I have the following gear that have different upgrade paths. I am not sure which one too choose from.
1. Tempered Calibur - Ascended Calibur or Cold Iron Carver
Personally, I prefer Ascended Calibur because of its higher damage to all monster but Cold Iron's bonus to undead is quite useful.
2. Dusker Coat/Cap - Skolver Coat/Cap or Vog Cub Coat/Cap
Skolver's defense against piercing is really useful on spikes but I think Vog Cub's resistance to fire is more useful than to ice.
3. Cutter - Vile Striker or Hunting Blade
Personally, I prefer Vile Striker because it causes poison.
4. Brandish - Nightblade or Fireburst or Iceburst
I prefer Fireburst because it causes fire which is useful but not Nightblade because I want to upgrade my Sealed Sword to Faust. Not Iceburst either
because I heard from a friend that it causes freeze only when charged.
5. Sealed Sword - Avenger or Faust
I think I will first upgrade to a Faust for farming Jellies and then get another Sealed Sword to upgrade to Avenger.
What do you guys think?
Cookie cutter - esque would be
Ascended
Vog
Vile Striker
Nightblade? (not really sure about this one actually)
Avenger
I believe thats the usual route - and "best" for firestorm citadel