Why do people have such a strong emotional investment in Spiral Knights? I don't mean this in an aggressive or even accusatory way. It's just something I've been thinking about for the past few hours.
It started when the Spiral Scientist himself, Zeddy, posted a topic about how Spiral Knights can never be a great game. At the time, I was reading the thread off my phone, so I couldn't make a big response as easily. When I got back to my dorm and opened up my laptop, I noticed Feyi-Feyi's response:
"I love how so much people feel almost directly attacked.
I think what you're all missing here is that all the things Zeddy is talking about have been know for a long, long, long time..."
Which made me think. Zeddy and Feyi are right, in that SK is definitely not the best game I've played. It's not even the best game I've played recently. In fact, I hardly play the game anymore. I find it boring, and grinding. Even the parts I used to love doing or even when I return to the game after several months, I still find myself bored of it. I've even grown to hate FSC so much that the mere thought of approaching that place makes me cringe. However, I still log onto the forums each day, read through the threads, and keep up with the new patches. When I first read Zeddy's thread, I had the same reaction that many other people had. I took offense, as if I had been personally attacked.
The only reason I can come up with is the amount of time I've spent playing the game and all the friends I've met in the game. I have over 1800 hours of playtime, as well as many amazing friends and guildmates. However, I could say the same about my middle school. I have many fond memories of the school, of my friends who I met there, and of the clubs activities that wasted so many of my lunch breaks. Yet I haven't given a hoot about that place in almost 5 years. Even when people criticize it, I don't respond as emotionally as I do when SK is attacked (unless the criticism is full of blatant lies).
So why is it that, when SK is criticized, people act as if they themselves have been criticized?
People don't like being told truths they don't like to admit.
Kinda similar to people saying something like "hey, I know I'm weird as heck, but don't bring to light that I'm weird".