Test Feedback: Overall Accessibility of The Watch

11 replies [Last post]

Greetings Testers!

Please go join an adventure as part of The Watch in game and let us know your feedback. Specifically for this thread, we're looking for feedback on the overall accessibility of The Watch and how it integrates into the game itself.

  • Was it easy to find? Are the arcade missions still easy to find?
  • Would a newer player be able to find their way?
  • Is it clear that weapons and gear progression still relies heavily on exploring/discovering through the Arcade?
#1
For the mission window, Rank…

For the mission window, Rank missions and their rewards are for many new knights the main way to progress until they hit a Hall of Heroes wall, so having it be the first and most obvious button makes sense.
The Arcade should come right after if your intent is for it to be the next thing to do outside of your rank missions.

I have 3 friends whom I have gotten into the game within the last year and all of them so far were unsure what the main ways to progress were, two just repeating rank missions over and over, and one only doing arcade over and over, which both will make you end up hitting a wall. So your concern about clarity for progression is already a problem with or without The Watch as a new game mode.

I think the changes you made to the "news" page in the uplink are a good way to guide players towards their actual progression. You could also give the rank mission or arcade buttons a little highlight or icon depending on whether or not there is a mission you have not yet completed, but are otherwise eligible for. (Hall of Heroes should only give this if you can actually complete it)

The Watch having it's own "fifth gate" in the Arcade section of Haven ensures a new player just exploring haven as they are encouraged to early on will eventually find it but it must be appropriately distinguished that it is not the same.

A new player may have trouble navigating levels of The Watch without help considering the map button being B by default is a bit odd by modern gaming standards so they may not even realize there is a big version of the minimap fully decked out with a legend for icons and colors.
Pings on the map or even just having the icons for "Attack!" and "Follow me!" and such appear on screen even when the knight using them is off screen (appearing at the edge of the screen with a little arrow perhaps) could at least provide a tool for more experienced players to guide newer folk better.

#2
Thoughts on Accessibility

I believe that access to The Watch is certainly clear. There's certainly some pain points that Leefy brought up - for example, pinging the big map would make a huge impact on guiding players around. I will say that having the big map completely replace the other expanded map messed with my muscle memory often - I feel like the concept of "fast press" and "long press" could make their debut here, as a long press map bringing up the new map while a short press brings up the old one would help with navigation a lot in the levels.

I'm not entirely sure if the progression being linked to rank or Arcade was abundantly clear, though. That's not something that the Watch itself will really be able to showcase, but maybe that will change with future iterations. I do think turning practically every NPC in Haven into a Watch guard is a bit much - the Garrison has their titles floating above their heads and they all have identical dialogue, which is more unnerving than it is helpful. One or two NPCs in each part of Haven would work - bonus points if they have varying dialogue so they feel like different people.

I honestly believe that the Rescue Camp missions serve as a primary guiding force for knights to learn about the mission system. The recent change to make Rescue Camp an optional step after finishing the crash site will do more to harm players who don't understand the mission system and its progression than the Watch does. I think letting players replay those missions is important, but new players should have to play through those missions before reaching Haven.

One thing I think would also help is to not have a watch gate in The Arcade, but instead, have a Watch Outpost in the Haven Town Square, right at the doorway to Haven. If the Watch is supposed to be about patroling and defending Haven, walking out the front door and checking the surrounding area makes more sense than walking into the Arcade - this also properly separates the Watch from the Arcade, creating a better understanding that the two are separate from each other.

#3
Overall Accessibility of the Watch

+ Was it easy to find? Are the arcade missions still easy to find?
Everything seems fine to me. I do note that OCH Missions were moved to the Prestige section of the window, which might be confusing for some veterans, but I don't think discoverability is enormously hampered right now? It does clearly claim to be an expansion mission, clarifying its purpose to returning players like myself and others - but now that it isn't actually an expansion I foresee it perhaps being a source of confusion for new players unaware of its history. This was always the case, though, as that Expansion tab was always set aside for itself (and probably set up expectations of more expansion content to come), so I'd make the case that it's a net improvement so far. Unifying its difficulty modes into tiers similar to selecting an arcade mission also streamlines selection compared to how it was previously implemented. I don't think any clarification needs to be offered to explain the difference between Tier and Difficulty, though - a player should understand that fairly naturally from the arcade itself.

+ Is it clear that weapons and gear progression still relies heavily on exploring/discovering through the Arcade?
This one's sort of a sticking point. For returning players and veterans, yes, but in terms of the New Player Experience, I'm less sure. The manner in which the watch is presented to the player right now makes it quite focal, and I think that would (and SHOULD!) draw players in - but that comes at the cost of minimising the Arcade's importance to that of an "endless dungeon mode" compared to the Watch's mission-based layout. If I really think about it, I feel like a Comms popup from Kora the very first time you go down in a Watch mission could easily clear that up. Something along the lines of "Are you okay? Nasty tumble, etc etc, but you can always come back to protect haven once you've geared up in the Arcade." It might be a clumsy way of doing it but conveyance is important, and centring the fact that the Arcade is (or should be - looking at you, Vanaduke!) a primary source of materials, crowns, heat and progression might be one of those things that deserves a textbox - or even a restructuring of some of the early game Mission dialogue.

---

Additional Thoughts
- I agree extremely strongly with Fangel and Leefy-Serpent here. Fangel especially; I even think that reopening the entryway to the south of Haven to provide access to a Watch Camp via loading transition would *really* add character to the gamemode (I envisage it as perhaps an "upgraded" version of the rescue camp that implies the spiral order is now well-situated. As a matter of fact, a "haven tour" mission like the ones that take you around the bazaar could point take you to the watch camp.). As for accessing Watch areas, I feel like an Elevator works for the Clockwork themed watch, whereas an NPC next to a large Cart works for the Jigsaw Valley watch, as though implying you're going on an expedition over Cradle's surface. Presently nothing immediately stands out for the Candlestick Watch, but a patrol of magic-themed knights looking for a brave escort to come with them would be a nice theming.

[Edit]
- Got too excited to post my post and forgot to note a couple more things I liked from Fangel - Long press vs Short Press for the map key would be a really great idea, but conveying this to players would be an open question. I do like the idea of having an overlay map available for navigation, though; I found myself missing the old style of large map at times.
- Leefy's idea for callouts causing pings would be a huge help. I think that should be added to the gameplay in general, frankly; I've played with enough people that use them actively that it'd just be a net positive.

#4
Feedback on Accessibility

Accessing the watch was really easy, whether that be by talking to Kora, going to the Arcade and using the elevator, or using the mission menu. The pop-up in the news tab reminding me which ones I still need to do is really nice as well. I do feel it shouldn't be the left most option; that should probably be either Rank or Arcade, then whichever of the previous two wasn't first (as these are the current "primary" modes of play), then either prestige or watch (as these are "secondary" modes of play). Everything is still easy to navigate towards from the mission menu, and moving OCH into prestige is probably the best home for it given the expansions as content are not going to be a thing going forward, though it still feels a bit weird seeing it there after being in it's own tab for so long.

Objectives and guidance is simple enough, anyone who's done the basic tutorial could complete most tasks. I think some might struggle with bunkers, as they're not too well explained or immediately obvious as to how you destroy them (given they come from a previously completely optional bit of content designed for more invested players).

I will admit, I have no idea what seperates the Arcade and Watch as activities for now progression wise. This is in part due to the placeholder nature of rewards, but still: both give heat and crowns, both drop materials dependent on what enemy family your fighting, and both have loot boxes to go break open for more stuff. The gameplay style is the main difference between them. The watch seems to be focused on going in, doing your objectives, maybe staying and grabbing a few loot rooms, heading out, and heading back in until you've done the 3 star objective and gotten the SL material, but unless I want that material I'm not sure why I should spend time in the watch at all instead of the arcade once I'm on 3 star gear besides for fun (due to how most of the area in a watch is blue, which seems to only drop Tier 1 mats?). Currently, I do not think the difference between the Watch and the Arcade is clear enough to understand why both modes exist and what their respective purposes are.

#5
1. Yeah, I found the Watch…

1. Yeah, I found the Watch fairly easy to find, as it's the first thing you see when you open the mission menu now. The Arcade missions are easy to find, too, as they're right where they've always been.
2. Very easily. The Watch is clearly telegraphed in the menu!
3. This, I'm not so sure about. I think the Watch being selected automatically might make players think that it's the game's main mode (though I understand if this is the case because we're in the preview server). I also think the Watch button should be moved either to the left or right of the Arcade button, as those two modes are sort of siblings.

#6
Overall Accessibility of The Watch

Was it easy to find? Are the arcade missions still easy to find?

  • The watch is really easy to find from the menu and from the news feed button. Still, this may cause confusion if The Watch is the core gameplay to progress in this game instead of rank missions. Could move the Watch next to the Arcade tab or tuck it around the Coliseum.

Would a newer player be able to find their way?

  • The watch right now is very easy to locate.
  • Although I wish those watch sentries (the NPCs) had a different appearance with slightly different dialogue, all of them should lead to the Watch menu or Kora
  • I have tested with all 3-star and 0-star equipment to simulate an actual new player experience. So fair it feels alright to play. You may not be a powerhouse of damage, but you can still deal considerable damage anywhere. Plus other activities which do not require heavy firepower, like operating cranes or driving a cart around

Is it clear that weapons and gear progression still relies heavily on exploring/discovering through the Arcade?

  • I think it still is. Because the main cause to let player to progress their rank is crowns and sometimes orbs lucky drops from repeatable levels. But I can see The Watch being something to help loosen those gaps. Since this game is pretty bad at telling players their current progression without help from an actual player's guidance
#7
Food now you may feed

Was it easy to find? Are the arcade missions still easy to find
It's in the mission tab, could not be easier to find and the same goes for arcade, rank, and prestige missions. Not entirely sure what is meant by "arcade missions" I see a watch platform got added in the arcade area but people will probably opt for mission tab. Having a gate in haven is good though, something new to stumble into.

Is it clear that weapons and gear progression still relies heavily on exploring/discovering through the Arcade?
I don't think any basic things have changed for weapon/gear progression, also may depend on what rewards will be earned through the watch. Doesn't seem like it'll hurt or confuse any core existing spiral knights systems.

#8
Feedback

Was it easy to find? Are the arcade missions still easy to find?

* The new mode "The Watch" is immediately noticeable upon login, as it is the first menu on a knight's mission/game tab, as well as being noted on the events page to the left. Though a suggestion would be to have the watch be the 4th tab on the missions menu, as not to interfere with missions being the main story progress.

* The main story mission tab is still called "Rank", I think this can cause confusion in new players, perhaps renaming it to "story" or some other term that implies this meaning would be good.

* The arcade as a concept is excellent, and should be the main "gameplay loop" after one completes the missions, while it is easy to find the tab for seasoned players, I think new players may be confused by the meaning of "arcade". Otherwise it is fine.
_______________________________________________

Would a newer player be able to find their way?

* The objectives could use some clarity, accessing the mission itself is simple, either through the missions menu or through Kora herself.

* One issue is that there is no arsenal in the watch area, so players cant really change gear if they mistakenly take the wrong equipment.

* Some mission objectives need to have a description on what to actually do to complete them, such as volatile minerals not specifying needing to do hitless combat. New players will struggle with not getting hit.

_______________________________________________

Is it clear that weapons and gear progression still relies heavily on exploring/discovering through the Arcade?

* No, not really. While it is clear to a seasoned veteran of the game that knows where items drop, currently loot in the watch does not really translate to progression in the actual game. Material drops are low, rarity drops are low and...

* The big issue, heat is very weak, and if a player were to just click "return to kora" they LOSE all their stored heat instead of it leveling up their weapons. This needs to be made clear or heat should directly progress the level bar as players play the watch. Ideally, current exp on weapons should be checkable when pressing the map menu.

#9
Accessibility Feedback on The Watch

Was it easy to find? Are the arcade missions still easy to find?
It was easy enough to find, but it felt wrong. The Rank Missions are the core of progression in the game, and to me the more important aspect of the overall Missions UI/Menu. That should be the first, leftmost item to see when looking at the Missions, then Prestige Next. I'm personally disappointed to see OCH moved to Prestige instead of its own thing, but I understand the need to limit the tabs available I guess... so maybe it should be where the DLC/Expansion tab used to be?

As for Kora being immediately at the fountain in Haven, I am hoping that's just part of the Preview. It feels very "How about here? Should be good enough," to me. My initial expectation was that we would need to check the Arcade for where Sullivan used to be and find a new knight there to inform us about the new content, similar to Anomalie with the mysterious spikes and weather. I don't mind Kora being the one to send us on quests or being in charge of The Watch, but a knight who could have more potential, like Barus, or a new knight would be fun too. Maybe a larger Guardian type knight named Winston, carrying a Kilowatt Pulsar? Just a thought.

Would a newer player be able to find their way?
I would sure hope so. That said, I think that new players shouldn't be finding it as if stumbling on it, but should be given a Rank Mission from Kora to give a brief overview of what it is and what to expect, before giving them access to the tab and directly guiding them to a Sample/Tutorial Watch. This could also teleport them to the NPC's location, similar to going around the Bazaar, to let them know where to find it in Haven.
Then either the game would force them to complete their first Watch to progress in the Rank missions, or let them decide to come back another time if it's not something they want to engage in. Like Kora asking "Are you ready to head out now?" and the player can say "Put me in Coach-I mean, Kora!" or "I'll be sure to put in my time on The Watch later."

Is it clear that weapons and gear progression still relies heavily on exploring/discovering through the Arcade?
Thinking on it, I don't suppose so, no. Players who do a bit of arcade and Rank before jumping in to The Watch might not realize that the harder enemies are from deeper tiers, and that they are meant to do the Arcade to grind and level up rather than keep it social and casual in The Watch, and they might wonder why it's taking so long to earn the crowns or materials necessary to progress. If I were a newcoming player, I'd find The Watch to be much more engaging than the standard Arcade, and sticking to The Watch might leave me frustrated that I'm not progressing through the Rank missions faster. This is definitely something that players should unlock after reaching Rank 4-1, at least. Maybe even after beating Rank 5-1? Regardless, this is something that I can see players getting stuck in a loop of playing and enjoying but never progressing past, with where The Watch currently stands.

#10
Feedback

Was it easy to find? Are the arcade missions still easy to find?
It was essentially impossible to miss the button to play The Watch. Arcade wasn't moved, so if it was easy before it still is. What did move was the Rank and Expansion missions. This way, it feels like The Watch is the primary mode you're supposed to play. I don't like how the expansion was put with Prestige. I do think it could just continue having its own tab, personally. I do prefer Rank being the first button, especially since when you start out, it's what you're supposed to do until at least when you reach the second hall of heroes mission, which is the first roadblock.

Would a newer player be able to find their way?
Find their way where? To what they're supposed to play? Maybe. Probably not, unless they're supposed to play the watch until they're done with that.

Is it clear that weapons and gear progression still relies heavily on exploring/discovering through the Arcade?
Probably not. Not that it currently really does. Gear progression in the current game primarily consists of grinding whichever is the last boss mission you have access to for crowns.

#11
My only grievance with the…

My only grievance with the Watch is its position in the Missions tab.
Since it's taken up the place of Expansion section, I'd like the mission categories to stay in that same order as well, that is to say:
Rank > Prestige > The Watch > Arcade
Alternatively, since this is a relatively obscure and optional mode, it could be placed below Arcade on the priority list:
Rank > Prestige > Arcade > The Watch

Also, regarding the Arcade. It seems to have a new active elevator specifically for the Watch. If possible, I'd like to see it relocated to either the far left end or the far right end. Having it placed awkwardly in the middle feels extremely out of place, and disorienting when it comes to ordering the gates.