pretty good defenses and health for their * level, but IMMENSE attack bonuses.
SOLUTION: Either tone down the attack bonuses, or drastically reduce the defensive capabilities. Actually no, do both.
NOTE: Just look at the swiftstrike, try and make it like that.

SWIFTSTRIKE – ***BIAS ALERT***
I believe this could do with a 4* and 5* upgrade

tl;dr Well, that's you're problem.

Thu, 08/09/2012 - 18:50
#1
Aplauses's picture
Aplauses

As it stands, the game might as well automatically provide them with a Divine Avenger, Gran Faust, Final Flourish along with full Skolver, Vog Cub, Snarbolax. Because if you want to have any hope of winning, that's what you NEED to use.
>You know right? I only use Royal Jelly Set and Leviathan Blade. Didn't have any problem? I still get 10k damage or above. Fail you.

As guns are almost completely useless versus any type of gremlin.
> Again, fail you. It is not useless. Can't you see there's a gremlin theme expansion mission? Ohh i get it.. You want to change it to jelly so you can make the JK a lot easier.

Swiftstrike Buckler. I believe this could do with a 4* and 5* upgrade
> To make it 4 or 5 star line is ridiculous and overpowered because of it's bonus.

MOST OF ALL. The only one that I agree on this thread is the Troika and Spur buff. The other is just meaningless buff.

Fri, 08/10/2012 - 01:19
#2
Asukalan's picture
Asukalan
" I really would like to see

" I really would like to see the player be able to choose their equipment, but unless some weapons are temporarily nerfed for the duration of a Lockdown match, that is simply not possible. "

Not possible, if current most used weapons will be nerfed then players will find new 'most popular' weapons and once again you will complain that now the most usuall set for LD is and demand to nerf those weapons to balance LD.

"PROBLEM: Striker completely outclasses both Guardian and Recon. "

Do we play same game? If you think striker outclasses all other classes you didnt play LD enough or you just didnt bothered to try other classes, and by try i didnt mean quip them till first death and then crawl back to striker.

"PROBLEM: These have completely rendered the Arcade obsolete, and give players no reason to do random elevators in the arcade."

Problem exist, solution must be found. One can be limit missions to 1 per player or make them drop like twice less crowns for a player who already did them. This way they wont be spammable and still players will can help others to did them even if they completed them.

"PROBLEM: The recipe economy has been driven into the ground."

True to that, Soultion is to make HoH accesable only once, so it will be like one in a lifetime chance to buy recipes you wish instead of ' oh i need recipe, to the HOH' or make it only a show room where you can see all weapons.

"Problem: Treasure Vaults really don't give very much, whereas Graveyards give significantly more."

Yeah, treasure valuts have very little in common with actual treasures, energy gates there make them more pathetic. Other way to make people WANT treasure valuts is to replace graveyards with candlesticks. Im sure people fear Grimalkins more than silly phantoms.

"FAUST SERIES
PROBLEM: Charge attack can self-inflict Curse"

Curse is powerfull status, self inflict curse that happens very rare is not a problem.

Flame of Vog -> Fang of Vog, same as above. Those whole 2 poitns are just silly

To sum up, based on what you wrote there, you look like someone very new to game with litle to no experience.

Powered by Drupal, an open source content management system