Every time you kick someone because they have a quality you do not like (no inspect, odd set, 'wrong' armor, looking too fly) that does not drastically or even minimally reduce their effectiveness as a team component, you are killing the game for yourself and your future enjoyment/ability to get pick up groups will be limited, because these people will remember your name and will join groups that respect them, leaving you to wade through levels alone or with people that are less experienced.
Be respectful, please. people don't -have- to play with you. Allow them when they chose to, especially if you need them.
Getting a kick from me is as rare as finding a Darkfang Shield.
all of us were once noobs. I say "give him a chance to prove himself" and if the guy messes up here and there, ill tell him what to do for future occasions.
(even though, there are some mean stubborn players that sadly, do have to go.)