This thread has gained a bit of attention, so I figured I'd make it more into a discussion than a question.

My idea: When a Love Puppy is found, one player of the party leaves, then the rest of the party kills the puppy, then the rest of the party joins the player who left, then one player leaves again, rest of the party kills the puppy, players join the player who left, and so on and so forth.

Other's ideas: At Heart of Ice or another location where gun puppies respawn, farm the Love Puppies that occasionally appear.

The question: Is this or any other Love Puppy Farming (True Love Locket Farming) possible?

What we know:

• It is possible to leave and have the rest of the party join you later on, but this only works once. After the first time, the party gets locked up.
• Love Puppies can appear on puppy respawners.

What we need to find out:

• Can Love Puppies on respawners drop trinkets?
• Does a Love Puppy change into a different gun puppy when you leave the lobby?
• Can a Love Puppy other than the original (the one generated after a player has left the lobby) drop a trinket?

Opinionated Question: If either of these methods work, are they an affective form of making money and/or retrieving 2 True Love Lockets for personal use?