Test Feedback: The Watch Objectives

18 replies [Last post]

Greetings Testers!

Please go join an adventure as part of The Watch in game and let us know your feedback. Specifically for this thread, we're looking for feedback on Objectives and how they are used during your Watch rotation.

  • Is the assignment of Objectives clear?
  • Is the way you find an Objective clear?
  • Were you able to complete your Objectives?
  • Did you enjoy some of the new tasks more than others?
  • Do you have any other feedback on Objectives for The Watch?
#1
Confusion possible

Sometimes when joining a watch in progress the objective you want to complete could already be no longer present on the map (all bunkers destroyed, all barricades destroyed, etc.) which does not seem to give any indication or marker, which can be quite confusing for objectives you haven't completed before and thus don't know what to look out for.

#2
Objectives felt engaging but odd

It took me a bit to understand the objectives exactly. Having your current quests be highlighted on the main map instead of referencing a key would clear that up. It took me a while to understand what the special slime was supposed to be since the map was cleared of them, so the icons looked a bit different. Some way to revive the lieutenants after they've all been killed (maybe they respawn on a set timer after the main boss is killed?) would help with that.

The tasks I completed were fun - the best one I liked was the one about helping someone else complete their task. That felt pretty good and encourages the social aspect this seems to be going for. That being said, the tasks would certainly hit a limit where they're not as engaging - the "kill 250 slimes" one is fine, but at a certain point you're just driving around the stage wondering when the minis will finally respawn. Some sort of "endless battle room" that's a bunch of T2 monsters would really help make that objective not too big of a slog.

I will also say it was not clear at all to me that I had to speak to Kora in Haven after completing a Watch objective to get my reward. I would click the button to collect the reward, end up in the Haven spawn area, and then wonder where my reward was. The mission system gives you the reward upon leaving the floor. I don't mind talking to Kora for that, just have the button for claiming the reward actually place you in front of Kora so it's clear she has our reward.

Clearing the objectives wasn't too difficult once I understood the assignments, and while I can't say I know for sure what the whole spread of assignments are, I definitely feel like adding more in the future shouldn't be too big of a problem.

... That being said, Basil should absolutely spawn with a blue candle on his back. Trying to trade a mineral to him in Candlestick was really awkward with Grimalkins deciding to munch on us while we were shopping.

#3
Feedback on Objectives

+ Is the assignment of Objectives clear?
Yes! So far they set clear expectations and are not ambiguous, in part because of indicators.

+ Is the way you find an Objective clear?
The availability of objective indicators when the objective window is visible (Right edge of the screen) helps enormously, but exploring and completing tasks on the fly is also an enjoyable experience.

+ Were you able to complete your Objectives?
Yes, certainly so far. The only hiccup encountered so far is the Crane objective, but I am reluctant to suggest any means of controlling for that. So far, players have been extremely civil in letting other players use the crane when asked, and the option to reinstance into a different group by joining the same mission from the mission selection dialogue exists to counter the very rare instances where a player doesn't heed a request - either because they missed it or were having too much fun with the crane to want to let it go (and it really IS fun to play with, especially when coordinating with other players).

+ Did you enjoy some of the new tasks more than others?
So far, I have encountered mostly activity-based objectives rather than loot-based or count-based objectives. At present, I find that Red Zones can be challenging to handle - though I also note that in the Slime-Themed Watch missions, there are forges dotted around that allow a player to reinforce their gear. I imagine that Red Zones are intended to be handled by a large group of players, but the power with which they can attack a player does sort of guarantee a knockdown for the unprepared and if that player gets unlucky to be struck twice, it guarantees the use of a spark. Introducing forges to the Clockwork Themed map that "activate" the conventional tier-based health boost and protection boost provided by armor for the duration of the watch or until a player falls might be nice to see. Hardened Armor I and Hardened Armor II, for instance?

Another thing I noted was that count-based objectives do get a little long. Instead of them finishing at an objective requiring 250, I wonder about 250 being the *total* goal, with milestones along the way at 50 and 125 to 250 total enemies contributing to an objective set's completion - I think this would motivate a player to finish all three star ranks of a Watch by providing one clear throughline that you're always working on, but I'm still feeling it out. I am aware that fighting in groups increases the count more quickly, and where it is right now does feel good - but I can see it potentially becoming draining after multiple consecutive sessions of play. At this time, though, it's pretty fun hunting, so I'm comfortable with it right now.

---

Additional thoughts
- I agree with Fangel that speaking to Kora is a process that should be streamlined in a similar way to how slash commands work - you should, on clicking the "go to Kora" button, actually go to Kora and auto-interact.
- I agree also with Leefy-Serpent that already-completed objectives in an instance could either be marked, or the game could attempt to detect an instance with those objectives still available and attempt to join that party if a player hasn't already tried to join a friend's instance.

#4
Objectives are fun

The objectives are well marked and decently descriptive, with a few acting as tutorials on the new game elements. I like this a lot: gives the player direction without directly telling them how to do something. Being able to the area map with a legend by pressing the map is great, as it helps you plan a route, but losing access to the expanded map that still lets you move makes actually navigating feel clunky at times. Additionally, some objective markers (specifically for objectives with multiple valid targets) change focus weirdly, meaning following the marker on the edge of your screen isn't always the best.

Objectives that are individual (bring a crate, grab a volatile crystal, get recon data, kill x mobs, etc.) are fine, they work, give you a task to get done and are easy to focus down. Objectives that are based on the watch instance are a little less intuitive. As people have said, sometimes you start a watch and their are no markers for a task left on the map because you've loaded into an instance that has already completed those tasks. This would be fine if the blue and yellow zone tasks were not easy to solo, but they are easy to solo; meaning rather than cooperate, a lot of the time one person will go off and do their objective because they want to get it done, and then no-one else gets a chance to either help out or at least get credit for being nearby. So, players looking to get watch objectives done might have to jump into new watches until they get one where they can actually get their objective done, rather than joining a watch and sticking till it is completed.

This is not true for red zone tasks, which feel almost mandatory to work together on, due to how hard enemies hit (typically breaking a shield with some overspill in one hit), how little damage you do to them, and how many there are. This is quite fun, I think the cooperation here, whilst chaotic, is a fine pay-off given that you have to kill 3 enemies in the zone to get access which is something that is easy to do with 16 players in a lobby. The loot is also pretty good at the end of these rooms, and tying them to the 3 star watch objectives is fine. The bosses that spawn in these rooms are a complete joke though, they need massive improvements if you plan to keep them as bosses.

I feel the curve between Blue/Yellow zones and Red zones needs to be evened out to encourage more cooperation, but that's also true for a lot of the watch objectives. The Cars and Crane at their best when used to achieve things that a single knight would take far too long or take far too much effort to do, but none of the objectives directly encourge this. The crate objective gets close, but can be soloed with a car, or just carried back most of the time (using the crane to take it over would likely mean someone else opens it before you get there). The objective that needs you to help another knight do their objective is good, and should be kept. For encouraging cooperation, an objective that is either shared to the whole watch instance and takes a lot of effort (e.g. Haul 30 gremlin crates back to the lift) or a series of objectives that needs to be completed in a single watch run (E.g. kill a lieutenant and kill the boss) would go a way in encouraging players to group up to get them done, rather than all doing seperate things and occasionally running into eachother.

#5
1. Yes, how objectives are…

1. Yes, how objectives are assigned are very clear.
2. How I find objectives is quite clear, though sometimes I get confused because the arrows point directly at the objective, so I get a little lost trying to find them.
3. ...Kind of. Most of the objectives are very clear and simple to complete, but I had issues with some:
- "Grow a volatile mineral in combat": This could use a little tutorializing. Initially, I thought I had to bring a monster over to a mineral deposit and kill them near it. It would be nice to see an info node explain the mechanics.
- "Beat a lieutenant/surging slime": These enemies don't respawn, so it can be hard to complete these objectives if you end up in an already active or cleared-out instance.
- "Support a fellow knight in their objective": I have no idea how this works. It's unclear how exactly to do this, so I found it frustrating trying to complete it.
Otherwise, the objectives work well.
4. I enjoyed fighting lots of enemies and defeating tough foes more than delivering crates. However, delivering the crates was easy, so I don't mind it.
5. It would be neat to see more objectives that encourage cooperation or puzzle solving.

#6
Mostly fine

Aside from one or two, the objectives were fairly clear to figure out - the new expanded map and map markers/indicators help a lot with these.

Most of these are fairly straightforward aside from a couple - sometimes the lobby happens to have some stuff missing like any lieutenant mobs or barricades because they've already been taken care of, which forces you to hop off to a different lobby. I was also confused by the crate delivery one at the very first impression of The Watch, cause I didn't really know where to look at first because all the crates might've been already taken in the lobby. I was able to guess on one with leveling up the volatile crystal, though that probably needs something to be explained in some way as it could be confusing to others as it's fairly vague. Supporting a knight in completing one of the objectives is also fairly vague as we don't know what exactly counts for it.

The general kill quests (e.g 250 slimes) weren't exactly problematic, though feels like it ends up usually being one of the last requirements for finishing the objectives, so sometimes you end up just going around waiting for mobs to respawn which can get a little tedious.

I agree that the Basil objective in Candlestick Watch needs a lit blue candle around him as it is awkward both for the objective side and vendor side of things.

I would love to see more objectives that encourage cooperation between players as well, nothing too complex, one example something that could require a couple people present for a party button perhaps that enables something on the map like opening a gate to a room that leads to an objective

#7
Thoughts after my very first expedition (1/2)

Usually I am the type of guy who first analyses a new system and gets to the nitty-gritty of it and tries to understand things myself before just going out and asking questions.
But since it is especially asked with new players in mind, I will just rush ahead some feedback after 1 single instance now and my thoughts when first encountering this system.

Is the assignment of Objectives clear?

  • No.
The very first thing I saw when getting to the missions' window of the watch were a lot of... objectives(?) or tasks to do that are pretty nothingtelling. Well one of them was ,,kill 10 gremlins", which is very self-explaining.
The other objectives though are tasks with new terminology that is difficult to grasp from the get-go.
Checking the other 2 watch missions, they seem to be pretty much the same, but with different enemies or something.
So I just went and entered a Gremlin themed mission. Because it was the first one on the list.
  • Inside that mission, the first thing that confused me was a missing arsenal station, that is usually at levels. So I can not adjust my equipment here. This was inconvenient at first, but in hindsight it makes players want to pick a loadout before entering the mission and probably have other players not be waiting.
  • The very next thing I did in order to orientate myself was to press B in order to see more than what I can see with the tiny minnimap in the top right.
  • I like the various symbols and especially the colour used to indicate different zones of difficulty displayed there.
  • As someone Who generally uses the ,,large map" in levels a lot to navigate and orientate, it is actually very annoying and bothersome that I am not able to actually keep walking around while the large map is open. So I constantly have to stop, check the map, then close the map, then continue fighting or walking. This leaves little time to actually learn the symbols along the way, since the forced stopping does interrupt normal gameplay.
  • The map has a legend on the side, but it is a lot of back-and-forth to get to the meaning of symbols.
  • Here I would like to suggest to add tooltip windows over the various symbols on the map itself, too, when hovering over them with your mouse.
  • Ultimately everything was so overwhelming that I fell back to default approach and treated it like a normal level. This included me to going down the first path that had what looked like a treasure room in the end. Since there were enemies and boxes along the way, it means that no one has been there before. Right? ....Right?
  • Well, as it turns out, I ended up in a dead room. No treaures, no key, nothing. But a simple podest that looks like something should be there at this location. That was a disappointment. On top of that, the mobs in the section that I just cleared up did respawn when I got to that empty square room; so I had an equally tedious way back. First I did interpret that respawning sound as ,,I just completed an objective".
  • In hindsight, that section in the end probably had a key at one point, which was grabbed by players who came here before I joined that instance - while ignoring boxes on the way.
  • Also in hindsight, it turned out that there was a greyed out symbol over the area that did lead towards the empty end room. But I have no idea, if that was there before or if I interacted with something that greyed it out.
  • After hitting that annoying empty dead end and walking back through respawning monsters, I wanted to join where the other players were, who initially were fighting in a red area. Since they left that red area, I assume that one is now cleared, too, and went towards the opposite of the map, where they were now. It was a section that got a crane control thing.
  • Now is that crane thing an objective? I have no idea. I were just going to the closest symbol on map, since good stuff seems to happen when interacting with something indicated there. Like getting materials from Gremlin Tool Boxes and the likes. But I have no idea if this is even supposed to be something that I need to do here.
  • Suddenly somehow there was a message about ,,all objectives having been cleared" and the other players just ran off somewhere while I was still trying to figure out how to tick off an objective with the crane. Or how to actually operate it in the first place. It did not let me pick up blocks or pots after all. Eventually I just gave up on the crane and went to another... objective? Now alone though, since everyone else left.
  • I encountered a ,,survey the area" objective that has a very nice top-down camera angle that allows to watch the clockwork from nearly straight up in eagle perspective. This objective was pretty straight-forward, the circle filling was also instantly obvious to me, too.
  • Somewhere I found a crate. I recall there being a crate station at the start, so I made my way back to there. Well, that was the plan, but I suddenly had a countdown on my screen, which indicated that I probably get kicked out of that instance soon? No one mentioned a time limit! :x
  • Picking up the crate again after placing it down was quite janky. It might be that the placeholder texture is to blame for an inconsistent hitbox though. So I assume/hope that this is not an issue after that item got its proper visuals.
  • However, at that point I thought that picking up could only be done after a room was cleared. Which was not really helpful with a countdown on the top, too.
  • I just reached the box station after the screen faded out. When puting the box inside, it went back to fully visible again, then I was teleported out. I think I actually got that box to where it was supposed to go, but I have no idea what this actually did or if it rewarded anything.
TL;DR: Objectives are a hella confusing and there is too much information at once for a first impression.

Is the way you find an Objective clear?

After having done one level, I believe that if I focus on a single task at hand, I can find what I need on the map and go there now.
But there is still extremely much information on the map. And this also conflicts with my completionist nature to clear out everything on the floor and not just go for objectives alone.
I know there are a lot of rushers in this game nowdays, but I prefer to chill and chat and do stuff together; and not just speedrun all objectives without dropping a word or opening boxes and heading towards the next instance.
#8
Thoughts after my very first expedition (2/2)

Were you able to complete your Objectives?

  • The first instance was too confusing and I did not finish everything. I randomly ticked what looks like all but 1 objective. When entering a new mission to look something up for this post, I had a random interactible thing aside the elevator that gave me a material. This completed the mission though. But that again was also completely random and not aimed at from my side.
  • So... technically I completed my objectives? But morely accidentally than on purpose. ,,Kora" wants to talk to me now, wherever he is. But I guess I will find out when pressing the button that tells me to report to Kora.

Did you enjoy some of the new tasks more than others?

  • So far, I like the exploration one the most.
This is primarily because it was the only thing that was instantly clear, featured a new mechanic, and especially since it was moving the camera angle. The camera is something that usually is set in stone in Spiral Knights and only ever changes in some very few cases. This is me as a vateran speaking who is excited about an interested gimmick that was not touched upon much.

Do you have any other feedback on Objectives for The Watch?

  • When seeing these objectives for the first time, they are straight up overwhelming. So I want to suggest adding some sort of introduction to that system as a mission for new players, in which they can take their time to learn how things work generally. Instead of just throwing new peoples into that system and see if they drown or learn swimming in the process.
  • That introduction should be very limited and only explain the most basic elements. Some elements are better left to finding out along the way, too, while working with other players.
  • Additionally, monsters should either not drop something or only drop loot when clearing a section for the first time. To avoid farming in a mission instead of the real thing.
  • Objectives could also get arrow marks on the screen, like the arrows pointing towards checkpoints in a Lockdown match. Cleared objectives would disappear then and stop getting displayed.
  • On top of the current difficulty colouring, there could be another colour to indicate cleared areas. Like a grey colour on the map.

I might have more to write later, but those are my thoughts after my very first encounter with that system as an inexperienced player, before really getting into understanding it.

#9
Feeding Back

Is the assignment of Objectives clear?
-Objectives seem clear and easy to figure out.
-The crane seems like it should have more to it, it unlocks the ability to transport stuff but the objective is only to unlock it. Should have more to it like a clear objective that requires the crane, using it to move boxes for other objectives is nice but could definitely use some more content for that objective.
-Destroy Gremlin bunker, a little unclear since we're used to simply shooting them to destroy them but after a few shots not working it's pretty clear you need to defeat all the local enemies.

Is the way to find the Objective clear?
Yes, the routes seem pretty clear and straight forward, objective arrows on the ground could be useful potentially but that might make it to easy.

Were you able to complete your Objectives?
-Map Timer, I had a few times the map cycle/timer kicked me out mid objective with only a 60 second warning, it'd be nice if a small timer was somewhere on the hud so you have an idea of how long you have. 60 second warning is nice but it is still short notice and not nearly enough time to plan for.
-I had a lot of empty sessions and some objectives require helping players which is impossible if you are by yourself.

Did you enjoy some of the new tasks more than others?
-Vehicles are obviously the coolest thing in this new test server instance by far, opens up a lot of possibilities and is quite fun. I do hope some vroom vroom noises and maybe a horn to honk with are coming in the future! Racing community events and hopefully some new minigames someday are in store. Some kind of private mission lobby would be really great for a future like that.
-Crane is fun but needs more to it, more objectives and maybe let the operator pick up enemies or support allies with it.
-Volatile minerals are neat, I feel like they need something but I'm not sure what.
-Kill objectives are a classic can't go wrong with simple combat objectives.
-Gremlin Crates, not sure what the purpose of these are didn't seem obvious but could just be me.

Extra:
The new organized feedback questions is great, especially for game masters in particular I imagine. Rather than sifting through our messy thoughts that vary greatly.

#10
Objectives! Wooo

Is the assignment of Objectives clear?

Yes and no, If you launch the missions yourself, the menu does tell you what to do clearly, but if you were to join someone else, and have the setting enabled to lock the interface while fighting, your objectives would be entirely hidden from you.

Same applies if the player has decided they prefer the older style of overlay map (which I do, I find it very useful for a quick peek at the map while I explore), they would find themselves entirely in the dark until they unlock their UI and open the side panels.

Is the way you find an Objective clear?

More or less, the map icons do make it clear that "something is going on here, and here, and here...", But when the side panels are locked (so closed, as it currently works), the markers directing you to your objectives are also hidden, making the map the only way to find them.

Were you able to complete your Objectives?

Yes, all of them, altho I was a little confused by the description for some of them, like "help out a fellow knight" did not telegraph "use the crane to carry someone around", or "drive someone somewhere".

Did you enjoy some of the new tasks more than others?

If I were to rank them, I think my top 5 would be:

  • Comandeer a cart.
  • Comandeer a crane.
  • Grow / Maximize a volatile mineral.
  • Beat a [insert miniboss].
  • Small tasks: Scouting / Steal a gizmo / Steal a battery / Light a candle ...

I enjoyed these because the have players move around the map, and give you a reason to explore. The mineral objective also gives you a reason to use them, and a way to obtain the maximized mineral for merchant pruposes. (which I wish all of the levels had a merchant of sorts, like forge or basil...)

And the ones I liked the least:

  • Clear a monster stronghold
  • Beat the boss (I forgot that one's name).
  • Battle [enemy] (0/250)

My reasons for the above are pretty straightforward, the first two are very boring, and chore-like, even if you went to the forge prior to get a damage boost, you're basically fighting an army of HP sacks that take forever to die and deal 50% of your HP per hit.
The 3* battle objective struggles from a similar problem, just going around and fighting this many mobs is not hard, but it is quite boring.

Do you have any other feedback on Objectives for The Watch?

The new map is a neat addition, and I do know it has the objectives on it, but I think that map should have its own button besides the overlay map, not replace it entirely. That, and the side panel that informs players of their objectives should stay open (but lock) when the UI lock is engaged, could be a preference setting?

#11
The Watch Objectives

Is the assignment of Objectives clear?

  • I found most of them clear; there's no issue there once you figure it out (the map icon also communicated well)

Is the way you find an Objective clear?

  • Most of them are straightforward, with a few exceptions and confusion about the icon or model (ex: Forge // Anvil station). The best example is growing the volatile mineral.
  • The Volatile minerals could use pop-up text in the mineral room explaining how to level them and warning that they will shatter when the player takes damage.

Were you able to complete your Objectives?

  • Most of them have no issue completing, and it's more fun with other players around. Although I found that "helping other knight complete their objective" can be fun and also frustrating under certain conditions. Once everyone gets their objective done. There's no way a latecomer can receive any help unless relying on another latecomer (which is inconvenient for different time zones).

Did you enjoy some of the new tasks more than others?

  • the crane one is the most fun, and the undead level is the least fun (with most of the objective sets)

Do you have any other feedback on Objectives for The Watch?

  • Firstly, the Jigsawvalley Watch could use some more objectives, such as knocking 3 gremlins outta the cart. Repair the vehicle. etc.
  • The Undead Watch needed love the most. I wish there were more unique objectives besides the shared ones from other Watches.

  • Example: protecting candlelight after being lit as some form of a light tower defense. Against 5 waves of undead, each wave progressively more challenging. A candle takes 5 hits from monsters before being snuffed out. Then the player has to reattempt to light it again. After the player defeats all monsters. The candle stays lit (blue candle). This area should also be provided with an infinite respawn Freeze Vial to help with solo player
  • Examples https://wiki.spiralknights.com/File:Scenario_Room-Graveyard_3.png
  • Another example https://wiki.spiralknights.com/File:Scenario_Room-Graveyard_7.png
  • Locate an ancient Tome The book will be hidden in a random bookshelf within the level. And magical tome stands will also spawn in the level (4 stands total). After the player locates a book. They carry it back to a tome stand, and the stand will require 4 minerals in order to perform a ritual and open a portal gate between the tome stands. Only one book is needed (but the number can be adjusted)
#12
+1 to Aino's suggestions (again!).

I believe that Kora could serve some more purpose in the chat. She could send clientside-only messages about the state of the area to give players information when the situation changes. "%1 commandeered a Crane," "Gremlins recaptured an area," "The bunker has been destroyed (already)."

The Watch shifts are short enough that this might not be necessary, but if they were slightly lengthened in the future to account for its growth as a gamemode, an ability to communicate information clearly to a player might help. This could be controlled or adjusted by player preferences if they'd prefer to get less watch messages in a similar style to controlling whether they recieve pickup messages or not.

As for objectives, Lucastigy and Blastawayer in testing sessions with Ainogommon, Silver-Hawke and myself were discussing rewards for completing objectives and we were circling the possibility of Kora offering rarities as rewards - like sparks or orbs.

Novelty will help attract players to this gamemode early on and it sets a solid foundation for more room types, objectives and events to be added as the game grows, or even Watch themes overall, but novelty alone might not always motivate players to play - but I DO want to emphasise that I think this gamemode's potential for continual growth and content/gameplay/aesthetic additions over time cannot be overstated. You have built something special with this.

#13
my 2 cents

Is the assignment of Objectives clear?

Only a few that aren't well explained. The slime crushing boss objective directed me to 3 different boss arena before finally giving me the proper one. Some objective you just stumble upon as they aren't indicated on the map (destroy a barricade)

Is the way you find an Objective clear?

Some aren't indicated on the map and you just stumble upon it.

Were you able to complete your Objectives?

No, Volatile minerals in undead mission is not doable. I've tried to complete it in 3 different map before giving up going karting. I upgraded a mineral and the mission never completed
Also I want to talk about the "help a knight complete an objective". It sucks ass when nobody plays. Remove it altogether or change it to "follow a knight for 1 minutes". I literally had to log in an alt to complete it. Nobody was playing at noon on wednesday during a holiday with an active objective.

Did you enjoy some of the new tasks more than others?

Yes but more as a novelty than anything. The crane has good mechanic though and the karting was fun but it's not related to task

Do you have any other feedback on Objectives for The Watch?

I really hate the "help a knight with objective", I get the angle but in reality ppl will just log an alt to complete it cause it's just faster and less hassle. I was asking ppl if they were doing objective and everyone told me "no, already done" so what do you in those cases?

Edit: Overall I like it, 7.5-8/10 for me. Needs some tweaking though.
Having a broken objective is so frustrating.

Edit2: Also the bunker spawns gremlin that drops loot infinitely. IDK if oversight or intetional so it counts toward the killing 250 gremlins but I just stood next to bunker and killed gremlin for 5 mins to get the 250 kill. Not sure if that's how you want ppl to tackle this.

Edit3: you can find all those things I talked about in my 1h39m stream over at: https://www.twitch.tv/videos/2925855141
The bunker issue is the last 10 mins. You can even see me being annoyed with objective that can't complete earlier on in stream

At 15mins mark I try to do the surging slime
At 42mins mark I try to do the help another knight objective.
At 1h07mins mark I try to do volatile minerals

#14
many tidbits

Is the assignment of Objectives clear?
Yes, it's generally easy to understand what the game is asking you to do, with only a couple exceptions. "Gather scouting intel" is vaguely worded and I saw a lot of players getting stuck on it, since the verbiage doesn't make it immediately clear that you're supposed to go interact with a specific thing. The way it's worded, it sounds more like general reconnaissance, not "go interact with this thing."

Is the way you find an Objective clear?
Yes, the map and the UI indicators make it pretty easy to find where you need to go.

Were you able to complete your Objectives?
No. There is currently a specific objective which can become an impassable roadblock under certain conditions. "Help a fellow Knight" cannot be completed if there's one around to help, or even worse, if both/all members of a level all happen to only have the "Help a fellow knight" objective remaining. This specific objective needs to be removed.

Did you enjoy some of the new tasks more than others?
Yes. I enjoyed objectives which involved interacting with specific items, delivering items to a dropoff point, or hunting down minibosses. I was much less fond of the more generic objectives like [ Kill 250 of X ], which just devolve into a chore, especially on levels without minis.

Do you have any other feedback on Objectives for The Watch?
A bunch, yeah.

No objective should require mandatory cooperation.
Playing together is good, but if you make it mandatory, it creates problems. If two players have similar quests, great! They can work together to complete them! But the moment you NEED two or more people for something, that something becomes impossible to complete if you have no one around to actively assist you. What if you're on in the late hours of the night, and there's no one around to help? What if you send out a call for help, and no one responds? It's just an awful feeling, discouraging roadblock.

Interactive Objectives are more much interesting than simple Kill Counter objectives.
I don't know how much flexibility you have for coding new objectives for this mode, but there are many possibilities which extend beyond simply ticking up a counter on a kill tally. It would be neat to see more activities which involve interacting with the world and using the specific gimmicks of each Watch level. To spitball some ideas:

[ Defend the Seismic Sensor ]
Activate a Lockdown-style control point item, and hold it until it fully captures, while waves of minis spawn to try and force you off of it.

[ Activate the Power Switch ]
Use the Crane on Clockworks Watch to grab a Statue, and place it on an otherwise inaccessible pressure plate in order to unlock a door (or simply power on some tesla coil props, etc).

[ Assemble the Forgotten Ritual ]
Search three different bookcases in a Candlestick Watch to "acquire" forbidden pages, then interact with an Incomplete Tome in another location to activate a miniboss fight.

[ Give the Puppo a Bone! ]
Pick up Treat Bones from a crate near the elevator and deliver them to friendly barking Wolvers hiding elsewhere on the level (use the car to do it quickly!)

[ Steal the Schematic Box! ]
Break into a strongly defended area, grab a pickup item, and deliver it back to base (use a car to outrun your angry pursuers!)

I'm not attached to any of these specific ideas - again, I'm just spitballing some options which could be fun. I'm sure other testers also have ideas of their own which could lend inspiration.

#15
Objectives Feedback

Is the assignment of Objectives clear?
I'm assuming this means the task list, which is pretty straightforward, yes. What each task means though isn't always clear; I'd never seen a crane in the game, and seeing it fly around above me when I first got in had me confused as heck. Having a short briefing mission that mentions unique aspects (Cranes, Carts, Volatile crystals, etc) before actually beginning The Watch (similar to other conversation missions with Kora when Ranking up) would help players more easily get into The Watch's assignments instead of dumping a whole slew of new content.

Is the way you find an Objective clear?
Most of the objectives are clear, yes. Some need some experienced intuition, though, which is fine if you've played SK or games for a while but it'd be helpful if the UI was more consistent. I've had times where I was looking around on the map for where to go, as there was no indicator I could see on my screen while wondering the level, and times where the indicator was pointing to something so far away I got lost trying to solely follow it instead of checking the map. Being able to choose/designate a particular objective could help players prevent clutter and provide clarity for what their current task is.

Were you able to complete your Objectives?
I dont think I found any objectives that were bugged so far. One problem I had was needing to help another player with their tasks; in the event that you are playing solo and nobody comes around to join, you're kind of stuck not being able to complete this task. I think making it a bonus objective instead, granting a small added reward at the end of The Watch based on how many times you aided other Knights (up until a cap), could be a good way to keep this from being a barrier to continuing The Watch.

Also, when defeating the Gremlin Miniboss in the Red Zone, it can be the last enemy killed but the body will stick around for a while before disappearing, even though no Menders are nearby. This doesnt prevent the area from being completed, but can seem like it.

Did you enjoy some of the new tasks more than others?
Absolutely. First off, the more intensive tasks that take more teamwork or coordination are far more interesting and fun challenges. Helping a fellow knight is cool to be rewarded for! (Being held back if nobody is around, not so much).

Fighting a bunker isn't terribly difficult, but it's a new objective based fight rather than just blindly running around and killing enemies, so I love it! I think making it so you need to use the rockets instead of just smacking the Gremlin spawner would make it even more interesting, for example: it'd force players to interact with a rarely seen environmental pickup to complete the quest, meaning a bit more play and puzzle solving.

The Crane is a fantastically fun new way to play with the game, but definitely needs some tweaking. Being able to hold enemies in the air so they cannot fight takes the wind out of one's sail, as much as it might feel necessary since the Red Zone enemies are so incredibly upscaled that it feels almost impossible to keep up unless you have 4+ knights working together to take them down. There's also the chance to ride a carriage somewhere inaccessible, like a Mineral island or behind a locked gate, and you get stuck there because someone working the crane just leaves you there.

The Carts are also fantastic, as they help players get around more easily in such a larger environment, but as fun as it might be to run logistics and ferry Crates back to spawn, the basic material reward doesnt feel very... rewarding, considering I could get more from killing enemies where I'm at in the field. I do like the Cart-only bridges, but it was not obvious at first they were for Carts only. Maybe making them more like Electric Rails would show players to not touch them without a cart? And it could make you zoom a bit faster, even.

Do you have any other feedback on Objectives for The Watch?
The "Kill X Enemies" task isn't inherently a bad task, but when fighting the Gremlins and Undead, once a Blue Zone is completed, you're forced to move on to Yellow or Red or wait for respawns. However, all enemies only count as 1 kill for the counter; I would argue that since the Yellow and Red Zones require a bunch more effort to kill, they should count as more towards the kill counter. That, or change the Kill counter to "Reduce Enemy forces: X%" and adjust the percentage based on the type of enemy killed. A charged enemy or Miniboss should also count for much more than just 1 kill. When fighting slimes, the Minis make it much easier, even if the rest of this point stands, but that could be argued that they count too much to the Kill counter for how easy they are, and could increase a % by much less to compensate for that.

I also understand the need to Re-instance, in order to reset unique Tasks that cannot be redone, among other reason I'm sure, but it really takes me out to just suddenly fade to black and wind up in Haven. I have an idea instead: Kora warns the player that enemy forces are staging a final attack, and that you have to get back to the Elevator before Haven defenses rain a torrent of explosions around the area, decimating it and knocking you out (a similar feeling to making your escape from "Silence the Guns" in OCH). If you make it back to the elevator during that last minute, you get a Prize Wheel as well as the minerals and the Heat associated with a normal level clear, and it'd be more fun and immersive to encourage players to evacuate rather than just ignore the timer to finish what you're doing.

With that said, having the elevator be mostly undefended feels odd; there should be some sentries and turrets stationed nearby, thanking you for supply crates and encouraging players to keep up the fighting, or telling them to wrap it up during the last minute of The Watch. We see that elsewhere in the Clockworks, why not here too?

#16
Feedback

Is the assignment of Objectives clear?
As in, that they're randomly generated on a per-player basis? Not super clear unless you ask someone else.

Is the way you find an Objective clear?
I'd say so. You walk to it.

Were you able to complete your Objectives?
Yes.

Did you enjoy some of the new tasks more than others?
Not particularly, though there were ones I enjoyed less.

Do you have any other feedback on Objectives for The Watch?
It felt quite grindy overall. I hope that you will change the difficulty scaling so it's not just making all enemies take way too many hits to kill. I also did not enjoy hunting down 250 beasts, it just turned into cycling around the t1 area until I got enough minis down.
The boss things were just slogs because it took so long to kill the enemies, but I also never felt any real thrill of danger, especially since all the content were existing set pieces with a spiked enemy of a larger variety at the end, but with my damage and hp scaled down despite enemies being scaled to a higher tier.
I did not really enjoy the objectives overall, though I don't hate the feeling of exploration initially.

#17

"Help a Fellow Knight" is an interesting objective and has correctly been noted as hard to complete, but I believe it can be made solvable without removing it. I noticed that sometimes when all of the objectives on a watch map are completed, Kora will announce via chat words to the effect of "Everything is done here, come on back home."

I would like to make the case that a completed watch represents a group of knights working together - so, anyone with this objective incomplete at the time that the announcement is made, could receive completion credit for this objective at the point Kora announces there is nothing left to do. Setting the objective to listen for this event OR its current already-existing trigger conditions would do that quite neatly.

Not everything has to have a point to be valuable, in my opinion, so if you did want to keep it in to reinforce the feeling of collaboration, then I think this suggestion would "fix" it, But, the fact that I want to pose a workaround to this issue sort of supports the case that it could be removed without incident.

#18
Gremlin Barricades can spawn…

Gremlin Barricades can spawn in Aurora Isles Watch, but are exceedingly rare compared to their Clockworks counterpart, sometimes taking several refreshes before they spawn in.
I'd like them to be completely removed from the objectives list since they slow down task completion by a long shot.