Test Feedback: The Overall Feedback on The Watch

35 replies [Last post]

Greetings Testers!

Please go join an adventure as part of The Watch in game and let us know your feedback. Specifically for this thread, we're looking for feedback on your overall impressions of The Watch.

  • Were you able to play with a larger group?
  • Did your party make it into the same Watch instance?
  • Did you enjoy the expansive nature of the area?
  • Were you encouraged to seek out other players to play with?
  • Do you have ideas or suggestions for ways to improve the experience of The Watch?
#1
arena treasure room not working?

This occured for both owlite arenas. after all the mobs/boss was killed the combat music continued to play and the gate did not drop.

also is there a reason moonstone was named something else? was super confused by the grow crystal by combat at first.

One suggestion would be open floors like Apocrea where its one massive map w/o all these hallways. Maybe this could be a search and rescue watch mission or players need to capture and defend key areas from mobs( kind of like LD but PVE) it could be strategic where palyers are able to build turrents and barriers to defend key choke points

#2
cant login?

also i cant seem to login i tried entering the training hall and my game froze

#3
Unable to log in

It times out and says: "Either there is a temporary network outage or the server is not yet fully operational. Please wait a moment before reconnecting"

#4
feedback

Got to be with a large groups of randoms and one with mainly people I know. Because of how many people it can hold, the expansive nature felt needed but also felt super confusing at times.
The worst part was pathing to the next objective. It felt really boring and long. The kart made navigating so much more fun. I would really love more transportation vehicles or abilities.

#5
@deeply-in

perhaps a transport knights objective could help? it would encourage those who have vehicles to drive you to your objective. I am not sure if you can send waypoints in the mode but that would help so you could tell the driver where you need to go.

#6
sk is so back

suggestion for the undead watch, more transport

add warping jars:
- matching color jars (blue, green, purple, etc)
- one jar warps to the other of the same color
- you can pick up and move to assist knights hopping from one objective to the other

#7
my 2 cents

I'm pretty happy with the new content.
There's an audio trigger that don't deactivate so you can retrigger the fight song over and over. It does fade out once you leave.
Is there a way to add a scroll thingy to the player list? I play windowed and can't see past the 9th player.
I wish there was an easier way to travel for ppl without full MSI boost as I don't run with BK set but chaos. The kart in the jelly are insanely fun. I drove into an arena helping ppl and got my kart stolen.
10//10 experience

Edit: I'm gonna make a new post in a few days after more playing with a more detailed version with suggestion

#8

Overall I think it's super cool and I had a lot of fun. As for some of your main points:

  • Found groups of >10 knights multiple times. I really like the idea of huge parties in theory, but when you're all in an arena together it gets laggy and difficult to see what's going on (especially when I started dropping Dark Retributions). And then you get two shot due to enemy scaling. That being said, when not in arenas, larger groups are nothing but more fun
  • I enjoyed the large areas with tons of interconnected rooms and respawning enemies. Made me wish I could move while the map was open, though. Also can make the crate objective somewhat painful to complete.
  • The level scaling in arenas definitely encouraged party play, and so does the fact that it doesn't seem like loot drops if you're not immediately present. Not necessarily fun ways to encourage party play, though (but I understand why this loot system is necessary to discourage splitting up to farm or exploiting respawning enemies).

Suggestions:

  • I think The Watch Specific arenas could benefit from being larger when playing with large groups of people.
  • I don't know how feasible this would be or even how much it would help, I was reminded of a setting in GW2 that allows you to hide effects generated by other players for a performance improvement.
  • Again, make it so that we can move while opening the map
  • Add an arsenal station by the elevator.

Some bugs:

  • If someone uses the elevator to leave, the elevator stays in the raised position until someone else joins.
  • Undead arenas didn't open the gates to their treasure rooms after completion. At least, this happened with the two arenas I played, both of which were the square donut shaped arena with four spike traps around the inner ring and four candles around the outer ring.
#9
About the new update

Can Expansions please stay as their own missions? I would have loved more expansion missions alongside Operation Crimson Hammer. We could have faced the other members of the Crimson Order and find out more about them and what they do in the name of their king. Maybe even find out more on why Herex betrayed the others, he could have discovered a truth he should not have about Tinkinzar.

I would wave loved more masks and weapons connected to the rest of the Crimson Order as well that we can gain by facing the other members. And see everyone again eventually like Seerus when the time finally comes to face the king.

Also, please keep the blue minerals as Moonstone, I loved that name for it. And on that topic, I would have loved for regular E-Class Battle Sprites to be modified to be strengthened using it as pet food. Eventually gaining a machine gun arm and a shield projector arm as it becomes a flying war machine.

The carts look fun also, hope they can be added to other parts of the game and maybe Guild Halls too. But the way splitting up is discouraged needs some work. And the arsenal next to the elevator to join and leave would really help too.

#10
the crane is fun, however...

The crane on the gremlin watch level is really fun but there is huge griefing potential with how it can be used to softlock players or objectives, or bringing boxes that spawn loot outside of the range of other people just to be mean. On the other hand restricting what the crane can do would almost definitely make it much less fun.

The karts are great but I think we can all agree it needs a button to honk a car horn (beep beep!), but that's a thing for the art-pass later. They could also benefit from some HUD element showing their remaining HP considering they can be damaged and will break down.

Candlestick Keep is a bit boring compared to the other two, altho I do like the idea of being able to trade minerals with basil for some goodies.

Loot from boxes only spawning if you are close enough to them is an unfun way to get people to group up as someone running off on their own is inevitable with huge lobbies, however, loot from enemies being restricted this way is fine in my opinion. If the boxes respawned (on a long timer or something) like enemies and minerals do, it would help with missing out.

Being able to move while having the map open would help a lot with navigation. Perhaps the fullscreen map could be a separate button from the "toggle map" button we know from your regular mission and arcade runs? Custom waypoints/map pings would also help a lot.

I was able to get into bigger lobbies a few times and have had a lobby I was hosting become really big (over 12 people!) at least twice, but I've also had one or two runs where I was completely on my own.

I wasn't specifically going out of my way to make a bigger lobby happen, so I can't comment on how partying up with your friends works.

First impressions are definitely positive, ignoring the lack of polish and bugs (those are kind of expected).
If the loot is interesting enough and/or provides a secondary source of some annoying to get items, this could be a very good new mode. People need an incentive to run this mode after all if you want lobbies to actually fill once this mode goes live.

#11
Most fun I've had in SK in a long time

Playing with a large group of people is a lot more fun than I thought it would be, especially with how the danger rooms are scaled. The new traversal vehicles, crane and carts, are also a lot of fun as well.

My favorite vehicle being the crane, its a powerful thing to have due to it being able to pick up just about anything and move it around. My favorite moments are when it was used to drop a bunch of players into areas where people are already fighting, holding enemies still or repositioning blocks to assist players. However, as mentioned before, it does allow griefing and theres very little players can do about said griefer. But I do worry that nerfing the crane will greatly hamper its fun factor. A major complaint I have with the crane isn't really the crane but the platform, its very awkward to fight when its nearby since attacking can make you jump into the platform instead.

I don't really have much to say about cars other that they're fun, but they do need a little more. A hud to display the status of the vehicle, dash being more consistent and doing a little bit more to enemies. Not sure I like having to repair vehicles, I never really thought it was worth it to go across the map and get shards to repair the big vehicle when I could just do other things or find a working small vehicle instead.

Candlestick is not only the most boring out of the three but also a bit strange with Basil being its gimmick. The update seems to want cooperation and knights working together, both what the crane and cars achieve, but Basil doesn't really have anything to do with that. Maybe I'm just mistaking whats supposed to be a side gimmick, like Slime's forge, with a primary gimmick, but if thats the case then candlestick simply doesn't have one. It needs a traversal gimmick that allows some form of cooperation or fun interactions to be on par with the others.

For the mode as a whole, I think its a fun casual thing. In its current iteration it might be decent for casually gathering cr/heat since enemies respawn and I do like the objectives being simple "kill x"/"do x" though the rewards are going to make/break the mode I feel, maybe leaning more into a social sandbox design might give it life outside of the grinding/reward mindset. In addition the boss at the end of each danger room obviously needs to be more of a threat, but I assume thats just placeholder and unfinished.

In short, its a breath of fresh air that SK sorely needs but longevity of the mode relies on the fun factor on playing with large amounts of people and the rewards. Undead watch falls short compared to others, and more might be needed to make use of large amounts of players.

#12
many tidbits

Obviously we're in the very early stages of this and everything is subject to radical changes. I'll offer my thoughts so far:

Every map needs some form of fast-transportation, similar to the cars on Jigsaw valley zones. The cars are amazing and probably the best part of this update. Zooming around in a battle buggy with your friends, ramming things and delivering cargo, is a huge change of pace from the base game and a very fun experience.

However, without fast-transport of some sort, these levels just become huge arcade zones, which frankly speaking isn't super interesting. Candlestick Watch especially suffers from this, offering almost no new experiences compared to existing Candlestick Keep levels.

For Candlestick Watch: perhaps teleport pads to quickly get from one section of a level to another? Perhaps broomsticks you can ride around? Anything which breaks up the monotony of just running on foot.

For Clockworks Watch: The Crane is amazing, but only one person can control it and few can ride it at a time, so in a highly populated level, many players end up missing out on the experience. Perhaps MORE CRANES?! Perhaps speedboost pads which simply make it more expedient to get around? Or, perhaps... MORE CARS?

I really like the unique interactions and "shops" found on the Jigsaw Valley Watch. Being able to turn in minerals for buffs and temporary gear is a cool way to mix up the experience. The gameplay loop of "find thing, bring thing to special location for cool thing" is neat and I'd like to see more of it. Hopefully we see those kind of interactions expanded upon across all three Watch types.

I also like the gameplay loop of "Boss Doors," which require finding unlocks throughout the level, leading up to a big showdown encounter. However, I will say that I hope the final boss encounters aren't just copy-and-pasted Danger Rooms, but rather proper boss fights in their own right. We have many enemies and attacks which could be remixed to provide a novel experience. What if that Collector enemy made an appearance, sporting a new suite of attacks? etc, etc

The novelty of a huge shared space is very interesting. Hopefully the final payout ends up being competitive relative to existing content so players have adequate incentive to run it over FSC or Arcade, if they so choose.

Overall a very interesting and significant update which has the potential to radically shake things up.

Incredibly, we got GTA in Spiral Knights before we got GTA VI.

#13
This is super fun

This is, quite frankly, the biggest content update that Spiral Knights has seen in over a decade. This is on the same level as battle sprites, in my opinion - and that firmly changed the course of the game after.

The goals of this update to bring players all together for social, low-stakes gameplay is absolutely there. The fact that we're stuck with D5 damage and health means that you need the focused power of several high level players to tackle the higher tier monster challenges, but it also equalizes the assistance that lower star players can provide. The simple drop-in, drop-out ability ensures that new players who die, revive, and die again aren't dead weight, as their place will be taken by a new player once they leave, and there's not an expectation of being revived by your party.

The actual gameplay loop is fun too! You can play alone, but with the branching paths of the levels, you can literally just wander around and contribute to the missions. The objectives are all interesting and engaging, I especially enjoy the "help another player complete a task" ones. Communicating with players for pickups with the crane or the car makes for some great moments as well. I also love that all the "miniboss" and "big boss" enemies are SPIKED! Spiked monsters acting as bosses is such a great idea - I was floating it very recently myself, and I'm very content to see I was beat to the punch on that one.

The volatile minerals is such an interesting idea. I'm not sure I'm on board with it from a lore perspective, but from a gameplay perspective they provide an interesting loop and act as a defacto third currency. I thoroughly enjoy how they are handled.

Now, that's enough of me gushing. There is still a lot to work on, and here's my thoughts on what can be improved:

  1. Fast travel options need to be available in every level

  2. The car/karts are an incredible addition. They provide excellent teamwork options, and remove one of the most frustrating parts of Spiral Knight's gameplay loop: walking from point A to B. The crane is another cool option, giving you the ability to support players and move them around is really fun. Seeing what the crane operator can do was really silly (picking up the mender healing the special barricade and then plopping them on the knight side is especially memorable. I love it). Candlestick Keep needs some form of fast travel - I think having various lit candles acting as fast travel points would be one way to do this, as it requires players to light candles for each other and thus keeps the spirit of teamwork for travel involved.

  3. More unique tiles

  4. A lot of tiles are reused from existing levels, and some naming conventions don't quite make sense. Jigsaw Valley is a gremlin logging operation, and focused on gremlins and constructs... But its Watch is based around gremlin/slime compounds? This isn't inherently bad, but the naming could be fixed to be "Compound [number] Watch" and be more accurate. Additionally, more unique scenario rooms for this would be excellent. Reusing assets is fine, but this would be an excellent time to allow players to create PvE crucible tiles. The gremlin tiles had a lot of love put into them, and while others were certainly WIPs, Candlestick felt pretty uninspired.

  5. More polish needed

  6. Similar to the above, a lot of tiles need some extra TLC to bring them up to code. A lot of tiles had blending issues, and for things like the Crane, blocks you pick up could be rotated, showing the normally invisible backsides and breaking immersion. Additionally, craning a key would not visually pick it up, but when you placed it it would just teleport from its previous location, often leaving a "ghost key" behind on the minimap. This is not a huge concern currently, but definitely will need to be touched up significantly before going live.

  7. Performance issues and large fights

  8. While the game runs really well for the most part, when a lot is happening on screen, the game does start to chug along. This is expected, and while it's not crashing anything, it may not hurt to have the game automatically adjust certain graphics settings when more than 4-8 players are on the screen. In the chaos of combat, you'll probably not even notice a change like this. Either that or have allied effects have a transparency effect so you can still see what you're doing, but not be blinded by fellow knights.

  9. Rewards will need to be revisited

  10. I know I might be alone here, but I really appreciate that the Watch is fundamentally not a replacement for grinding out crowns from FSC/Arcade. You get somewhere between 1-2k crowns per instance, and that's OK for a social element where you can goof around with friends or random folks you run into. What I do think is that the Watch should have some unique rewards - the Spikes being available as rewards year round is a massive W, and the amount of heat you can gather just casually is also great... But please make it so if we leave the level through the "Turn in to Kora" it gives us the heat rather than requiring us to backtrack to the elevator to do it. I think that having material drops be available as good drops is a huge positive as well, as it can allow newer players to get access to higher star materials to then feed their battle sprites much earlier.

    In-Watch rewards, like the temporary weapon from the forge, are cool (and would be a GREAT way to field test new weapons, btw) but act a bit weird if you already have 4 weapons. If you don't have a next/previous weapon key bound, then if you have all 4 slots filled it gets a bit weird trying to find your new 5th weapon.

I am very tired so I might not be covering everything, but first impressions are strong, and I'm really excited for the future of Spiral Knights with this on the horizon.

#14
Overall Feedback on The Watch

+ Were you able to play with a larger group?
Yes. Sixteen-strong parties of knights and large maps are a lot of fun and I hope desperately that this never gets reduced. I haven't had an experience like this in Spiral Knights ever before and I hope to have it for many sessions to come.

+ Did your party make it into the same Watch instance?
Yes! Joining friends was quite easy in my experience. Reinstancing was easy too, if I wanted to see other groups of players.

+ Did you enjoy the expansive nature of the area?
Enormously! :)
I'd love to see a rotation of maps become available in the future because it'd be entertaining, but the diversity of map features and new mechanics breathes a lot of new life into this little game. Enough that I don't actually know about calling it "little" quite as often, actually.

+ Were you encouraged to seek out other players to play with?
Yes! Or rather, I was comfortable joining open groups in the Watch gamemode because it is difficult for a player to outwardly impede progress and - as already said - players have been extremely civil and helpful.

+ Do you have ideas or suggestions for ways to improve the experience of The Watch?
Anything I've suggested is written in other feedback areas, but to summarize for GH's benefit:
- Controlling for Crane Use is a consideration on my mind but I don't think it's urgent.
- Tiered Zones are very enjoyable and clearly conveyed, but without a way to consistently protect oneself they can be more challenging than perhaps intended.
- "Defeat N enemies" objectives could be made Continuous rather than Per-Objective-Set so that they can always be contributed to and no progression towards them is "wasted" between objective tier, promoting play and giving players options if they're pending one objective that isn't available at that time.
- The discoverability of Watch and Arcade gameplay is fine, but a lingering question exists in how OCH will be handled or whether it should be made into a Prestige mission of some kind or whether it should actually be moved to persist on the last page of the Missions tab.
- (This also opens the question of whether similar styles of multi-floor, story-heavy mission to OCH could be added in the future, but that is presently out of scope.)
- If centering the Arcade's importance to a player's progression is a goal of the current play mechanics and user experience, I do not think it presently succeeds - small changes could be made to clarify this through dialogue or pop-up, either in the new-player-experience or as a part of Watch gameplay.
- Volatile Minerals do not presently make sense to me. I either haven't experimented enough or the game hasn't made their function clear.
- An "Onboarding" process or mission could help introduce the watch and its mechanics, resolving the prior two points (and possibly also giving cause to move OCH onto this possible "side missions" page). Kora alone in haven is not quite enough, if I am to be honest, but I understand the watch outpost is to be revised.
- I fundamentally do not believe rank-restricting the Watch in order to force onboarding is a good idea - onboarding should be available at any time. I agree with Fangel that the fact that everyone is important to a Watch mission is its single most attractive feature and focusing on it will benefit the gamemode enormously.
- More of these very large maps would keep the play variety up, and I don't necessarily believe that the features on the maps need to be ever-present, given how objective randomization works. Different maps may have completely novel objective sets (of course bound by the same interactions.) Something that comes to mind is destroying a generator instead of a bunker, or sabotaging a production line through some kind of puzzle, but that's something to be left to GH to consider.
- Reopening the Rescue Camp south of Haven and styling it as a Watch Camp or Outpost to give the Watch missions a place to "live" away from the Arcade would benefit its style of gameplay by clearly separating it, and also enhance the feel of the game world.
- I support Fangel's suggestion of reintroducing health-share revives to further centre the highly social playstyle of this game and reduce the risk of engagement with the gamemode (in terms of resource loss) to both incentivise collaboration and participation.
- If anyone remembers the three special loadouts from Lockdown, I think it could be quite interesting to see those show up as craftable abilities in Watch areas, much like how Weapon Tempering is an ability already. The effect it might have on supporting knights as they deal with difficult rooms is worth discussing.

---

Additional Closing Thoughts
I haven't been this excited to play Spiral Knights in my whole life, and the Forge update was already a really nice change that sucked me straight back into playing the game. I played this with a small group of discord friends and the mood was absolutely electric throughout; we all have a long history with this game and seeing it come back to life like this was the nicest early christmas present we've gotten in a REAL long time.

The experience I have had so far even in this early greyboxing form has been delightful. I would honestly make the case that very little actually needs to be done to hone the mechanics - and so much has been introduced to the game at this stage already that I honestly think in a restrained context, these mechanics could spice up the Arcade, too. Specific rooms for cranes or long drive style arcade floors with rammable obstacles or things that can only be destroyed with a well-placed crash.

The mission-based gameplay expands the scope of the game much further than simply producing more Rank missions ever would (even though I still want that, of course!), and I love how the Gremlins are being characterised now (of COURSE i love the gremlins even more now!). There's more "life" in the game, in a way; it sets a solid foundation for an engaging future for the game and I genuinely never thought I'd see anything like it. I cant express my enjoyment of this intensely enough, other than to say "thank you so much for your work on this," and I can't wait to see where it goes.

#15
If you really want to make it big group mode

- Make one big safe entry point
-- Place loadout chest
-- Place mineral deposit for crates and minerals (good old one existing 3d model)
-- Add new big map terminal there, it's terrible for usual gameplay, but you can turn it into information hub (zone 1: 5/5 crates left, 1/1 bosses left and etc.)
- Add teleport to safe zone, you can do it at any time, but you can't bring anything with you

- Set few big goals for all:
-- Kill 250 mobs (add reward increase for every 50 killed mobs)
-- Bring 20 crates to entry point (the same reward increase for every 4 boxes)
-- Bring 20 minerals to entry point
-- Save 5 knights
-- Kill boss (optional)

- Add some extra valuable crates/minerals/knights (for example, 1 big crate = 5 usual crates)

- Add some challenges for valuable cargo
-- Chase, steal valuable crate and run or try to kill strong mob
-- Trap room with one way barriers, you can enter, but you have to kill all mobs to turn off barriers, other players can join you
-- Fragile crate, don't let mobs destroy it
-- Bleeding knight (limited by time)
-- Heavy cart, more players - more speed
-- Sudden route change, short way is closed
-- Party puzzle for 2-4 players, buttons, switches, crane and etc.

#16

I returned to the test server just a moment ago and found that the map layouts do in fact change - so that's pretty good! Let's say my hopes expanding the variety of the gamemode are for more modules and more themes, instead - but that's absolutely a "future of the feature" thing; so far I'm thrilled with how it feels to play and finding that there's going to be a natural variability to it is great.

Oh, and I adore the fact that gremlins can use their own cranes and carts to drop enemies off onto unsuspecting knights. It really adds to their feel as an organised enemy force...!

#17
Most fun I had in a while

I love that it's a big open public area that anyone can join in to do daily activities, it's very socially interactive; it also allows some potential big guild activities and various big activities between bigger groups of friends. It's awesome.

It's very easily accessible through either the missions tab or party finder for existing lobbies. I agree with Vyre on the Watch Camp idea towards south of Haven - it would make for a cool set piece and a lobby place for The Watch related stuff (e.g Kora could be in there too for you to turn in the missions, also could create an opportunity for something like unique vendors for The Watch related stuff or other things)

Having other players around definitely eases some missions, particularly any 3* ones where you need to clear a dangerous arena and with something like Karts in Jigsaw Valley helps other players let people navigate towards set missions. Clockworks Watch could use more cranes for the same regard too. Candlestick Watch unfortunately lacks something like that, so it would be nice to see something similar of the sort for it.

The suggestion of bringing back health splitting revives particularly for The Watch sounds great.

I definitely agree on adding a loadout chest at the spawn area so we'd have ability to switch up gear without having to leave the lobby.

I definitely agree with Retrofit, Fangel and Vyre in general on the points they've provided, they pretty much cover my impressions in general as well.

#18
I stand corrected

Okay, reading some more comments, turns out these are volatile versions of existing minerals. Sorry for my mistake before.

I agree with everyone else on needing more mobilization options in the other watches though. As well as an equipment chest at the start so we can change our gear and not need to leave the lobby to change. I hope we can reuse the intro tile set though and that of a few missions on the surface. Help further show that this is taking place on the surface.

For bosses, I hope the Collector can appear again as one of the bosses we fight. Would be a great way to add it again.

Kora for turning in Watch mission rewards is a pretty nice idea too. As well as repurposing the camp for an outpost too. Would be a great way to revisit that location.

#19
My experience so far

Hello,

Here is my experience so far, trying to reply on ever point of the OP:

Were you able to play with a larger group?

I was able to reach party sizes of 14 people, however clicking the "join" button in the mission screen has always forced me to start alone, which I assume is a bug (I have not tried party finder yet)

Did you enjoy the expansive nature of the area?

The levels being very big was interesting, my favorite has to be the jigsaw area. Clockwork coming second, and Candlestick at a low low third place.

Jigsaw is most interesting to me because of how permissive it is with moving around, something the clockwork area tries to also do with the crane, but the first few minutes of a fresh watch can feel a bit long, until the crane room is reached.

Candlestick in that regard has no appeal, while mewkats can be very mobile, but knights get no option for moving around a little quicker, furthermore, the candle mechanic makes it quite annoying to traverse on the long run, I feel there could be more of the blue candles in some of the rooms. Candlestick level pieces also have a lot of instances of "tile puzzles", where players have to wait for a path to clear, or repeatedly break tiles to move, which makes traversing a MASSIVE version of this level theme very, very, annoying.

Were you encouraged to seek out other players to play with?

I was, the bug cited above did mean that I always joined newly created instances of the watch, and players would join me. Once people started to join tho, I felt compelled to try and stick together, or cross their paths to see how we could help each other.

Do you have ideas or suggestions for ways to improve the experience of The Watch?

I do have a few suggestions, some are more of a polishing pass, others I judged to be necessary for a more pleasant & refreshing experience.

First off, I think the clockwork and candlestick in particular could heavily benefit from more unique & diverse prefabs, there have been instances of both clockwork and candlestick where I encountered the exact same room 2, 3 or even 4 times, which made it feel redundant (this also happens in jigsaw, but the car rails made it less of an issue to me). This was especially an issue when the rooms that repeated this many times were rooms full of spikes, or that required me to break a lot of individual tiles, or times that require more shots to be broken.

Candlestick in particular got old and repetitive very quickly, being pursued by a big invincible kat works in the clockwork because there is minimal backtracking and the levels are linear. But in the watch, that fella became an annoyance quickly, especially because watch levels seem to tend to have a lot of dead ends. And as said above, some of these levels pieces repeating does not help, and the near total lack of blue candles also makes traversing annoying, especially if the watch is really intended to be for knights of all ranks.

One last thing I was thinking of for candlestick: I think it would be worth experimenting with mixing graveyard and scarlet fortress prefabs into the "Candlestick" Watch level. I say prefabs because most of the watch as it currently stands re-uses arcade levels, but I also think more unique pieces could highly benefit all 3 of the watch levels, so the watch feels even more unique, and players don't get bored of seeing the same pieces as they do in the arcade.

On a similar redundancy point, enemies re-spawning is good, and interesting, but in some specific rooms, I think this mechanic should be removed. More specifically in the gremlin forge, the crane room, the hall leading up to basil, and maybe the leader/boss rooms.

#20
Amazing concept, a bit rough.

Were you able to play with a larger group?
Yes, and it was an insane amount of fun. I found most people loved playing on the Jigsaw Valley, just because of how fun the cars were to ride around in; and I agree with a lot of what's said by others, the interactable vehicles and machines are an awesome evolution of gameplay. They add a new level of interaction to the levels and encourage the social aspects of the game significantly. Multiple times I'd have someone stop to pick me up in a car to drive me around, or drop off supplies via crane like vials.

Did your party make it into the same Watch instance?
I played on my own most of the time joining whoever, but there was rarely a time I ever found a Watch without anyone in it, with the exception of the higher tier ones being a bit drier.

Did you enjoy the expansive nature of the area?
I'm mixed, but overall positive. There was a bit of running around which felt a bit slow (candlestick seems widely agreed upon as the biggest offender), as well as the new minimap being a bit clunkier compared to the one I'm familiar with, particularly being unable to move, but the new modes of transportation made up for it.

I feel like new tiles in general might be very helpful for merging everything together better. For example, the Destruction Zone segments that spawn in the Gremlin watch were wonderful for quickly navigating through the map as they were effectively connected to several parts. The new roads the Jigsaw Valley were also very helpful for solving that problem too. More tiles like that would greatly enhance the Watch I think, and also just add more uniqueness and variety in general to the levels.

Were you encouraged to seek out other players to play with?
With tasks, I often found that I would help if it was convenient, I happened to share the same task, or if I was just running around exploring. I think more tasks focused around helping other players would help with this a lot, I've seen some good suggestions here already with regards to that.

For the new arenas, 100%. Those arena's are possibly the most fun I've had in this game when doing them in a HUGE group of 10+ knights, they are scaled very well for a high player count, with the exception of the boss itself, which is a bit underwhelming in comparison.

I also just found in general it was fun to be in large parties, there was always some chatter happening somewhere and it felt very lively; like a club.

Do you have ideas or suggestions for ways to improve the experience of The Watch?
I would highly recommend creating new tiles to go with the old for The Watch's gamemode that are much more open-ended with more exits/entrances to make navigation a bit cleaner.

The difficulty on the boss enemies themselves should 100% be scaled up and I feel you should 100% push your boundaries with this, like allowing the boss enemy to be something rare or unique, (things like almirian guards, dreadnaughts, phantoms, things not commonly seen), or maybe even story bosses (Arkus, Collector, even Ironwood Sentinel would be fun to see again but beefed up; maybe with new vague names). There is a huge amount of potential with these raid-like bosses given how well the arena before them is balanced around large amounts of players.

Overall, I really enjoy the new content, and I feel that it should be expanded upon greatly as there is an INSANE amount of potential here for content that all players can participate in.

#21
I fed you, please feed me

Were you able to play with a larger group?
Not really, largest group I found was 6 people but most the time I was on my own most the time. I would like to experience a full or nearly full lobby though. Could be because of low player count on the test server and/or not being on during the initial hype. Party finder could be useful for this or someway to search for bigger groups or require a minimum amount of players to start.
Did your party make it into the same Watch instance?
I invited someone once and they had no problem joining, don't have anymore data other than that.

Did you enjoy the expansive nature of the area?
Yes the large maps are fun to explore and the kart roads are handy for traversing the area

Were you encouraged to seek out other players to play with?
I did get stuck with help someone with an objective due to being in and empty lobby but thankfully had a friend online whom I could invite to help them help me help them. If I had others in the instance I would of asked naturally but that was not the case. While using a kart in a lobby with other players it is definitely a natural state to give people a ride or hitch a ride and team up on objectives.

Do you have ideas or suggestions for ways to improve the experience of The Watch?
Most ideas for this category I have covered little by little in each previous feedback question but a few obvious but simple ones would be:
-Keep The Watch as a permanent thing not a cycling event, I assume this is already the case but if it is not it should be.
-Seems like this is meant to encourage interactions with other knights but some sort of private party version would be very very nice. By doing this you give the players keys to a lot of fun community content with minimal effort, as someone who hosts a lot of live community events this is super necessary. I have many ideas with this and I'm sure many others do too and having access to a customizable 16 player lobby and access to karts and cranes is an amazing thought. Please, please heavily consider custom lobby options for this experience.

#22
The Overall Feedback on The Watch

Were you able to play with a larger group?

  • Yes, it is very easy to find a party during peak time.

Did your party make it into the same Watch instance?

  • Yes, there're party finders and join via the friend list. Very handy.

Did you enjoy the expansive nature of the area?

  • After 10k hours of spiralknights. To me, they mostly feel like reused rooms. I wish to see all of them being made with this game mode-exclusive set pieces and maybe tilesets. Right now, the undead Watch is the weakest of them all.
    I like the driving road for the Jigsaw Valley one. And I wish to see more of it, or make a central area wide and big with gremlins watch towers // camps scattered around. So you can drive by and gather their supplies.
  • The undead Watch Need love the most. I wish to see the map being reworked with its own exclusive rooms and being mixed with a Graveyard section. think about the Moorcroft Manor map, but extended!
  • Add a way to make teleports for the undead Watch map, as a form of fast travel

Were you encouraged to seek out other players to play with?

  • YES!!! And it is much more fun with more players!

Do you have ideas or suggestions for ways to improve the experience of The Watch?

  • Add a player TELEPORT mechanic to the Undead Watch! How it works is copy-paste from my other post.
  • Locate an ancient Tome The book will be hidden in a random bookshelf within the level. And magical tome stands will also spawn in the level (4 stands total). After the player locates a book. They carry it back to a tome stand, and the stand will require 4 minerals in order to perform a ritual and open a portal gate between the tome stands. Only one book is needed (but the number can be adjusted)
  • This basically fits the owlite theme for being a magic user and ritual with the Kat tribe. Plus, adding teamwork to locate a book and find a tome stand + mineral to activate them... and, most importantly, TRANSPORTATION
  • Basil should be spawned with a mini blue candle nearby him. I got Grimalkins bit 2 times trying to trade.
  • Bring back HP sharing to revive. This will not be overpowered for this mode, plus this will help reinforce the social aspect of this game mode.
  • Add arsenal station at the start of the level
  • Add text telling the player that the supply dock can be overcharged (upgraded) to be able to open gremlin crates
  • Add more supply crate rarities and types, from common material to something more rare. (which can be a rare chance drop from mini bosses and bosses)
  • Add pinging system for the map
  • Make special map allowed you to walk while having it opened would be 100% better

I might add more later, but I see others also have pretty good suggestions in their hands.

#23
+1 to Aino's suggestions.

I also think a Free Lost Spirits mission objective could add some spice to the Undead Watch theme. Or purifying Phantoms - you know, the red Knight Ghosts? Perhaps interacting with certain features prompts them to spawn and chase the knight that activated them.

Side note: Huge fan, HUGE fan, of the resizable Minimap. I like that option a LOT.

Oh, and it's cute that Kora cheers for you when you return to Haven.

#24
The Watch Feedback

Were you able to play with a larger group?

I found the jigsaw valley level to be packed and it all went well, super fun. The other levels on the other hand were very inactive and practically just a big solo mission.

Did you enjoy the expansive nature of the area?

I like the concept but I think it could use some work, the maps I played out didn't quite feel well put together, so it felt a bit too much like the proc gen of the clockworks where everything is just mashed together.

Were you encouraged to seek out other players to play with?

Generally no, not unless they had something i needed for my objectives such as the carts.

Do you have ideas or suggestions for ways to improve the experience of The Watch?

So looking back at my critique of the proc generation, I think games like Terraria are a good example of what to emulate, players start off in generally safer zones, moving into the more dangerous ones the further from spawn (or the elevator in SK's case). Perhaps for the Gremlin levels the further from Haven and deeper into gremlin territory you get, the harder zones are their lab/factory levels? Same could go for slimes, could have scarlet fortress/Jelly Palace inspired zones the further from Haven you get. I would also like if some of the danger zones even borrow stuff from the prestige danger missions.

#25
My Feedback

Were you able to play with a larger group?

unfortunately not so far. I haven't tried logging on during peak hours so I expect this to change (especially considering this is the test server with limited playerbase).

Did you enjoy the expansive nature of the area?

Yes! this element contributed to it overall feeling very different from the typical gameplay loop of Spiral Knights, it's a refreshing change of pace. However, as others have pointed out, it's not without its downsides. The "aurora isles" levels seem to handle the issue of transportation in the most fun and well-thought-out ways; the carts are fantastic! the most fun I've ever had moving around in SK, very silly.

The Clockwork Watch levels have their own solution for transportation (gremlin hoist), but it is entirely dependent on party members/collaboration; I understand the intention behind this and I don't dislike it, encouraging socialisation in Spiral Knights can only be positive for the game and its playerbase, but even when Spiral Knights was at its peak popularity years ago, there would be times when it was hard to find people to team up with, so perhaps there's a way that this solution can be augmented.

As everyone has already pointed out, the Candlestick watch doesn't have any form of fast travel, and is in need of it, people have suggested candles as teleportation points. maybe this can be done.

Were you encouraged to seek out other players to play with?

Yes, in that certain objectives were literally impossible to do on my own. It's unclear HOW exactly one is meant to seek out other players though: at present there's no party system or a party finder like what the arcade/ranked/prestige missions have. You just join and hope that you get dropped in an instance with other people. How your chance of teaming with people is calculated I have no idea.

Do you have ideas or suggestions for ways to improve the experience of The Watch?

Visually, I would love it if The Watch could be made more distinct from regular clockworks exploration; since the setup is that we're performing tasks in the surrounding areas of Haven (as I understand it), it would be nice if the areas could somehow take on some of the theming of the early-game levels that take place on the surface, to sell the idea that this really is happening in the vicinity of Haven.

Aside from more options for fast travel, I would love if Candlestick Watch could have more diverse theming (even disregarding my previous suggestion). The other two Watches we've had access to take tiles/proc gen elements from a number of level types and essentially "kitbash" them together; this mostly works well enough and provides some needed visual variety. All the more uninteresting, then, that Candlestick Watch is exclusively based on Candlestick Keep levels, why not mix it with Graveyard? Maybe even mix in elements from the Legion of Almire Prestige mission. Could be cool.

Overall I'm thoroughly impressed, the sheer number of new mechanics and interesting reworkings of existing ones is nothing to sneeze at, and the objective based nature of The Watch genuinely contributes to it feeling like a different game entirely from that we've grown far too accustomed to. This is a much needed shakeup.

#26
Testing feedback

Were you able to play with a larger group?

* I have played with 8-10 players at the largest, and while it was fun to see so many people in combat, it caused lag, framerate issues and a lot of "trolling" using certain new elements like the carts or crane. (Crane can grab lootboxes and poof them, or send enemies to inaccessible areas, can lock players behind a locked gate without access to a key)
______________________________________________________________

Did your party make it into the same Watch instance?

*Yes, but only if I invited or joined them directly, through random joining the mode I was more often put in solo instances of the Watch.
______________________________________________________________

Did you enjoy the expansive nature of the area?

*Yes, it invokes a different kind of feeling in the game, and the idea is generally fun, there just needs to be more loot to be found, or enemies need to be more plentiful for there to be a reason to stay longer, maybe rotating quests that appear alongside your daily missions, just simple things like being reward x1000 crowns for delivering 5 boxes etc. Some sort of bounties to fill the large parts of the area where nothing happens. (The compound level, jigsaw valley has a lot of empty space)
______________________________________________________________

Were you encouraged to seek out other players to play with?

*Not really, the only quest objective that pushes you to find people is the one that asks you to help out or "back up" a knight doing their mission. This mission/objective shouldn't be in the mode, imo, because you can get into situations where you simply cannot activate it. Maybe make it "spend X minutes near another knight"

______________________________________________________________

Do you have ideas or suggestions for ways to improve the experience of The Watch?

* More objective variety, better descriptions of what to do

* Smaller objectives or a bounty board that gives you reasons to stay "ON WATCH" to earn rewards (it should be "competitive" in the reward sense where the crown or payout needs to be on par with running the arcade)

* Better rewards for fully completing watch objectives, 1x 2* material just isn't it. Straight up give crowns and prestige points, trust.

* Music keeps replaying its startup sound when passing over certain tiles, this is very jarring.

* ! Why not make a new variant of a party button, where instead it goes on a 10 seconds timer/clock, and locks in all the players who stood on it to activate the danger rooms, strongholds and arenas that can be found, i find that better than it just being open and enemies being able to teleport out of the room (wolvers especially).

* Enemies need to respawn a bit faster, at more than 6x players in a map, there is literally nothing to be found since knights have such a quick "time to kill", enemies dont live long, and respawn too slowly.

#27
Overall Feedback on The Watch

Were you able to play with a larger group?
Because of work, I only get time to play really late, after midnight my time. The most I had was 5 knights in once instance. Cool to see we're able to do that! But I think it would be interesting if maybe some NPC knights were running around, at least close to the elevator, if other players are not there to help you out.

Did your party make it into the same Watch instance?
Had no issues joining random parties, and when I left to return to Kora to submit my progress and get the next quest, I was able to join back even when selecting The Watch from Kora's screen. So even if not directly selecting the instance I was just in, I was not joining another random group or making my own, which is nice.

Did you enjoy the expansive nature of the area?
Oh I loved this so much. At times the Yellow and Blue Zones didn't make much sense; I feel like increasing difficulty should always be radiating outward from the Elevator or a central path, which it seemed like it did sometimes and other times not so much.

With how big it is, I like the carts and the Crane to help you navigate, but there wasn't anything to help in the (admittedly one instance I tried of) Candlestick Watch. We don't know a whole lot about the Owlites other than they studied mystic arts, but would it be possible they had a Mystic Book of Travel? Knights who open the book on both ends can travel between them, and there's a decent chance of one spawning at least close to the Elevator, for instance? That or a ritual needs to be completed to finish a runic circle, like we see Devilites/Fiends spawn out of, and players can use that to travel from one side of the map to the other. Maybe at the cost of some minerals for balance?

Were you encouraged to seek out other players to play with?
Operating the Crane was fun, but pointless if another player wasn't along to mess around with or help, or to protect you in case more enemies came knocking. The Carts are very fun! The bash doesn't do much on them, so carrying knights was always more fun to Run-and-Gun (or sword, or bomb). Obviously I couldn't complete the "Help another knight with their task" task when I was playing solo, but since that kind of task does not transfer between Watches it can be hard to finish if people are only playing on the others. And of course, the enemy scaling was wack and nigh impossible to deal with on my own, so I gave up on the Candlestick Watch to try the others that had players online. So in those regards, yes.

Do you have ideas or suggestions for ways to improve the experience of The Watch?
Oh I could go on about ideas...

One big recommendation I have is to make the types of Watch available depend on Knight's rank: if you have made it to Moorcroft Manor, you unlock a Watch defending them instead of Haven, and same for Emberlight. This way, there's more justification for The Watch to be a bit harder all across the board at further depths, instead of having horribly scaled enemies at just depth 5, as well as better loot all around instead of only in certain zones of The Watch.
Access to this could be something to add directly in to Moorcroft and Emberlight as well, since there are areas of those cities that are kinda void/empty and could use some more life. While I wouldn't want to lock the types of environments to the specific city being defended, that might also make a bit of sense lore-wise as well?

I would like for certain Objectives/Tasks to build off of each other as well. Like needing to complete the Crane in order to access an Elite enemy needed to kill the miniboss, or destroying a bunker reducing the enemy presence in an area but causes enemies to start making their way to it from somewhere else in the map to repair it.

I mentioned on the Objectives Feedback already, but while I understand the need to Re-instance, it really takes me out to just suddenly fade to black and wind up in Haven. My idea to make it more fun/immersive: Kora warns the player that enemy forces are staging a final attack, and that you have to get back to the Elevator either before Haven defenses rain a torrent of explosions around the area, decimating it, or the enemy forces close in and take you down. It could change based on the Watch too; for example, a mass of Grimalkins could swoop in and Blue candles start getting extinguished in Candlestick Watch. If you make it back to the elevator during that last minute, you get a Prize Wheel as well as the minerals and the Heat associated with a normal level clear, and it'd be more fun and immersive to encourage players to evacuate rather than just ignore the timer to finish what you're doing.

Guild contributions to The Watch would be fun to see as well. If we want this to be a big social engagement/encouragement thing, then being able to compete with guilds based on a range of player size would be fun. Just for bragging rights, or maybe even an acknowledgement by Kora and HQ about a job well done each week/month?

I've also always had the idea, ever since Energy was called "Crystal Energy" once upon a time, that players could be able to earn a very small amount of energy directly every week or month by performing a set of tasks or mission. Being "Crystal Energy", I always had in mind the idea of Strangers going down to an area full of Moonstone/Blue Minerals and mining the energy with tools, like it was some kind of Ore, and players would escort them or do the mining themselves to earn a whopping 10 to 25 energy each week or something. Not enough to make a big change in the economy, but something small for if you wanted a little bit to buy a spark in case you need it or to save up over time for a pack of orbs. Having an objective similar to that, protecting a stranger or mining some crystal energy and returning it to spawn, would be a cool addition (even if there's no energy reward tied to it). The Strangers deserve some more action, overall I think.

Lastly for now, a really minor detail but Basil in the Candlestick Watch should 100% have the Blue candle on his hat, not his backpack. Similar to the birthday candle accessory placement on a Stranger's hat costume? I get it's not a big deal but it kinda just feels slapped on as is.

#28
If a portal system is added...

If a portal system is added, I figure that the portal itself could be styled similarly to the portals that Devilites spawn from in the tortodrone event - sort of an orb you can see through to the other location? I know that it's a faked effect, but a candlestick-keep-like image and an aura colored to indicate which portals are linked together would probably work.

#29
The watch ambient and location

A small suggestion. I understand that gameplay should be the top priority and that we're currently in the beta phase of this game mode, but I think this is a good opportunity to bring up the atmosphere, background, and overall feel of "The Watch".

I understand that it's set during a patrol around Haven and that it's a large map, so I think it would be really interesting to give it more of an open-world feel (even if it's just a few levels connected together). Right now, it feels like several Clockworks or compounds placed next to each other, with the same floating-island feel that all the levels have. However, if this is the first addition of new level content in a long time, it's a great opportunity to give the environments more depth and atmosphere, similar to the pre-Haven missions (1-1 to 1-4), which take place on the surface and are packed with environmental details. They don't just consist of floating corridors.

Again, I understand that this isn't a priority and that it would require some extra work to create well-designed level layouts that aren't just corridors. However, I think it would be a great way to create visually appealing content. We could even have some The Watch levels set on the surface, with several scenario rooms. One of these could be the old rescue camp or even the crash site (including its miniboss), which I believe is currently unavailable due to the changes in how new players arrive at Haven.

Thanks a lot, and best regards to the team. Fantastic work!

#30
Were you able to play with a…

Were you able to play with a larger group?
I did get to briefly experience more than 4 players being in the instance.

Did your party make it into the same Watch instance?
I used the party finder to join the person I wanted to join.

Did you enjoy the expansive nature of the area?
Not really. Especially what with being expected to leave the area and return twice, it felt like there was extra travel time for no real reason. And most of the time you can just walk through without fighting.

Were you encouraged to seek out other players to play with?
Well, I was strictly forced to by the mission that said I had to assist someone. I did not feel like any other objective actually had any point in having more players.

Do you have ideas or suggestions for ways to improve the experience of The Watch?
Don't make this a daily reward system. I don't want to feel like I have to log in every day and play for a reward. That's a dark pattern that is already way too common in, primarily free to play mobile games. I want to play when I want to play. it is the kind of dark pattern that will mean that I will never recommend the game to anyone. Making it a daily reward also makes it harder to actually find people to play with, since people who already got their rewards will avoid playing it again with you.

Make it less grindy.

Allow us to report our objective success without leaving the instance.

You added a ton of icons to the map, so it's now quite cluttered around the edges. You should improve visibility of the surrounding icons for the minimap.

#31
Were you able to play with a…

Were you able to play with a larger group?
I was mostly solo so I'll have to see more on this another time

Did your party make it into the same Watch instance?
See first

Did you enjoy the expansive nature of the area?
For the most part yes

Were you encouraged to seek out other players to play with?
See first

Do you have ideas or suggestions for ways to improve the experience of The Watch?

One thing is having the respawns on a longer timer... found several cases where you could end up spawning multiple enemies in actually fairly fast speed, nothing insane but enough to see 3 Gun pups trying to be in one spot... part of it is just having to do with general area completion and I could see a decently long timer for a spot that gets lowered depending on how far away everyone is.

It also fixes another complaint of mine with how the rooms meant for tougher fights seem to be different sections with these fast respawns... you can clear out a spot and then when you need to backpedal some you find yourself pincered by the fresh respawns of the enemies you just cleared out.

AND it also helps stem some of the potential abuse from spam spawning certain enemies like turrets trying to get a Love Pup to spawn.

Another thing is just enemy variety... I've only done the gremlin one so far but a huge chunk of them were just knockers... you could spice it up some by putting a 1 in 10 chance for enemies to spawn in as something else from the family with of course restrictions on some... You obviously don't want Tortodrones spawning in place of a Scuttlebot, but having a Scuttlebot spawn in as a Cinderbot, or maybe a Retrode could be fun

----

Another suggestion is having the minimap be on a different hotkey. The typical minimap can be in the normal spot and function the same way while the big one can be something else... This is mostly because I and probably some other people like to be able to toggle the map while also being able to fight as needed.

If you want a suggestion for the typical minimap you can have it with arrows pointing in the direction of allies and objectives.

-----

Even though I didn't play with others, I would like to suggest a shared move speed just to make partying a lot easier. If you have someone bringing a Mercurial Mail with 2 Somnambulist Totems and a Sprite Perk of Swift Steps then everyone in the group should get that speed.

You could argue that it would make some gear too good but it could also be argued that groups could use this as a role for someone to have to support their teammates rather than everyone being forced to run MSI boosting items to keep up with the one or two people outrunning everyone.

#32
**Were you able to play with…

**Were you able to play with a larger group?**

Only up to 4 one time, mostly 2-3. I am in eu so maybe not so busy and also a bit laggy.

**Did your party make it into the same Watch instance?**

Yes was easy to join friends

**Did you enjoy the expansive nature of the area?**

To be honest, not really. I dont feel like it added much, in fact I mostly found it irritating, taking a long time to get to different objectives, and then you have to go back and forth carrying stuff, just very annoying. I also felt it doesnt really fit in well with my idea of the game.

**Were you encouraged to seek out other players to play with?**

no one was on when I was :(

**Do you have ideas or suggestions for ways to improve the experience of The Watch?**

I don't like the "difficulty" being increased by making mobs really tanky. It felt like I was using a 1 star weapon trying to kill mobs in tier 3 in the red areas. I think increasing their numbers and increasing environmental hazards is the right way. imo, prestige missions are excellent examples for fun, challenging levels. (with bad rewards)

I am not generally a fan of these extraction style things. they seem a bit directionless, transient and unsatisfying to me.

#33
I like this gamemode!

I'll preface by saying I am eager to see this hit the public build! This' got me spinning so many different wheels with how exciting this is! I'll address the bullet points that I can. I hope my input's useful!

'Were you able to play with a larger group?'
-When playing I only managed to see...Two other people in separate parties, which by the nature of the preview server I expected. Nonetheless I enjoyed working alongside them for objectives.

Did you enjoy the expansive nature of the area?
-I really enjoyed the Jigsaw and Clockworks locations, the Jigsaw karts were really fun and the unique structures in the clockworks watch was full of fun surprises. I can't say I liked how claustrophobic and obstructed the candlestick tileset felt, with or without grimalkins chasing.

Were you encouraged to seek out other players to play with?
-Given how the Red zones are built it feels like other players are highly encouraged, otherwise I think that yes I would've been inclined to play with others should the need call for it.

Do you have ideas or suggestions for ways to improve the experience of The Watch?
-Red zones are painful for what you have to work with, even with the right equipment for the job, Red zones still ended up making light work of me and things like Vitapods and health capsules do not drop very frequently to alleviate this issue, especially when my shield is knocked out instantly in these areas even with the right damage resistances. I wouldn't say to dial them down though as opposed to giving us more means to comfortably work with them survival-wise. Another issue I ran into concerning red zones is I had to play so cowardly around one that I ended up running the timer out for the floor to shuffle itself around, and I didn't have anyone join along the way so I ended up doing it solo.

-I don't want to ruin Jigsaw watch since it's my favourite one, but I was preparing for the gremlins/Elemental in the beast-specific watch. If I had any way of mediating this I'd split the Jigsaw watch into jigsaw Valley and Aurora Isle and have the former be an alternative to Gremlin-watch with Aurora being the Beast/Pierce watch. This' ultimately a pet-peeve though.

#34
Mixed feelings

I have mixed feelings about the new content. I've played a few times, and had a relatively good time. My first impression was mostly confusion... which I'm assuming when the actual content is released, there will be more information and tutorials, etc. So my confusion is probably a mute point. But as is, it just isn't super obvious what is going on. I have figured a few things out, like the exclamation points on the map being objectives.

I think the content is moving in a good direction. I really liked being able to have more than 4 players at a time. The max I played with has been 5 others. It was obvious that most of them had played the watch more than I had. The maps are big, but not too big. I have concerns about how often we will find a good group to play with. Most of the time I was alone, or there was 1 other player.

I really enjoy the carts. They are a fun addition. Though it can be annoying to not know when you are about to be rammed by a gremlin who stole your cart. Would be nice to have an impact warning or something since the carts are so fast, there just isn't much you can do to get out of the way.

I was unimpressed with the rewards for completing missions. 2 gremlin gears...? For killing 100 gremlins? Yikes, pretty sure they already dropped those, and I don't need them. Hopefully the rewards get better the further you get. Though needing to kill 250 or more mobs will take some time. Kinda feels like busy work.

I have not been able to get the crane to do much... Probably just me, but I try using the input it says, but it didn't do what I thought it should. So I can't really give much feedback about it

Another commenter said: "I don't like the "difficulty" being increased by making mobs really tanky. It felt like I was using a 1 star weapon trying to kill mobs in tier 3 in the red areas. I think increasing their numbers and increasing environmental hazards is the right way. imo, prestige missions are excellent examples for fun, challenging levels" I do not agree that adding more mobs and hazards is the answer... I, personally, can't stand the overcrowded areas in SK. My internet is not good, so it's just annoying and frustrating to get hit constantly even though I had my shield up, or moved out of the way. I thing the answer is just make the mobs killable (scaled to the knight power??)

That's my 2 cents for now. Probably not that helpful.

#35
The Watch for all

If you want to make this mode for all players despite of rank, add autoscale. It's not so hard. Enemy has 100% HP. T1 equipped player see 160 HP and 40 dmg per hit - 25% real dmg per hit. T3 player see 1600 HP and 400 dmg per hit - the same 25% real dmg. The same thing you can do for yellow/red difficulty zones, set 150% and 200% HP.

As endgame player, i see no reason to play mostly T1 mode with T1 loot. Also red zone is broken, enemies get full T3 HP and DMG, but i stay with limited HP and DMG (T1 limits). Enemies are much stronger than SL and spiked versions. I have to spend few sparks of life just for a few ordinary Stratum 5 boxes.

I don't need T1 loot at all, so if i want to complete zone tasks, i ignore all enemies and can finish zone in 2 minutes.