Test Feedback: Individual Game Elements

20 replies [Last post]

Greetings Testers!

Please go join an adventure as part of The Watch in game and let us know your feedback. Specifically for this thread, we're looking for feedback on Individual Game Elements. In particular the items that are new within this area that you don't see in the current game.

  • Did you enjoy the new elements like Cranes, Karts, and volatile minerals?
  • Did you run into issues using one of these new elements?
  • Do you have suggestions for any of these new elements?
#1
I think the Karts are a…

I think the Karts are a wonderful addition and make navigating these larger tilesets so much more fun. The fact that you can ferry other Knights around the map adds a fun bit of team play, where you can essentially play taxi for other Knights completing different objectives, and the rails are neat little shortcuts exclusive to Kart usage.

However, specifically this is related to the big Kart and its related objective - There is a chance for you to get pinned between the big Kart and a wall after breaking it. This leaves you unable to move or attack (as your attack gets overridden by the interact prompt), and you're stuck there until people either fix and move the big Kart manually, or you decide to leave. Dying and sparking does not help move the Kart if you get trapped, which is admittedly an edge case, but still possible as the enemy can attempt to charge you with their Kart as you're attempting to break it and knock them off.

#2
Love the Karts

The Karts are great so far. I love using it to transport boxes or fellow knights, but aiming guns as a passenger at higher speeds or while turning is very difficult. If you add an HP bar of sorts to show how damaged the kart is, and a car horn for mischief and whimsy, then I think the small karts at least are close to perfect for the driver already.

The big kart can feel quite clunky to steer considering it doesn't have the ability to reverse. If you can give the big kart the ability to drive in reverse to get out of weird situations better it would make it feel much better to drive.

The crane is also really fun but only one knight gets to fully enjoy using it and has huge griefing potential, as well as this said knight missing out on all of the loot despite contributing to the team, especially when bringing boxes to the lift. Griefing could be combated, without making it less fun to use, by making more things respawn after some time, most notably loot blocks, vanish blocks and keys (as well as the gates they unlock).

Volatile minerals are interesting but having them get knocked off your back in one hit and breaking really easily is a bit too punishing in my opinion, making it much easier to just sit around where they spawn hoping to get a shiny one immediately. I do like the concept of using them to trade with basil or giving you a damage buff etc. at the forge, however the temporary 5* weapon from the forge feels a bit weird when everyone is locked into t1 damage.

#3
Very fun stuff

I have thoroughly enjoyed these elements. I like the vision of each one, and believe we could definitely add more to them.

The karts are great - I really like how the gremlins drive them around, and that they will take them back from you if you let them! As others have said, the teamwork element the karts provide is critical to the design of a social open world area, and the special kart-only paths can lead to some humorous situations where you need to call your own "uber".

As others said, the big kart is a bit of a wash - powering it up doesn't really do much to help your team despite how much effort it can take, and if it gets damaged in the wrong place, it can cause a lot of problems blocking paths or unfortunate knights. Making the vehicle split into pieces and lose collision when damaged would be one way to fix it, and then have minerals fuse it back together to a working condition. Either this, if it splits into 4 parts, you could load each piece up and bring it somewhere on the map to repair it. That would be a more enjoyable side objective, as powering up minerals can take a while and one hit loses out.

Speaking of the minerals, the volatile minerals are interesting. They're a new dungeon currency that you have to charge up. I like the idea in theory, but in practice, the minerals blowing up and falling off your back so often can be problematic. I like how they have combat utility and deal different statuses, so picking a certain mineral has a purpose, but perhaps the minerals could become stable at a certain point. If we could box up stable minerals to carry them around the level, that would make most interactions with NPCs that take minerals more accessible, and make minerals feel more fleshed out in this mode.

The crane is a lot of fun. I feel like we should have two cranes per level though, as one person being on crane duty is a lot of fun but not very rewarding loot-wise. Maybe the crane could collect loot like a player normally would, but scoop it all up into a client-sided baggie that they can then bring back to themselves to collect?

One thing I really enjoy is the fact that all fast travel options are based around team play. The karts can pick up and drop off players, the crane can pick players up in the lift and carry them around for reinforcements or general assistance. Candlestick Keep needs something like this as well - I think that lighting Candles should be able to act as fast travel points. If we need new props, just have new green candles that will instantly whisk you away to another green candle. I feel like all lit Candles as teleport points would be fine though, as that would make even the temporary candles fast travel points if a knight is near it.

One thing I feel like this mode could use is a return to health share revives. This mode is much more casual, and health share revives would bring the social aspect even closer together. Knight goes down? Drive over and revive them, or use the crane to pick them up and bring them to a knight who can revive them.

#4
Feedback on Individual Game Elements

+ Did you enjoy the new elements like Cranes, Karts, and volatile minerals?
Cranes and Carts are riotously good fun. The moment I saw the Carts especially I called up some discord friends to urge them to check them out - they're spectacular fun and the co-op opportunities reminded me of the good old days of Halo 3 and screwing about with rocket launchers on mongooses. The Crane is excellent, too - being shuttled around by one player keen to coordinate and streamline a Watch mission is not only fun but exciting too - and even getting trapped by a playful player looking to prank someone is kind of fun. Reinstancing addresses that problem neatly if it becomes an issue and a knight can't be picked up against their will, so it's not something I'd actually push to change. The only thing I would warn against is the fact that Cranes need no-go areas because circumventing treasure gates kind of defeats the purpose of the mission-based gameplay. I would like to emphasise that they should be used sparingly, though; it really is fun to play with. I'd actually quite like to see them in the arcade sometime, if in reduced capacity... And a Racing minigame better show up this time next year, that kind of sells itself.

+ Did you run into issues using one of these new elements?
Other than the aforementioned lack of ease of access to the crane, no - so far they've worked as desired and been rewarding to play with. If I had to give an idea for handling the crane issue, I'd maybe use gremlin crates as a fuelling mechanic - after a couple of minutes, you'd have to refuel the crane by filling it up at the base, forcing a player to disengage either to refuel and extend their time (allowing another waiting player to swap in) or to let it "recharge" on its own - but with how fast Watch missions cycle, how easy reinstancing is, and how fun the crane is to use, so far, I don't see much cause to change it. You kind of nailed both the Crane and the Kart.
Volatile Minerals are an exception. I don't understand how they work, how to maximise their utility, or what prompts them to act the way they do - nor if they're a hazard to myself or to opponents in the area. Those need some explanation, by my reckoning.

---

Additional Thoughts
Fangel is really good at this, actually - every post I've seen from them so far is really rich with ideas. The rework of the Big Cart to prevent trapping by having it break apart and be reassembled with the help of minerals on subsequent crashes is a good idea in my view, and I especially like the idea of a return to health-trade reviving, especially to handle some of the difficulty in Red zones (mentioned in my other post on objectives feedback). The social aspect is important, and the difficulty isn't insubstantial in dangerous areas, so it'd reduce the risk of a player balking at the prospect of not being able to complete an objective because of the spark cost, and compel players to stick together to share the burden (and rewards) too.

Their ideas on the crane - specifically there being two of them and there being a way to gather loot - really would improve not only the access to it, but the fun had using it. That said I also agree that removing loot access to a crane user would incentivise them to let the crane go for another player to use, so that's kind of an open debate in my mind.

One thing that could probably assist the crane's "safety" is drawing small no-fly zones over inaccessible/locked rooms to prevent knights being trapped, but I would strongly insist that those zones be used EXTREMELY Sparingly, and would function as a "Can't drop here" rather than a "Can't move here" restriction.

#5
These things are insane

So, having messed around with the 3 new elements, thought I'd give my feedback on them!

The crane was the first new element I interacted with, and it was so fun. Being able to move enemies, barricades, special loot boxes that only the crane could reach, and of course the basket was amazing. Interactive with these felt like a way to contribute to other players without just fighting with them; I was providing a very unique benefit. The crane also being used by the gremlins to move sprial boxes to their bunkers and drop enemies on top of you is a very nice case of showing how it can be used rather than just telling a player how to use it (Jumping on a basket that just dropped enemies to instantly get brought over to the crane to take control of it is brilliant design).

I do however see a ton of griefing potential with the crane in it's current form. I've seen similar suggestions, and I agree that restricting what types of items it can pick up (explosive blocks, ghost blocks, general level blocks) and restricting where it can place players (e.g. into loot rooms that haven't been opened yet) would go a way in reducing this. Griefing likely will always occur if someone wants to hog the crane and doesn't want to cooperate at all, but I don't see an easy way to restrict this as players cannot be forced to cooperate, even if it is in their best interests to do so.

Then tried the cars cause I kept hearing about them from people, took a while for me to find my first one in a level. When I did though, it was again amazing fun. Both being a passenger and a driver of the small cars was great, the rails were great shortcuts that helped get around the level much quicker, to say nothing of the speed boosts the cars themselves give you. Transporting boxes back to the lift, volatile minerals to the forge, or other players to their objectives felt like novel things to do with my time that were still helpful to everyone on the watch. The big car was a bit eh, was fun to drive if not a little awkward. It being able to transport both a box and players is a really nice utility, but one that I didn't use often, as people didn't want to go the same direction as the boxes generally. Takes a lot to get fixed for not much gain compared to the small cars.

Both Cars and Cranes are fun, but they're a lot less interesting when you don't get to interact with them (stating the obvious I know, but follow me for a second). Both elements strongly encourage cooperation, and are arguable at their best when both the primary user (crane controller, cart driver) and secondary users (basket passengers, car passengers, people willing to load/unload/move crates) work together to get a task that would take far longer or be too much effort for a single knight to achieve. When these two parties aren't working together to achieve a task, both elements become much less fun (the crane more so than the cars, the cars are just really good no matter what). I strongly feel these elements are perfect for being used in more puzzle-combat style mechanics (giving FCS's nature sprites, OCH as a whole, and the switches in the lead up to the Romulus Twins) in more traditional constructed levels (perhaps with a bigger party size). They should still remain in the watch however

Lastly, volatile minerals. These feel the weakest of the new elements, but are pretty neat. I did not understand them at all, until I did the Undead Keep's watch objectives which were a psuedo-tutorial. As I understand them, they are a perfect combat mechanic: the more you fight the bigger they get, but get hit and get sent back a stage. This is cool, but currently they feel very punishing for how little they grow for combat versus how much is lost when you get hit. This is doubly true for the Gremlin watch, where I don't know if they have any purpose at the moment? As of now, I tend to just wait for a shiny to drop from them and then run straight to the forge or Basil. Trading them to Basil though is really fun, especially for the goodies he gives out. The forge's upgrade is cool, gives a thing to do before hitting the boss rooms for extra power, and getting another random weapon is neat, but not game changing.

Overall, you're cooking with these game ideas, and I cannot wait to see these get improved, modeled, and expanded on!

#6
Dude. Truck, yes.

The new gameplay elements are so friggin' fun!!

I like the crane well enough. Without a use for gremlin crates yet, I imagine it's not as strong or rewarding as it could be, but as it stands it is an extremely fun and goofy addition that feels in the spirit of Spiral Knights--of course gremlins use construction equipment to move troops around.

Volatile minerals are an interesting addition. I think they're weaker than they could be, as there's no way to turn in minerals early, AFAIK, so just growing one and being done with it unless your floor has a forge is kind of lame. I think the "growing" element of it could be tutorialized a little, as I was confused what the quest wanted me to do at first. Add an info spot or something that explains that they grow by killing enemies.

The cars are the best thing added to this game since the removal of energy costs for elevators. I don't know what it is about them, but they are genuinely so fun and magical to drive around in, I love them! I especially like how they encourage teaming up with other players by letting more than one person ride them. I also love that they're half-tracks, judging from the current placeholder model, which are very "gremlin" vehicles, so they fit very well into the game.

I'm very excited for where these elements go! I'd especially love to see some goofy side mode where you get to race on the cars, haha.

#7
neat

Karts are super fun for multitudes of reasons as people have mentioned. There's not much purpose currently with the big kart unfortunately and it can cause issues in pinning people down into corners getting them stuck or blocking pathways. I do like Fangel's suggestion with split parts as well which would help fix this issue and potentially provide a different sub objective of sort.

The crane is pretty fun as well, the ability to carry around different blocks, objects or enemies is definitely cool but also has griefing potential as Leefy mentioned. One other example is you could carry around a Shankle which is technically still "grounded" despite being carried around, so you can use it to drag around other knights, damaging or killing them that way. This technically works with any mob as well, so long as they are able to hit other knights this way. I think the crane could just deactivate their function entirely on picking them up to prevent this sort of thing happening.
Another downside of the crane as mentioned in another post is there is usually only one on the map, so there's a big possibility of a player hogging it, which is an issue because it's tied to one of the objectives as well. Having more cranes around would help alleviate that but also allow knights to be more efficient with it's functions, being able to carry around more stuff around the map including other knights themselves for transport

Volatile minerals are interesting, they provide a bit of a combat boost by exploding enemies on growing them by killing different mobs, but also has use cases through the Forge/Basil. I think the minerals downgrading or breaking on getting hit is a tad bit punishing though, sometimes you have to carry the said mineral around through multitudes of rooms if you want to get it somewhere specific, or fighting mobs in general could result in you getting hit multiple times which would result in losing said mineral.
I like them having a use case for Forge/Basil, it would probably be nice to have the Forge specifically in all three of the Watches to be able to have the option to buff yourself through boosts or a temporary weapon. I think it's interesting, particularly the ability to have a temporary weapon which would allow newer players to try various different 5* weaponry.
Additionally I would like to add that it would be cool as another way to obtain said minerals for battle sprites - you could have a mineral deposit spot on the map which you could use so it would create this sort of a cycle of killing mobs to level up the mineral to then deposit it.

#8
My thoughts so far, good stuff!..

Did you enjoy the new elements like Cranes, Karts, and volatile minerals?

I was a bit skeptical when other players started to talk of "cranes" and "karts", there were strange speculations. But I must say I am very happy with both the crane and karts, they both provide fun cooperative gameplay to the otherwise very slow to traverse watch levels!

The Crane allowing to transport a mix of players and crates, while requiring that someone is left static in a room is an interesting dynamic, I have been attacked by mobs a few times while idle at the crane, so it isn't without risk as it currently stands (altho, for monsters to spawn, I'm pretty sure another player had to trigger them... SO that would be anti-coop).

The Karts were a more of a compromise between playing on your own, or helping others, since (mini) Karts can only transport one crate OR 2 players, the cooperative aspect is lost if someone wants or needs to bring a crate to the elevator. This is an aspect I think we could improve, maybe allow for 2 free handed players when there is no crate, and one player that has to hold onto the crate when there is a crate?

The volatile crystals are something I'm still making my mind up about, as it currently stands, it is absolutely not clear that: for example: gremlin crates need you to upgraded the crate machine with a medium crystal. It is also unclear at the moment where a given crystal stands between "levels", I was often wondering "am I close to growing it? how many more monsters do I have to kill/damage?". SO while the mechanic itself feels interesting, encouraging players to fight well to grow a crystal, I think the overall clarity of their whereabouts could be clearer, and also that it should rather require one or two more hits for a crystal to shatter.

Did you run into issues using one of these new elements?

Some tiles aren't affected by karts, like loot boxes which don't budge even if you were to charge into them. Making them behave more like a standard shield bash would be nice!

The Crane being able to pick up enemies is very neat and can lead to fun coop gameplay where a player picks up and enemy and another kills them, but it may also lead to some sabotaging where a player puts enemies behind a door that would open if said enemies were to be killed, so there is definitely room for anti-sabotage measures with this one. But I want to re-iterate that the gameplay of it as it currently is, is already incredibly enjoyable and fun! This is just a thought for the future.

Some bugs we found as well (some unrelated to the new elements):

  • The Crane cannot currently deposit players on the floating crystal platforms out of bounds, even tho it is clear they should be able to.
  • The mega kart (truck?) that holds one of the minibosses on jigsaw can push knights riding karts out of bounds, and lock them outside the usual pathways. (this can be fixed by asking someone to position a cart within interaction range, but it is still an issue).
  • Sometimes the arena gates don't open once all enemies have been killed, in the clockwork that is because gremlin corpses take time to despawn, but in candlestick, it seems to be permanent and makes the arena impossible to finish.

Do you have suggestions for any of these new elements?

Other than feedback about Volatile crystals and Karts in the first section, and my worries with the Crane and issues with karts in the second section:

I think using crystals to repair elements is a neat idea, but I wanna really emphasize that these crystals will have to be less fragile if you expect players (especially new players, or low level players) to bring them from one end of the level to another, taking a single hit can ruin a crystal expedition as it stands. This could be argued to be just be difficulty, but I still think adding one or two additional hits before the crystal shatters or downgrades could help make it more approachable and fair.

#9
Feeding, Fooding, Feasting

Did you enjoy the new elements like Cranes, Karts, and Volatile Minerals?
-Karts very enjoyable, need sound effects and horns if they aren't to annoying.
-Cranes are interesting but need more to them.
-Volatile Minerals are a neat new take on minerals but feel like they lack something.

Did you run into issues using one of these new elements?
Karts have a few obvious issues:
-Minerals spawn in the way of kart tracks sometimes(most times).
-Thorns in front of kart tracks dismount the player, the thorns shouldnt appear where kart tracks are or vice versa.
-Large Karts, npcs in larger karts seem to think they can go on kart roads but they are to big so they end up stuck.
-Enemies in karts is very funny but that fun can quickly change if they decide to take off on a joy ride across the map, the enemy ai should focus on the player and not go on a joy ride as they sometimes do this. I pray a mortafire and a kart never encounter one another, that scenario scares me.
-I noticed bushes break when driving through them but basic cube obstacles you find in construct zones do not break and obstruct the kart, since bushes and block obstacles are basically the same thing it would probably be best to make all cube like obstacles break when a kart rolls up.

-Crane didn't notice any issues but a clearer indicator of where it is hovering over the map would be useful, currently it only has a small shadow to go off which isn't easy to see.

-Volatile Minerals are discouraging if you lose your mineral after taking damage but maybe thats part of the challenge.

#10
Individual Game Elements

Did you enjoy the new elements like Cranes, Karts, and volatile minerals?

  • Yes. Love all of them, mostly. But there are some issues with a few. Which will be addressed below.

Did you run into issues using one of these new elements?

  • Crane I really like what it is currently. So many possibilities. Feels nice with small combat aids too. Thank you, Crane person!
  • Karts Absolutely loving these little (and big) things. Although there are several issues regarding the collision box and its ability to push the player out of bounds or shoot up toward the moon or whatever clockwork sphere allowed to be. I suggest making the game check if the player is out of bounds on the level or tune down the knockback.
  • Some setpiece props also blocked the Kart from crossing the bridge (the gremlin level tile set) for the mineral room.
  • I wished the big kart had more impact on the player after repair. Maybe you can upgrade them...maybe add mounting turrets.
  • Volatile Minerals So far, I am ok with this element. Only one issue I wished it doesn't exist is when you taking damage it will drop the mineral. Downgrading it from the back is fine. But dropped minerals can be hard to pick up in a busy battle and CAN block your knight from escaping the danger

Do you have suggestions for any of these new elements?

  • Cranes No, I like them as it is.
  • Karts Reduce collisions and address the ability to push players off the map. Make them upgradable with minerals. Mark the big kart as a special point of interest instead of the boss icon after deafeated
  • Volatile Minerals Make a pop-up text in the mineral room, telling the player how to grow them and what to avoid. Add a level indicator for when it will advance to the next stage. Make them no longer fall off your back until a shard (material) forms
#11
Some updates from today

Firstly, I've noticed we have two cranes per Clockworks Watch, and Basil has been given a blue candle now in the Candlestick Watch. These are both huge improvements for the feel of the levels, so I want to say thank you for making these adjustments!

That being said, there appears to be some sort of buffer with picking things up mid combat. While this does prevent you from accidentally jumping into a car in the midst of battle, it has the side effect of preventing you from picking up your mineral unless you stop attacking for a moment (which is bad when they deteriorate so fast in combat), and also prevents you from rapidly interacting with a car when you want to (or a crane platform). This is also very problematic for Candlestick Watch, where you can't pick up the embers mid combat - and a snappy pickup of embers is mandatory for those stronghold rooms with how much is going on.

#12
Critical concern

If a player controlling a Crane carrying a group of knights logs out during their session, there is no way for the knights on the cage to make it back to the ground safely.
I propose that if a Crane suddenly suffers a control loss due to a player leaving or being knocked down by enemies, that the crane should immediately return to its starting area and drop whatever it is carrying. During its reset procedure, no force should be able to interrupt it - either Gremlin or Knight intervention.

Thanks to Ainogommon for their assistance testing this interaction in a controlled manner.

Outside of that I am thrilled to see the addition of a second crane and I actually really enjoy the back and forth of Gremlins fighting with Knights over who has the cage - makes the whole place feel more like a battlefield being contested by two forces.

#13
Ainogommon also helped test…

Ainogommon also helped test the interaction of a Car being picked up by a Crane while being driven - the knight is kicked off safely and that feels reasonable. I'm also absolutely DELIGHTED to see the appearance of Cars in the clockworks watch area!

I am also now aware that the Crate Opening Dock can be charged with minerals to activate its ability to open Gremlin Crates for materials, making the crane even more valuable - but this information could stand to be clarified to players. I think the way to do it is to have picking up a Gremlin Crate clearly tooltip the player about charging the dock before they can use it, with a marker that points to minerals - and if the dock is already active, marking its location would be helpful regardless.

#14
I want to also support…

I want to also support Fangel and Ainogommon's suggestions of adding arsenal stations, with the added note that if Health-Share Revives aren't on the table, a station to recharge a knight's Emergency Revive (that could require activation) might be a suitable stopgap.

#15
my 2 cents

Did you enjoy the new elements like Cranes, Karts, and volatile minerals?

Yes, a lot. I really love the volatile minerals system, the crane is insanely fun (but also can break stuff), the karts needs to have more objective to use them

Did you run into issues using one of these new elements?

Crane can put ppl behind key door and leave them there.

Do you have suggestions for any of these new elements?

I think you should add kart variant like the easter eggs enemies (love puppy gun turret, impostocube, etc) that does something silly.

#16
Spiral Karts!

Did you enjoy the new elements like Cranes, Karts, and volatile minerals?

Cranes I like well enough, they're quite funny to play around with, and it's shocking how much you're allowed to mess with using them (maybe to a fault). Karts I LOVE, they're so funny. As the old Adage goes; we got GTA in Spiral Knights before GTA VI. Volatile minerals are also very cool in their own right, it's like a salt bomb strapped to your back at all times without wasting an inventory slot on a salt bomb... The behavior of how and why they fall off your back is a bit janky and hard to understand though, made worse by a distinct pick-up lag being experienced on the preview server right now; dunno what that's about. Also, the temporary candle-glow your knight gets when their mineral becomes shiny in Candlestick Watch is so cool!

Did you run into issues using one of these new elements?

Nothing significant to note from the aforementioned. It is strange, however, that the crane can turn certain cube-shaped objects around, revealing their backface-culled side, this shouldn't happen.

Do you have suggestions for any of these new elements?

Not at this time. anything I would suggest ought to be sorted with polish before release, I should think.

#17
Did you enjoy the new…

Did you enjoy the new elements like Cranes, Karts, and volatile minerals?
I enjoyed the crane for a bit, but it did feel a bit slow to maneuver it across the map, especially to grab a mineral.
And it was fun to drive around for a bit.

Did you run into issues using one of these new elements?
Carts can't be interacted with for a couple seconds after using a weapon.
Attacks used while riding a cart activate as if the cart, with its size scaling and different origin point used it, rather than the player.

Do you have suggestions for any of these new elements?
The crane could do with a, return to controls, button.
The volatile minerals could do with some kind of tutorial for how they work. It was not apparent to me that I could increase their size by fighting enemies.

#18
my thoughts

I'd like to see how these new mechanics effect the level design of the Watches.

Assuming the current levels are subject to drastic redesigns, I'd like to see the Jigsaw Valley Watch become more spatial, with a larger focus on transportation. Perhaps you could have regions of the map that can only be entered via those special rails. There could also be better ways to integrate the karts into the map rather than having them just spawn in various rooms. I was thinking of a "vehicle station" which could let the player summon a kart a la Borderlands 2 (obviously with a limit to how many can be spawned. Or similarly to BL2, summoning a kart could despawn the last one summoned by that knight). If that idea seems to overpowered, you could have the players "craft" the karts at these stations with Gremlin Crates or some other resource found around the map.

The Crane in the Clockworks Watch has MASSIVE puzzle potential that I beg the GMs to tap into. You can transport keys (and presumably heavy statues), use pots or rockets to destroy Ghost and Explosive blocks or to hit switches, you can move ghost blocks around which I really hope gets integrated into the level in some way. In my opinion, I feel like the Clockworks Watch could benefit from being slightly more linear. As it currently stands the Crane can pretty much be completely ignored for most objectives (aside from the one which asks you to operate it). I'd like to see a version of this where the first step upon entering the Watch is to seize control of a Crane and use it to unlock more parts of the map. (This does NOT mean that every player is required to use the crane to progress, just that one is needed to open up the map and make exploration easier)

I'm a bit iffy about the Candlestick Watch. I see some good ideas here, but it just isn't as interesting as the other two Watches. First and foremost, its lacking a form of transportation. I remembered about those "ghost tracks" found in Moorcroft Manor and Angels from Antiquity and thought, "what if we had some sort of fast travel station?" I imagine 2-3 train station-esque rooms which would allow knights to quickly jump between different parts of the map. (personally I'm against the idea of simply throwing karts into each Watch. I'd rather them all have their own unique gameplay elements) As for the Volatile Minerals, currently they're a little underwhelming but I think they're only a couple changes away from being more engaging than the Cranes & Karts. Firstly, have minerals provide stronger buffs that linger around. I'm approaching this with a "stackable buff" kind of idea, where the more you can grow your Volatile Mineral, the more powerful it'll become. Secondly, each mineral should provide their own unique effects (they kind of already do, but there could be more. currently they all just explode) For example, I noticed that growing a mineral to the next size made the player glow for a second which does actually act as a temporary candle. Why not have Luminite give off a constant glowing effect at Large or Shiny? Something else that came to mind is some sort of "Alchemy Room", where Knights could mix and match minerals for special effects. [insert magic trope here]

I hope I'm not asking for too much, but I would like these Watches to consist of mostly new prefabs rather than reusing Arcade rooms we've already explored a million times. If it comes down to it, you have a whole community of Crucible Builders who would be more than happy to create new rooms for levels like these. Just a thought.

All in all, I would like to see maps lean into these new mechanics more that they currently do.

#19
New Gameplay Elements Feedback

Did you enjoy the new elements like Cranes, Karts, and volatile minerals?
I loved them! They were fun, creative new ways to enjoy the game and interact with enemies and other players alike.
The Cranes provide an interesting way to support (or troll) fellow knights, to catch enemies to be held prisoner, or to place blocks anywhere in the map allowing for unintended destruction via Ghostblocks or creating traps with explosive blocks, and even making labyrinths using barricades.

The Karts immediately alleviated my worries about getting around the larger maps. More than that, of course, they provide a fun new way to fight enemies, whether the charge or attacking from on back while another Knight drives. I get they're also available to use to move Crates around, but unless there is something more worthwhile than a random material drop or for the sake of completing a task, I see this feature of the Karts being used sparingly.

The Volatile Minerals were a very unexpected addition, and while they don't seem very reliable upon in combat, when they work, they're cool as heck! The ability to use them to upgrade equipment is also neat, although I found it interesting that these weapon buffs were the only ones in the game to have a strict number value to them, instead of the Low/Med/High/V.High/Ultra/Max buff values we see via our gear stats usually. My personal bias prefers these kind of number values universally in anything I play so I know what I'm getting out of an upgrade or debuff, so I do like this, but it feels inconsistent and might need to be addressed.

Did you run into issues using one of these new elements?
I tested the Crane with another knight, and after moving some Green treasure boxes out of the way, they were able to place me behind a gate that required a key. Obviously this is not something that a player might want to do, but if someone disconnects while messing around with other knights, this could cause players to be locked and unable to continue in the instance. I think a simple skyblock would be fine to keep the Crane from reaching areas that this could be an issue in, or to keep it from being utilized to cheese the miniboss fights by picking up enemies and holding them in place for other knights to beat down. Otherwise, making the Cranes spawn in designated areas where they can be used within a specific range might also work, but would limit the variability of The Watch instances.

In general, it was difficult at times to interact with items. Karts and Minerals or Crates could be a bit wonky with their response, where it might play an animation to pick up or interact but nothing would happen. Changing position or pausing to stand still for a moment helped the interaction work, but this is something that typically doesn't cause issues anywhere else in the game.

The Volatile Minerals, like the other pick-up/Interactable items, had issues with picking up as well, but more than that they were unclear in their usage. My deduction was that they charge up and explode when doing damage to enemies, and taking damage drops the Volatile Mineral immediately, whereupon it will cause more explosions and shrink in size until it becomes a Small Mineral or it is picked up by a player. Picking up a discharging Volatile Minerals proved to be difficult, not least of all becomes of enemies nearby, but the interact issues made it difficult to pick up before it disappeared.

Do you have suggestions for any of these new elements?
Adjusting the range or limits on where the Crane can move to will alleviate any issues with players accidentally getting stuck or cheesing The Watch. Or, as others have mentioned, giving it fuel to keep a player from just sitting on the Crane the whole time would make it a bit more balanced.

For the Karts, I wonder if players could add a turret on the back, similar to the Crates? Not one the players would operate, but an automated turret similar to those that can be summoned, or found in the Rescue Camp or in OCH that defend positions. Players would have to use Volatile Minerals to activate them, and it would take the place of anyone else sitting there and could be destroyed, but it would be a fun feature to allow players to bring their own little added firepower as they explore The Watch.

The Volatile Minerals could shrink while on the player without them dropping it until it becomes Small, or could take more hits to knock off the player depending on its size.

As others have mentioned, Volatile Minerals could also be used to grant an armor/defensive buff to players; similar to the % increase in attack, it could be used to grant a % increase to current armor values, or could maybe modify a shield bash to do more damage, cause a varying status effect, or deal alternative damage types. Considering there's not many ways to get stronger in order to take on the Red Zones where enemies are so beefed up, giving the players options to prepare themselves before venturing to take down the minibosses or Strongholds would be a very welcome boon.

I also like seeing the new engagement from enemies with their quips, and would love to see more. I don't know if I've ever seen a Gremlin actually call us a "knight" before, usually they have some other way of calling us if I recall so that felt really weird...

If any of these recommendations for Gremlin quips are repeats, apologies: having a Gremlin driving a Kart by a knight on foot could shout "Eat my dust!" or if the player is also in a kart "You'll never catch me!". When a knight is operating a Crane, it would be funny to see them shout "Hey, that's not your toy!" or "You aren't certified to operate that!". For any of the Volatile Minerals, I can see them targeting players more directly and shouting "Destroy that crystal, before it destroys us all!" to help signify to players it could be used as weapon, not just loot, too.

And as mentioned by others, the option to share health or recharge your free revive feels like an obligatory addition; players will be engaging with enemies for much longer, and since there is no Basil at the beginning to buy anything from either, you'll be struggling to find vitapods and health capsules to keep you in the fight after you've cleared even a quarter of the map. I remember being able to give half your HP to a knight that was downed, and would love to see that or a reworked version of that returned for The Watch.

Eager to see what other new elements come out down the line; this has been a blast so far, so thank you!!!

#20
Most of this feedback will…

Most of this feedback will be regarding Volatile Minerals since I have the most issues with them:
With the way Volatile Minerals are currently designed, I think it's a completely flawed mechanic. I said this once in my Spikestorm feedback thread, but this game just keeps introducing new mechanics that kill any remaining reason to consider building for tankiness. Minerals seem to drop on the first hit that you take, and with that, there's not a lot of reason to intentionally go out of your way to get hit in the first place, which only rewards players that go full-throttle glass cannon.
I think Mineral loss should depend on %hp lost, rather than each individual hit taken. That will make the mechanic slightly more forgiving, and in the long term be healthier in terms of design.

I'd also like to point out that something has SERIOUSLY been tampered with in the pickup department. Interacting with objects in this update has become ten times more cumbersome, and more often than not the game prioritizes that I use my main attack than using the item I'm standing still and facing directly to use. I don't know what's causing this, but I'd like to see it reverted.