1. Why is the Argent Peacemaker quoted as "the best weapon for citadel"?
I personally hate the silversix, it's not super effective against anything and is super uneffective to a lot of things.
2. Why are shields with piercing resistance hated so much?
From what I've seen people hate piercing resistance. I think it would be useful, especially for jelly runs!
3. Why is the Wild Hunting Blade so bad?
I love my Hunting Blade and I'm planning on upgrading it. Never caused me any problems, I usually attack right through taking damage.
These are just a few things I've noticed, I think I forgot one. Please and Thank You for answering.
2: Things that deal piercing damage:
Floor Spikes
[Various Lichens]
Tortodrones
Floors spikes you should never get hit by and the only time I've ever been hit by Tortodrones is when I was shocked from something else. That leaves lichens, but those are pretty easy to dodge/block. If you're doing T2 runs, pretty much any 4/5* shield will have more enough health to last you anyways.
3. It's more that the DVS has greater utility. You trade a relatively minor damage boost to one type for poison. (And in this game, poison prevents healing, decreases damage done and increases damage taken.)