I'm full of respect for current (soon old) game design to Three Rings, it is simple+useful and it is different. And as any good design it don't distract working/playing process.
New Ui design is a step back. As a designers you know that main thing of any design is usefulness.
1. The big image of player's knight on top left - what purpose of it, who needs to see his knight and rang all the time?
2. Shield bar - we can see shield health by checking it's colour.
3. Percent of health+Health bar.. maybe something one?
Overall new Ui remembers me some of RPG games from 99-05, and they wasn't great at all.
Cheap looking gradients, cheap icons.. one word - cheap. Like one of those korean games.
Ui is like great infographics, only main information without any heavy information.
The current "old" design have something close to clockworks, something from steampunk, and what about new UI? What pushed you to make it?
I can't say how useful the new design, but it is ugly, and that is enough. Old one is full of rounds (clockworks yeah), and new one is a mess from "squares", rounds and even rectangles.. what?
If you have taste (and you have it, OOO), just compare:
omgwhathaveidone
<3
ps. There is lots to say about new UI.
I love this game, I didn't play any other game for last 5+ years, because they was awful. Please, Three Rings, don't make Spiral Knights ugly.
What to do? As you can check, companies make rebranding from time to time, and they don't change their look at all, they looks like before but renewed at same time. For example Nivea, Apple, Google or even Starbucks.
As an example: current UI is a little bit ragged, it could be more smooth (I'm about squares on roundings)
And as I type before, UI size should be adjustable and with option to minimise.
I constantly update this message.
I dont like the top left picture and the pill/vial skin, maybe there should be option to remove / minimize it.
it's blocking so much vision. health bar of monster I like,
The picture on top left corner, doesn't do anything, thanks I know how I look like, I can do that pressing tab, I dont need a small sculpture there constantly reminding me of how i look like ._.