Forums › English Language Forums › General › Treasure Vault

Search

[NEW!] Role-Playing Council! Vote on it's members!

33 replies [Last post]
Wed, 10/23/2013 - 05:01
Topoyozariane's picture
Topoyozariane

Role-Playing Council. Post only proposals, or votes. Votes must be formal. Any other discussion will be conducted within Thinslayer's Roleplaying Discussion thread.

Link Here: http://forums.spiralknights.com/en/node/91450

Candidates for the Role-Playing Council!

-I will be updating this everytime someone votes-

Thinslayer: IIII

Topoyozariane (Me. xD):

Sandwich-Potato: III

Ultimaknightz:

Hexlash: III

Creeperlucario: I

Darkwatch:

Hearthstone:

Edolas:

Remiliaoftheearth:

---------------------

Feel free to nominate anyone else!

_______________

Wed, 10/23/2013 - 08:12
#1
Viorayne's picture
Viorayne
Vote.

I vote for Sandwich.

Wed, 10/23/2013 - 09:16
#2
Thinslayer's picture
Thinslayer
Tough choice!

Thinslayer: Can't vote for myself.
Topoyozariane: Undecided
Sandwich-Potato: A bit immature for my liking
Ultimaknightz: Writes well, cool-headed, but online-frequency is erratic. Also, pride+mod powers=problems.
Hexlash: Writes well, seems mature. Not online often enough for my liking.
Creeperlucario: Does not write well, and does not respond ideally to criticism.
Darkwatch: Does not write well, but seems quite mature.
Hearthstone: Writes well, seems mature. Not online often enough for my liking.

My strong experiences with Hexlash lead my to cast my vote for him.

Wed, 10/23/2013 - 09:35
#3
Creeperlucario's picture
Creeperlucario
...

I vote Sandwich-Potato and I don't know why I am on the list since Topo even put me and Dark as complains... So, me and dark shouldn't be on the list...

Wed, 10/23/2013 - 09:43
#4
Thinslayer's picture
Thinslayer
@Creeperlucario

You're on the list because you exist. :)

For the record, I'd seriously considered voting for Dark, and I toyed with voting for you, Lucario.

Wed, 10/23/2013 - 12:34
#5
Viorayne's picture
Viorayne
Im not on the list, which means...

I must be a figment of all your imaginations!

Wed, 10/23/2013 - 12:41
#6
Thinslayer's picture
Thinslayer
@Topoyozariane

Mind putting Edolas on the list, Topo?

Wed, 10/23/2013 - 14:50
#7
Hexlash's picture
Hexlash
Oh stop it you...

Thanks Thin! :)

To be honest, with the vast quantities of experience that Thinslayer has attained, not to mention his high knowledgeability, leadership qualities, ingenuity within a great variety of aspects, online consistency, punctuality and devotion to the creative literature, as well as those that create it, it would be foolhardy not to have him on the council automatically.

However, to honour the interests of democracy, I'm inclined to vote, and I vote for Thinslayer.

Can we vote for more than one candidate, though?

Wed, 10/23/2013 - 15:05
#8
Thinslayer's picture
Thinslayer
@Hexlash

I don't reckon it's a good idea to vote for more than one candidate, but I'm certainly not going to stop you, and we will still count it.

Wed, 10/23/2013 - 15:14
#9
Sandwich-Potato's picture
Sandwich-Potato
How does this election work?

Do we have, say, the top people with the most votes join the council? Or is it X campaigns, each one with one winner before the next one?

I like Edolas's (AKA the figment of our imagination) posts quite a bit, but I'm not very familiar with xyr (no offense) and xe might fluctuate in posting time occasionally. So thus, I cast my vote for Hexlash. However, since we can vote for multiple people, I'll vote for Thinslayer, though xe should default on the list anyways.

On another note, where's Remiliaoftheearth (as you stated that everyone who exists and participates is part of the voting thingy)?

Wed, 10/23/2013 - 15:45
#10
Topoyozariane's picture
Topoyozariane
Okie Dokie!

I will be putting both of the nominees on to the list.... AND.....

Honestly, we either need more voters, or we need to have people that vote more. xD

Wed, 10/23/2013 - 16:36
#11
Remiliaoftheearth's picture
Remiliaoftheearth

I vote for Thinslayer, for reasons already given by others, and for Sandwich-Potato, because.

(also, I got eaten by them Apocrea seven times, so I probably don't exist either, so I don't quite get why I'm up there :3)

Wed, 10/23/2013 - 16:39
#12
Darkwatck's picture
Darkwatck
Honsty

Well I will be frank, I have seen this kinda thing happen before and it leads to bad things. Back where I came from on the WoW RP world they tried something like this. But they called it RPC, and it made it to where the RPs became very similer, dead, and no one was wanting to experiment. Thus it is slowly dying and is in the final stages of people leaving. Some have converted over and made the change ajusting to the style that is not required of them.

My point is this, I agree but I dis agree. To have a system would mean that bias and the like would follow leading to blacklists just because you don't like something that some one is trying to fix. Or maybe a RP gets shut down because the par was not the best. ETC.

crass as I may be, I vote to Sustane: Let it stay as it is we really don't need it.

Wed, 10/23/2013 - 16:56
#13
Hexlash's picture
Hexlash

Anyone mind explaining what authority and power this council holds, its purpose, and responsibilities of those who are on it? :D

Just saying, something that has no purpose, has less existence than something like Edo, who apparently doesn't exist...

Wed, 10/23/2013 - 18:15
#14
Feline-Grenadier's picture
Feline-Grenadier

Voting for Hexlash.

Thinslayer, though as much as a good storywriter was he, has been getting a loose grip on his RP. That's just a short IMO, but I also have other reasons....

Wed, 10/23/2013 - 18:27
#15
Thinslayer's picture
Thinslayer
@Vinnydime

Good point...

What are the "other reasons?"

Wed, 10/23/2013 - 18:55
#16
Feline-Grenadier's picture
Feline-Grenadier
Also...

Controlling a bunch of people isn't hard, though you have to cut your rules VERY fine in an RP if the people you're catering to tend to assume wacky, inane, and outright overpowered things. Though the crowd here has certainly improved, they all too often break off on their own tangents and add whatever the heck they feel like to the story.

This is the problem that many GMs have, the lack of a self-controlled audience.

However, it's not a difficult thing to shut them up and tell them bluntly what to do, but I've only seen a few other players try to "guide" them, though they're too rough with their words and let their angst or whatever spite they have get the better of them.

I'm hoping that Hexlash will be firm, but not too harsh on our players.

That being said, I'd prefer if only Hex and Thin co-GM at this point, as both aren't too harsh and condescending towards their own players. However, I want to make sure that both can provide logical, well thought-out decisions. I want Thin to be there to create the content ((I'm going to be honest here, he can make good stories without making them sound too ridiculous and action-packed)) and supervise what can and cannot be done, while Hexlash makes sure that no one person can get out of hand.

I don't want to vote for Topoyozada because of his failure to guide players. Yes, you're more experienced than a tenderfoot in the ways of roleplaying, but I simply cannot trust you to solo GM or take any high-up positions without someone to help you. And though this may anger you, I don't want a GM who just can't keep up after a solid burst of roleplaying. Like you did with your last stories a long time ago, before you began to RP.

As for Sandwich-Potato, I am considering him, but given that I cannot make heads or tails of his writing at this point (my fault for not paying attention to him is the real reason xD), so I'll withhold the vote until I finish reading his past experiences.

Creeper, as fun as his ideas may seem, may be too centered around a few characters. Unless I've read a whole plot from him and how it'll come out, I'm not sure if he's going to be a GM. I simply don't KNOW him as an author.

Darkwatch, I'm also considering, as he seems to be fair, but if he's busy, I don't want to make him feel obligated for RPing.

Skye-Lightning has an erratic schedule. Better for him to keep up good grades and make his colorful, cheery characters than get him depressed over how is he going to keep up grades and an RP.

Edolas...erm...I dunno. Seemed invisible to me at times. Dang, I need to focus on more people XD.

Remiliaoftheearth seems like a person who might do well with a couple of first tries, but I don't wanna overwhelm her by pouring down a bunch of a players onto her lap.

As for me? I'm already busy, so that's a no-go.

Ultimaknightz? I forgot him XD

Thu, 10/24/2013 - 06:00
#17
Hearthstone's picture
Hearthstone

Hearthstone: Writes well, seems mature. Not online often enough for my liking. ~Thinslayer

True(second part, I mean) :P

Skye-Lightning has an erratic schedule. Better for him to keep up good grades and make his colorful, cheery characters than get him depressed over how is he going to keep up grades and an RP. ~Vinny

Yup :) The better I keep my grades up, the more time I have with my computer and the more time I can spend with others. :) Although I keep beating myself over and over again for not completing my fanfics anymore... I feel irresponsible(which I am).

~

( > ^w^)> Hugs?

~

Anyways... I'm trying to lean towards shipping(preferably Echo and Daxen) and practicing expressing things more clear and vivid. Any vote I make will go to Thin.

Thu, 10/24/2013 - 09:52
#18
Thinslayer's picture
Thinslayer
Amazon Prime of Life: 2-day relationshipping

Regarding shipping between Echo and Daxen, they're both NPCs, and as such are not available to players, so I can't promise to ship them. If the players are around them long enough, though, I might try it. ^_^

Also, hugs. :P

Thu, 10/24/2013 - 12:15
#19
Trolololololololoe's picture
Trolololololololoe
Uh...

Don't know who is on-line frequently or not except for 1 person. I vote for CreeperLucario

Thu, 10/24/2013 - 16:04
#20
Thinslayer's picture
Thinslayer
Current tally

Thinslayer: 4 votes
Hexlash: 3 votes
Sandwich-Potato: 3 votes
Creeperlucario: 1 vote
Sustane: 1 vote

Thu, 10/24/2013 - 15:38
#21
Darkwatck's picture
Darkwatck
@Thinslayer

you for got one. 1 to Sustane.

Thu, 10/24/2013 - 15:42
#22
Topoyozariane's picture
Topoyozariane
*Sniffles*

@Viinydime: OK. I think I know what you mean. You think I don't know how to control a band of RP-ers, I quit after every fan-fic I make, and I'm just *a little* better than a tenderfoot!

That is absolutely true.

But..... How 'bout your own fics, Vinny? You quit like.... half the number I started. xD

Anyways.....

*no one votes for me?* Go cries in a corner.

Thu, 10/24/2013 - 15:46
#23
Darkwatck's picture
Darkwatck
Truth

You asked for something and people are telling the Truth, or what they believe to be the Truth. And when that happens its going to hurt, all you can do is be a man and suck it up I suppose. Jokes aside my point stands, its going to hurt but at the end of the day we will all be better for it man.

Thu, 10/24/2013 - 15:48
#24
Topoyozariane's picture
Topoyozariane
Dude.

That was a joke. xD

Don't take it too seriously.

And a vote to abstain doesn't go on the list. xD

Thu, 10/24/2013 - 15:55
#25
Darkwatck's picture
Darkwatck
-

I sustaned, not abstained.

To sustane I am holding of my vote.

To abstain would be to not cast one.

Thu, 10/24/2013 - 17:36
#26
Isekuube's picture
Isekuube
Roleplay Derp. :3

Quick question. I was talking to Topo about this earlier, but I just have to ask: How is this relevant, I'll be completely honest with all of you, this just seems like a random made up position to boost egoes and frankly, will probably not last long. Of course, I could totally be wrong, this is a completely one-sided opinion. Topo informed me that this would... I guess pass or veto upcoming Roleplays? Honestly, I think if somebody would like to create an Roleplay then they should be able to make an idea, and have others help him/her create it and put life into it. Regardless, people are going to sign up for it. Whether you like it or not. In fact, I could go create an RP thread right now. You can't limit whether people can create something or not.

That was my complete and honest opinion, I by no means mean offence to any of you and have no personal grudge against any of you. But, this is what I think. If somebody could explain better then maybe I could be swayed to be neutral. Or perhaps even support this, but of course, it would be particularly hard to persuade me.

Thu, 10/24/2013 - 17:09
#27
Hexlash's picture
Hexlash

Still don't get the point of this thread :D

Thu, 10/24/2013 - 18:29
#28
Feline-Grenadier's picture
Feline-Grenadier
Well...

...the old Council that came up consisted of people who were decent-good at RPing. However, that disbanded after a few members got that power to their heads and tried to boss other RP makers like me around, and it collapsed after said members left.

We're trying to do the same thing here, though now that we're without those players who have hindered us in the past, we can create a formal RPing group that collaborate to create and play RPs. The council here with the voting just shows who do we prefer in this little group should be spearheading the effort.

No, they're not going to micromanage all roleplays that come and go here, but rather do so for their own RPs. That means I can still create an RP that isn't affiliated with them, and that's fine.

If I wish to work by their rules and play their RPs, then I can join their little group.

Thu, 10/24/2013 - 21:46
#29
Hearthstone's picture
Hearthstone

Lol, Thin, I meant in a fanfic somehow :P

I still don't know why I am included in this list...

Thu, 10/24/2013 - 21:52
#30
Feline-Grenadier's picture
Feline-Grenadier
:P

Why not Skye? XD

Thu, 10/24/2013 - 23:19
#31
Hearthstone's picture
Hearthstone

I don't know. I just feel like I shouldn't be on the list :P

Fri, 10/25/2013 - 17:36
#32
Ultimaknightz's picture
Ultimaknightz
Vinnydime has a valid

Vinnydime has a valid point.

Also, I've gotta prepare for my exams. So you won't be seeing me post here for a week or so. :P

Sat, 10/26/2013 - 13:21
#33
Granseal's picture
Granseal
Well I'm an upstart.

I don't know who to vote for but I will willingly throw my hat into the ring. I'm not the best but I'm no slouch either. However I will drop a vote for Thin.

Powered by Drupal, an open source content management system