Forums › English Language Forums › Off-Topic › Gremlin Chatter

Search

HELP raise AWARENESS and help those unnecessarily HATED on. Please read and support this thread by leaving a comment.

98 replies [Last post]
Wed, 04/30/2014 - 13:40
Arcknightdelta's picture
Arcknightdelta

Being more self aware

This thread is to discuss how everyone can help stop making it such a hostile environment for people who are feeling very depressed over personal attacks. Please read this with an open mind and heart. Letters in game are being sent around to people from upset individuals. Everyone should be made aware including OOO. To those who are feeling upset use what I say as a fire to strengthen your resolve. Don't feel as if you are alone. Make yourself be heard. If 1 person or a 100 people hate you there is always another person or a 1000 more people who will love and support you.

My experience on this forum

Before I begin can I just point out something without anyone taking offence. By now you should know I argue my side as fiercely as anyone on this forum, I know I am right and I won't be stopped until, and this is very important, *UNTIL I am PROVEN wrong*. So I don't mind having lengthy discussions and correcting anyone who tries to prove me wrong based on personal opinion. Big difference between personal opinion and solid fact. So please don't confuse the two when discussing with me and you THINK you are right. That's the way I am I won't change. However if I am wrong I'll be the first to admit it.

Hate me for this or love me, if I feel I can make a positive impact I'll push and push. My suggestion thread was hated on not because I wanted to harm or hate on people. It was hated on because a few individuals made such a massive deal of me trying to turn this forum into a policed society and they believe freedom of speech should allow us all to say what ever we want with minimal consequence. My suggestion was logical based on how things are successfully run on the Steam forum specifically on the Don’t Starve discussions forum where I HELP moderate with Klei developers. Those arguing against me had no solid logical argument to suggest my suggestion would not work here. Only Rating and Perronius came up with reasons which I accepted and dropped the whole thing. I stayed true to myself and didn't let anyone get the best of me. Especially those who deliberately tried to make my suggestion worthless. Trolls are very good at that.

Upholding rules

When rules are upheld and individuals through accepting those rules, learn to choose what they say more carefully, it produces an environment where constructed and positive topics can flourish. I can say hand on heart the community in that forum (Steam Don't Starve) is the best I have ever seen. Same goes for the community at Klei Official Forum for Don't Starve. Why? Because rules are upheld with no 'grey' areas in between. No forum is perfect but it is much better than most forums. Personally I don't see any grey areas. I take the rules as they are. But in all honesty I don't need to look at rules to know what is right and wrong. How I act towards a stranger in real life, I try my best to replicate here. Yes I make mistakes, we are all humans. But as humans we must learn from those mistakes and move forward.

Self belief and accepting mistakes

Although I have started to familiarise myself here, there are things that I dislike. What I hate is having a discussion where someone assumes something negative about you and proceeds to throw out little hateful comments. *I hate it but I have learnt to put up with it*, because I BELIEVE in MYSELF and BELIEVE I am right as long as I can base my argument on LOGICAL FACTS. I have never started an argument on personal opinion and if I have, I have always accepted both sides and if wrong I apologised. I made one mistake with EOS and I made it clear in their thread I was sorry for the trouble I caused, after which I have never dabbled in their affairs (separate issue to the <69 thing). I accepted my mistake and didn't feel sorry for myself after I openly apologised.

Being on this forum (not including the Bazaar) I have seen quite a few people with strong personas. Honestly if we have ever had an argument over game related things I thoroughly enjoyed them and hold no bad or ill intentions for you. But not everyone is the same on this forum. Not every can tolerate full blown arguments, not everyone can tolerate negative comments, not everyone can tolerate hate. That is where this community fails. When individuals contemplate suicide this is a serious thing and honestly families can get involved along with police.

Expressing yourself and being more conscious of others

What you guys have to look at is the reasons why someone would go as far as to think of suicide. This must be acted on indefinitely. Everyone has a right to express themselves how they see fit, this is the internet, you feel protected sitting behind a screen typing what you type. You can say anything to anyone with no PHYSICAL harm. What you do say however, can cause MENTAL harm. So is it fair for individuals to have freedom of speech on a public forum where the slightest of comments can hurt someone immensely? My honest answer is yes. BUT freedom of speech should never be abused and those who do abuse it should be punished. OOO do an excellent job at that and I tip my hat to them. But it is clear some things are passing through undetected.

How WE can help

Now as a tight knit community it is up to all of us to help OOO by helping those we feel are being targeted unnecessarily. Reporting straight to OOO should be the first port of call. Supporting that targeted individual is just as important. What happens is one or two people will help while a bunch of people will leave silly little hateful comments. We call them trolls. You know who you are. We know who you are. So please stop. This is a gaming community, to have kids talk about suicide is very disturbing and not right. If you see someone saying something you find to be "stupid" either ignore it or correct them nicely. DON'T try and be CLEVER and say something to make YOU and your friends LAUGH. I can see people giving out advice. Yet it is those same people who have some cause to the reason why people are feeling bad about themselves. First you say what you want, then you are made to feel sorry, then you advise and feel apologetic? Funny thing is you then go and do the same hurtful thing to someone else. I am not targeting anyone in particular. If this has upset you, as you feel you may have upset someone use it as a tool to make yourself a better person.

Time for change

I believe everyone can change for the best. But it's best only for you to correct your mistakes as soon as you make them. There will come a point where trying to fix the wrongs you have done will be too late, no harm will come to those you have upset at that point. Please be more aware of people around you, especially those you associate yourself with on the internet.

Conclusion

This has gone too far now, even if the victims are joking or being serious, the topic of suicide should not be talked about here in this forum because it should never be thought about. People should not be in a position caused by people in this community to contemplate something as extreme as that. We all have the power to change, it's your choice to change and help make a difference. Use the love we ALL have for Spiral Knights to make that change :)

Please take a moment to leave a comment and share your viewpoint on everything I said. If you also want to help make a difference, by making everyone aware that there is always a consequence to how we behave on a public forum and we should take every effort to make this forum a friendly place for everyone to use, please leave a comment to support this thread.

AKD

*EDIT: In response to Skepticraven post #13 I clarify some points in post #18.

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 13:58
#1
Melonfish's picture
Melonfish
Suicide is a serious problem.

This is a huge topic (and post), so I'll approach it one step at a time. Is it a response to something that triggered in-game or the forums?

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 14:18
#2
Arcknightdelta's picture
Arcknightdelta
@ Melonfish

Technically both. One sec I'll get the link. I did post this in that thread but the OP I believe sent the thread to the Graveyard.

Edit: Link Retracted

I thought against bringing that topic up. If you want to read it you'll find it in the Graveyard. That's all I'll say. This thread is about raising awareness of which I look forward to hear your opinion on the matter I have raised based on recent in game and forum activity in general.

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 14:35
#3
Untrustful's picture
Untrustful
Suicide is something that

Suicide is something that should be talked about, you can argue that the topic was in the wrong forum, but a lot of sheltered people keep thoughts like suicide to themselves, and by reinforcing that in the closed bottle that is peoples' heads whatever pressure someone has in their life will only make those thoughts more prevalent and fog up the good they do have.

Speaking of wrong forum, this doesn't belong here.

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 14:41
#4
Midnight-Dj's picture
Midnight-Dj
:/

Tl;DR, hurr durr, Midnight is a [bucket] who thinks freedom of speech is gud, and I am a Nazi who wants to control the forum with a complain button. I am logical because, what worked on steam, definately works on everything else, I am sure OOO still have a web designer some where.

No Arc, the reason why I am so angry with the button is I can see how come ppl can abuse it, again I am sure most ppl on this forum will be 'responsible' as you believed they would, but there will always be exceptions. *cough* *cough* This is not about me been irrational, it is about me worrying about the worst case scenario: some big figure who can mute thos that he/she hate with ppl backing /him/her up.

You can't expect all of us to have a wide range of views as you arc, some ppl have very very narrow mind about things. I won't give you examples that I encountered around here, but let's just take the ancient battle between Dryacos the RNG hating dragon and Midnight-Dj the derail valkyrie for example. Who is more logical here? You be the judge of that.

Draycos: "RNG is bad!"
Midnight-Dj: "RNG is good, because it give ppl equal chance of getting a slime low on a FF and a CTR VH on a haze bomb."
Draycos: "BUT about the guy who used 500K cr and only got a beast low?"
Midnight-Dj: "Then he should stop using punch. The UV addiction is bad."
Draycos: "Without UV, ppl can't kill darkdog in LD."
Midnight-Dj: "Skillz bro, use tempest and be support then."
Draycos: "But UV helps bombs as well, so UV still gud, FIX RNG DAMNIT!"
And the same argument start all over again....
------
Draycos: "I want BK and Apocrea event to be on all year!"
Midnight-Dj: "Then what about those players who fought hard during those limited event?"
Draycos: "The event weapons affect the game play! And since they do make a difference, every one MUST HAVE ACCESS TO THEM!!!"
Midnigh-Dj: "Chaos + SSB, problem solved..."
Draycos: "NUUU! You are removing variety from the game!"
And the same argument start all over again.

As for suicide, if ppl really kill themselves over the things that I write, no one can really arrest me over things like this, how many times do you see a troll get brought to justice in RL? Very few as far as I can tell. Right now, I am still pretty upset about how Mawashingmachine removed my story completely from her fanfic, so who knows, I might just release those anger on somebody. But still, I will post the missing bits tomorrow (special investigators: the missing Lengsk).

If you want this society to become a better place, humanity must first evolve as a whole through education, better care and of course, teach them the value of things not the price ect. ect. This will be a painstaking process.

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 14:45
#5
Arcknightdelta's picture
Arcknightdelta
@ Untrustful

You missed the point altogether.

It should not be talked about here in this forum because it should never be thought about. People should not be in a position caused by people in this community to contemplate something as extreme as that.

@ Midnight-Dj; if we stand together we can make a difference. We can make people aware and we can stop all the hate.

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 14:46
#6
Aphrodite's picture
Aphrodite
Community Manager
This is a serious discussion,

This is a serious discussion, which I hope you will continue in a constructive way, but it does not belong in General Discussion.

Be excellent to each other. Keep your posts respectful and polite. Disagreement is fine, but scratching, biting, and hair pulling is not allowed.

If you are looking for more information to help a friend, or to help yourself, please check this website: http://www.befrienders.org/ Geared towards suicide, self-harm, and depression, this site lists resources worldwide for both victims and the people in their lives who are trying to help them.

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 14:48
#7
Markus-Aurelius's picture
Markus-Aurelius

...the topic of suicide should never be mentioned on a forum where we all share one love. Spiral Knights.

Hmmm, what about Gremlin Chatter? What if I want to discuss it?

What if I wanted to have an honest coversation with people about why suicides are so prevelant in our society and what can be done to reduce them? What if I wanted to discuss issues facing millitary personnel like military suicides and PTSD?

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 14:49
#8
Arcknightdelta's picture
Arcknightdelta
@ Aphrodite

Thank you. I was unsure where to put this so thanks again for moving it. I'm sure the community as will I, will help keep this topic related and as constructive as can be :)

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 14:51
#9
Melonfish's picture
Melonfish
My tooth itches.

So basically a motivational guideline.

I personally never really fell victim of either taking or dishing out personal attacks at large, however I have been on the receiving end of a few threats for banning my account. They have been addressed without notable consequences.

Do we have an estimate of how much the toxicity of PvP affects the cases?

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 15:00
#10
Fehzor's picture
Fehzor

As much as I would like to partake in this conversation, I cannot help but feel that nothing good can come from expressing my views on this issue, or as Untrustful suggests, experiences with it. Sharing those kinds of things with ANYONE was a mistake that I am not keen to make twice.

So I'm just going to drop it right now and not get banned.

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 15:13
#11
Arcknightdelta's picture
Arcknightdelta
@ Markus-Aurelius

I edited that line to make it more clear what I mean.

@ Melonfish (quoted) So basically a motivational guideline.

In a sense, yes.

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 15:01
#12
Mayaura's picture
Mayaura
@ Aphrodite

Be excellent to each other. Keep your posts respectful and polite. Disagreement is fine, but scratching, biting, and hair pulling is not allowed.

So, what is that? An ideal you wish we would aspire to, i.e. wishful thinking? Some vague half-joking guideline that you know people won't follow? Is it in any way a rule you are willing to enforce?

Since insulting posts and name calling are quite common and rarely reprimanded or censored, I'm going to guess your answers would be "yes", "yes" and "no".

In my opinion, it would be better if you just stopped saying it since it is has become such a meaningless exhortation.

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 15:13
#13
Skepticraven's picture
Skepticraven
"This thread is to discuss

"This thread is to discuss how everyone can help stop making it such a hostile environment for people who are feeling very depressed over personal attacks."

Lets discuss your first post.

#1 "I know I am right and I won't be stopped until, and this is very important, UNTIL I am PROVEN wrong."
#2 "What I hate is having a discussion where someone assumes something negative about you and proceeds to throw out little hateful comments. I hate it but I have learnt to put up with it, because I BELIEVE in MYSELF and BELIEVE I am right as long as I can base my argument on LOGICAL FACTS. I have never started an argument on personal opinion and if I have, I have always accepted both sides and if wrong I apologised."
#3 "DON'T try and be CLEVER and say something to make YOU and your pathetic friends LAUGH. I can see people giving out advice. Yet it is those same people who have some cause to the reason why people are feeling bad about themselves. First you say what you want, then you are made to feel sorry, then you advise and feel apologetic? Funny thing is you then go and do the same hurtful thing to someone else. I am not targeting anyone in particular. If this has upset you, as you feel you may have upset someone. Use it as a tool to make yourself a better person."

#1 is logically wrong. If you are right, then you cannot be proven wrong.
#2 Putting up with it is the wrong thing to do. If something is morally wrong or against the rules, letting it go is just as good as supporting it.
#3 This brings out your strong personality, ironically moves against the entire notion that the beginning set out to prevent. What gives you the right to call someone else's friends pathetic? You just made an enemy of anyone that it was directed at. It is not wise to fight fire with fire.

Personal attacks should not be tolerated. Aphrodite already posted the guideline. Whenever I encounter them, I often send a silent complaint to inform the staff. Why silent? I don't get involved, but also do not stand by and watch. If moderators deem that the situation crossed the line, I assume action is taken.

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 15:13
#14
Mayaura's picture
Mayaura
@ Arcknightdelta

This thread is to discuss how everyone can help stop making it such a hostile environment for people who are feeling very depressed over personal attacks.

It's not rocket science - just don't be hostile. but that's not going to happen, and while discussing it might be entertaining or even cathartic, it's certainly not going to change anything as long as the Game Masters are taking a pie-in-the-sky hands-off approach to upholding their guidelines.

this goes back to another sentence in your OP: When rules are upheld and individuals through accepting those rules, learn to choose what they say more carefully, it produces and environment where constructed and positive topics can flourish.

I wholeheartedly agree. regrettably, it all too often doesn't describe these forums (or probably 99% of the forums on the internet).

Also, I appreciate your efforts and I apologize for giving you a poke in the eye over your response to my post expressing happiness that the rules had been enforced in regard to an individual I had complained about and thanking the Game Masters for doing their job in that case. Your words ("some things are better left unsaid") are a reasonable opinion, but I would still not retract my post in that situation since the banned player was using a friend to try defend his "innocence".

Anyway, as you were. Carry on.

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 15:17
#15
Midnight-Dj's picture
Midnight-Dj
@Arc

Thanks AKD, for some reason I got banned for 2 days for posting this. Hurray for the freedom of speech, I get banned for calling myself names...

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 15:20
#16
Mayaura's picture
Mayaura
@ Midnight-Dj

You can't make posts personally attacking someone and then expect them to want to pal around with you later. It sounds like you've had this life lesson several times already. I hope for your sake it sticks some day. I was even giving you a second chance and threw it back in my face.

I have found that with people who know they are jerks and enjoy being jerks it's a frustrating, useless waste of time to try to reason with them. And it's a fool's errand to live your life trying to please people around you (the exceptions being your boss and the reasonable expectations of your parents) or persuading people to like you (ha ha ha - that one's funny).

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 15:26
#17
Midnight-Dj's picture
Midnight-Dj
:/

I hope for your sake it sticks some day. I was even giving you a second chance and you threw it back in my face.

Telling phantom to hang out with you is hardly an insult. And since you decided to remove my hard work in the fan fic completely, that is more of an insult than anything else. I spent hard work trying to make the story intresting, even throwing out plots and lore for you and the others to work with, but at the end, you are still the same person. You can't expect others to change when you refuse to change your self.

I have said all I wanted to say to you in the threads you graveyarded, I don't hate you Mawa, I sincerely hope that maybe one day when I read your post on the forum and I won't be as mad. I tried to change, for you and for everyone else, but it is hard, but I hope the ppl of forum can give me chance to show that I can change as a person. But if you think I am beyond redemption, then so be it.

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 16:01
#18
Arcknightdelta's picture
Arcknightdelta
@ Skepticraven

These points are not fundamental to recent issues but they are important to help people learn not to get trampled on when people disagree with what they say.

#1 I explain that further. The message to that line is this. I never go into any argument thinking I will lose as long as I have done research on the topic beforehand. When I argue I don't involve emotion or opinion. I have on some occasions, and I found it hard to carry on the argument, mainly because when you bring in opinion there will always be someone else with a stronger opinion than yours. However if you argue with fact and logic you can carry on arguing and feel confident you are right.

For argument sake. If you had an opinion that the world was flat and if travelled in a straight line from where you stood, you would fall off the world when you reach the edge. I would argue you are wrong with evidence and facts. Someone who has travelled the world seen all there is to see. I can confidently argue the world is round and you will eventually come back to where you started if you travelled in a straight line, I would win. It is a logical argument. Sometimes opinions do matter but in an argument you have to back your opinions up with facts.

However on a few occasions I have been proved wrong because my facts were not as strong as someone else, and I have held my hand up to it. I have never tried to drag the conversation on for longer, fully knowing I was in the wrong. I know a few people who have done just that.

#2 What I mean when I say I put up with trollish behaviour, is that I don't let myself get upset over it. I used to, but I learnt if I let others win for the wrong reasons I only encourage them to hurt someone else. So what I mean is I don't allow anything anyone says to effect me emotionally to a point I break down and give up. That's a lesson people need to learn. When they do they won't get easily offended and isolate themselves.

#3 I see people who gain satisfaction from upsetting someone else, as a pathetic individual. I won't change my stance on that. This comment should make an impact on anyone who likes upsetting others, if someone hates on me for that we will know they are the ones who don't care if someone gets upset after they deliberately upset them. I can't and won't put it any way nicer.

@ Midnight-Dj; I believe you have already made a change. And a good one.

@ Mawashimono; no need to apologise. It's cool.

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 16:09
#19
Skepticraven's picture
Skepticraven
↓

"#2 What I mean when I say I put up with trollish behaviour, is that I don't let myself get upset over it. I used to, but I learnt if I let others win for the wrong reasons I only encourage them to hurt someone else. So what I mean is I don't allow anything anyone says to effect me emotionally to a point I break down and give up."

You should clarify that. Put up with connotes with me to mean as I stated above.

"#3 I see people who gain satisfaction from upsetting someone else, as a pathetic individual. I won't change my stance on that. This comment should make an impact on anyone who likes upsetting others, if someone hates on me for that we will know they are the ones who don't care if someone gets upset after they deliberately upset them. I can't and won't put it any way nicer."

Sure. The only problem here is that you've already lost that reader. You know, the reader you made this post in an attempt to change their point of view? I have a lot of reasons to feel people would be superior/inferior to my moral stance. If I want them to change to have a similar stance as my own, one major thing I should do is NOT get them angry and ignore me.

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 16:24
#20
Arcknightdelta's picture
Arcknightdelta
@ Skepticraven

Agreed I made changes to the OP.

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 17:19
#21
Deleted-Knight's picture
Deleted-Knight
just saying

Arc, your OP is a huge wall of text. There's no real sections, just paragraph after paragraph. You also tend to be a bit long-winded. None of this is bad per say, but it makes it hard to read and comprehend.
If you want this post to be read by as many forum goers as possible, I suggest making a more condensed summary.

What I think you're saying:
People tend to be hurtful and insensitive online. Some more so than others. This can have serious consequences on others. This is demonstrated in a recent issue (that you don't have a link for). Everyone should remember there are actual people behind the screen-names, and those people have feelings than may be hurt.
The conversations in SK should be be kept light and related to the game. In general, people should also be nicer to each other and support a respectful environment.

IMO
I kind of agree with Skepticraven.
While your intentions are good, I don't think this post is going to make much of a difference. The people that need to be more sensitive are not going to read through your wall or text. Even if they do, they won't take you seriously.
In addition, the burden lies on both sides. Obviously, it would be good if people are more respectful and sensitive when talking online. However, people who read things online also need to keep things in perspective.
I believe SK mandates players to be at least 13 years old. I think it's reasonable to say a 13 year old can consciously choose to distance him/herself away from disagreeable things online. There's a lot of crazy things online, but every person, as a web surfer, can choose to read it or ignore it.

Spiral Knights is not Facebook. Nobody can attack you personally because they don't know you personally (unless you choose to make yourself vulnerable). Whatever they say is like words in a book you are reading. If you read something you are uncomfortable with, just skip it. Arguments are inevitable, and you may get caught up in the heat of the moment. However, the instant you shut down your computer, all those problems should go away.

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 19:23
#22
Seiran's picture
Seiran

@Midnight-dj:
Thanks AKD, for some reason I got banned for 2 days for posting this. Hurray for the freedom of speech, I get banned for calling myself names...

People (especially those from the US) really need to understand the whole "freedom of speech" thing. All it means is that the government cannot impend on your freedom of speech. Within local situations, ex: forums and games and the like, you're subject to the rules therein. There's an xkcd post I've seen going around lately that addresses this point exactly, but I'll refrain from posting it due to language.

The two other recent threads I've seen where the topic came up have disappeared from GD (or moved to an inaccessible forum). I'm glad this one's around and accessible.

@Arcknightdelta: (in mixed order)

I hate it but I have learnt to put up with it*, because I BELIEVE in MYSELF and BELIEVE I am right as long as I can base my argument on LOGICAL FACTS. I have never started an argument on personal opinion and if I have, I have always accepted both sides and if wrong I apologised.

Aye. I try to stay on a calm logically-based ground when it comes to argumentation. Chalk it up to a certain class I took in high school that talked about philosophy and discussed argumentation and fallacies. In arguments, both sides need to be willing to concede, and the important things are the ideas presented. There's a whole list of logical fallacies (in short, things that people use to bolster their sides that aren't logically sound), including ad hominem (personally attacking the presenter of an argument). I try to avoid those when possible, but I can't always expect the same in return. Because when the things being argued about are held dear, it's way easier to cling on to your opinion and emotion, and that can/has led to terrible things.

This thread is to discuss how everyone can help stop making it such a hostile environment for people who are feeling very depressed over personal attacks. Please read this with an open mind and heart. Letters in game are being sent around to people from upset individuals.

If you're referring to Pandafishie's mystery, while we still haven't figured out who the 'first' mailer was, I think it's safe to assume the second mailer saw it as an inspiration to do the same.

This is a gaming community, to have kids talk about suicide is very disturbing and not right. If you see someone saying something you find to be "stupid" either ignore it or correct them nicely...
This has gone too far now even if the victims are joking or being serious

And the difficult thing is that due to the nature and gravity of the issue (you know, life), once it's brought up, you can't (well, shouldn't) treat it as a joke. I had a friend who has told me about his experience talking one of his friends out of suicide, and it's unnerving - I don't feel I can really do the same. While I haven't had to deal with that with my friends, I've had other dramatic one-on-one's and have been in the helpless situation where I wish I had the thing to say, but I don't have the background and experience to give it weight. Anything I'd say would come across as platitudes. I've had the similar situation here - "you can get past it over time" > "no you can't." And I really have no idea how to convince them otherwise. Sure I've seen the lessons played out in less-serious situations, but if those lessons are dismissed because the situations are that heavy, I don't really know how to contribute.

So all I can really say is to try to get help offline; there are call centers and professionals with people who have either gone through similar situations or have dealt with the issues enough to help you out. Thanks, Aphrodite, for posting a link to one such resource.

Wed, 04/30/2014 - 22:31
#23
Hexzyle's picture
Hexzyle

I've had the similar situation here - "you can get past it over time" > "no you can't."

It's true. I'm a chronic self-loather and it does not get better over time. Every life problem is like adding trash ontop of a pile, no matter how trivial the problem actually is. Every time you get into emotional distress (in my case it's caused by making mistakes and then getting in trouble with people close to me) you remember everything terrible that you've done or experienced up until that point and it causes you to make rash decisions, often along the lines of doing self harm in some way (treating yourself horribly, especially)
It looks childish, it feels somewhat childish when one does it, but it certainly doesn't elude from the fact that people do it because they want attention, and are in a distressed enough state that they cannot see the good things in life.
The solution is not to feed that desire for attention directly, like a mother feeding a baby, but rather to teach and show the person interesting things if life, like philosophy or maybe a funny channel on YouTube, or tell them good things about themselves (provided they're true)

Or maybe I'm just an autistic man-baby and this stuff only applies to me :P

You should probably direct a person with any sort of problems to a professional, but you don't need me to tell you that.

Thu, 05/01/2014 - 00:27
#24
Sir-Wuddle's picture
Sir-Wuddle
"As for suicide, if ppl

"As for suicide, if ppl really kill themselves over the things that I write, no one can really arrest me over things like this, how many times do you see a troll get brought to justice in RL? Very few as far as I can tell. Right now, I am still pretty upset about how Mawashingmachine removed my story completely from her fanfic, so who knows, I might just release those anger on somebody. But still, I will post the missing bits tomorrow (special investigators: the missing Lengsk).

If you want this society to become a better place, humanity must first evolve as a whole through education, better care and of course, teach them the value of things not the price ect. ect. This will be a painstaking process."

1) Your problem with other people is yours alone, and it's unacceptable to go venting it out on other people.

2) Don't bother criticizing the problem if you plan on adding to it. Just because internet trolls get away with something doesn't justify you stooping to their level. If you want to show people that you're better than this, start acting like it.

"Aye. I try to stay on a calm logically-based ground when it comes to argumentation. Chalk it up to a certain class I took in high school that talked about philosophy and discussed argumentation and fallacies. In arguments, both sides need to be willing to concede, and the important things are the ideas presented."

^this
You end up taking away so much more from an argument by really challenging ideas with solid, honest, points. Going in saying "IM ALWAYS RIGHT" and smacking other people with insults is a good way to stop the flow of ideas and lose credibility, and we really could do with less of those.

Thu, 05/01/2014 - 02:44
#25
Arcknightdelta's picture
Arcknightdelta
Replies

@ Auto-Target; this thread isn't targeting one group in particular. It should make everyone aware to do their role to help kick out hateful comments, hopefully it will teach those hating, how severe their actions can be when things go too far and help those who are going through a bad spell and see there are people here that do care and want to make a difference for a better forum.

Spiral Knights is not Facebook. Nobody can attack you personally because they don't know you personally (unless you choose to make yourself vulnerable). Whatever they say is like words in a book you are reading. If you read something you are uncomfortable with, just skip it. Arguments are inevitable, and you may get caught up in the heat of the moment. However, the instant you shut down your computer, all those problems should go away.

This is not a fair comment and maybe you may have a strong character but not everyone can just shut it away and forget. If that was true you would never hear once on this forum that someone is getting suicidal over things that went on. People don't get to that stage over a day. Maybe they did shut the computer off once, twice or three times. But every time they come back they see the same thing over and over and over again. Don't blame the targeted person for being too soft, blame the individuals who are targeting that person, harming them mentally. Report to OOO asap, and maybe leave a comment in the thread to make people aware they are doing wrong and it should stop. This thread is about raising AWARENESS.

Edit: divided each point I am enforcing in the OP with headings.

@ Sir-Wuddle; there is a big difference between thinking you are right and thinking you are right without accepting you are wrong. When I started this thread, if I thought what ever I said was wrong, if I doubted myself I wouldn't be able to defend what I am trying to say. Any comment would beat me down. Belief in yourself is very important, it doesn't mean you become arrogant and disregard what others say though. In defeat you should be just as strong. Don't be weak and attack someone who makes you out to be wrong but instead show strength by accepting your mistake and correcting it.

The problem in most cases is when someone says something, when they give an opinion, there will be someone with a stronger opinion that challenges you, this is the internet after all. The difference between someone who believes in themselves and someone who doubts themselves is big enough to cause people to become a vulnerable target. Speaking to parents, family and good friends is a great way to build self confidence, because you can express yourself differently to how you express yourself behind a computer screen.

Thu, 05/01/2014 - 06:43
#26
Vishno's picture
Vishno
video games

Is it fair that someone has such thin skin that I have to closely guard and moderate everything I say?
Answer: in today's politically correct world, yes.

Thu, 05/01/2014 - 07:25
#27
Seiran's picture
Seiran

@Vishno:
I don't think you have to always moderate what you say (and it's not realistic to expect that for everyone). But when you're dealing with someone who you know has susceptibility to serious (irl) reactions, then guard them.

That shouldn't really be a big issue though if you treat people with decency, which I think is generally what this thread is going for. You know, the whole "don't be a bully" thing.

Thu, 05/01/2014 - 22:57
#28
Hexzyle's picture
Hexzyle

Is it fair that someone has such thin skin that I have to closely guard and moderate everything I say?

If you were wise and understood the fact that everything you do has consequences, yes, you'd watch everything you say, not just for the sake of others but also the sake of yourself.

Those who guard their lips preserve their lives, but those who speak rashly will come to ruin.

Thu, 05/01/2014 - 10:44
#29
Deleted-Knight's picture
Deleted-Knight
@Arc

If a particular person is being targeted repeated, then that counts as cyber bullying/stalking.

My comment is referring to general messages that some people find upsetting. This is because there is no way to figure out if a post will settle well with every single person that reads it. For instance, what if I have a super intense fear of spiders and you wrote a horror story about a giant spider eating someone alive while they slept? Suppose that story kept me awake for the next week and made me extremely paranoid. Should you be held responsible?

ie. Saying someone should to kill him/her self during a forum debate out of stupid rage is much different than pming them repeatedly in game and saying they should kill themselves. Would it be better if you not said it at all? Of course. But people should also be expected to read messages with context in mind.

As an example, in the "Would you rather thread" I posted this:
"Would you rather be betrayed by your best friend or kill your best friend?"
Taken out of context, this statement could be emotionally unsettling. However, the post was made in a thread that is full of crazy hypothetical scenarios. So it shouldn't be taken seriously.

Thu, 05/01/2014 - 12:22
#30
Arcknightdelta's picture
Arcknightdelta
@ Auto-Target

If a particular person is being targeted repeated, then that counts as cyber bullying/stalking.

Very true. What happens in game, would be wrong of me to assume any form of cyber bullying goes on, as I have never seen or heard about it, that isn't to say it does not happen. But what we have all seen from time to time is hateful comments thrown unnecessarily at someone continuously every time they say something, which is wrong.

My comment is referring to general messages that some people find upsetting

On such a serious topic, please be more clear when making a point, I'm sorry if I missed it but based on what we are discussing here, general messages don't apply, so I over looked that.

people should also be expected to read messages with context in mind.
people who read things online also need to keep things in perspective.

The impression I'm getting is, that you are saying the person being targeted should be expected to take a beating and get over it? I know it sounds a bit harsh but that is what you are saying in a nutshell right? I can't discuss this until I am 100% sure what you mean.

Remember this thread does not include small talk. This is more serious than that, based on how forumers have been reacting to hateful comments thrown their way. If your argument is solely based on what you mentioned in post #29 I urge you to reconsider your stance. Arguments are unavoidable but hateful comments are avoidable. This is what people should be aware of.

Thu, 05/01/2014 - 14:01
#31
Deleted-Knight's picture
Deleted-Knight

I'm sorry if I missed it but based on what we are discussing here, general messages don't apply

Oh, well I'm sorry. I'm not exactly sure what is it you are trying to say. In post #21, I gave summary of what I think you are saying. Since you didn't mention any inaccuracies, I just continued with that assumption.
I don't think you provided details regarding the specific event that motivated you to make this post. All I know is it had something to do with suicide.

Fri, 05/02/2014 - 12:40
#32
Arcknightdelta's picture
Arcknightdelta
@ Auto-Target

Well it's a tough situation. I didn't want to post the link in fear it opens up more hate and attention to the person/people involved. If you searched in the Graveyard page 1 you'll find the thread. But please respect my decision to not post the thread link here.

Fri, 05/02/2014 - 23:33
#33
Draycos's picture
Draycos

[off-topic derailing, ignore me]

Sat, 05/03/2014 - 03:49
#34
Midnight-Dj's picture
Midnight-Dj
THE POWER OF THE DERAIL VALKYRIE

HAS DEMINISHED

Fri, 05/02/2014 - 23:33
#35
Draycos's picture
Draycos

I can't stop derailing topics to start arguments nobody cares about but me.

Edited this out, mailing you in-game, let's keep it there.

Fri, 05/02/2014 - 23:37
#36
Midnight-Dj's picture
Midnight-Dj
@Draycos

Meh, I will call it a cease, don't wanna waste em precious crown on mailing...

Midnight, you are stingy...

Yes, I am, I guess I will stop derailing, there is no point, OOO won't care about what we have to say then we won't waste ours complain about it.

Sat, 05/03/2014 - 03:40
#37
Xxpapaya's picture
Xxpapaya
The papaya is a tad confused

I've never been able to process walls of text (although this is a very important and meaningful one, I'm sure), but I'm assuming the title summarizes everything? Bit confused about what the discussion is about... from my point of view, "yes, we should be raising awareness to help those unnecessarily hated on" but what exactly is this whole chit-chat about, is there something that not everyone is agreeing with ? 0_0

Sat, 05/03/2014 - 04:10
#38
Sir-Wuddle's picture
Sir-Wuddle
Discussing different

Discussing different viewpoints on how we go about interacting with others on the sk forums and how it's interpreted for a better forum environment.

Sat, 05/03/2014 - 09:00
#39
Arcknightdelta's picture
Arcknightdelta
@ Xxpapaya

Hi, nice to see another friendly face returning. Basically over the past month or so there have been some disturbing accounts of forumers contemplating suicide because of the way they were treated in game and on the forum. From what I gathered the person feeling deeply upset by this, has been a target of continuous hate, based on what they have told us on the forum and other comments we read.

This thread is about making everyone aware that there are severe consequences when you engage in a discussion with someone that can turn sour. You can't just say what ever you want (hateful comments) and not expect a reaction. Sometimes you won't get the reaction, sometimes that person may react in a way that harms themselves. This is what I want to help prevent.

Recently we had two cases of in game mailing where the sender is deeply upset by how things are and believe life isn't worth living. The person who they sent the letters to, by the looks of things were involved. This should not be happening here. In all my life of using game forums on the internet, I have never come across such extreme measures.

To those who are upset this thread can help them realise there are people on this forum who do care and not everyone is out to spread hate and unnecessary comments. If we all take the time to just even leave a comment that you support this thread, things can take a positive turn.

Sat, 05/03/2014 - 09:10
#40
Canine-Vladmir's picture
Canine-Vladmir
Oh my Gosh you guys

The One day i decide to check on the forums if theres been any dramatic change and i see this.

Is this for real happening? It's a E+ game how it this happening?

Sun, 05/04/2014 - 00:46
#41
Arcknightdelta's picture
Arcknightdelta
@ Canine-Vladmir

Welcome back I guess.

Yep this is true. Unfortunately.

Sun, 05/04/2014 - 05:57
#42
Xxpapaya's picture
Xxpapaya
The papaya breaks out the ham

(Welcome back Canine :D)
Bring out the bread and cheese because I'm going ham! >:( (Basically, I'm angry)
Seriously, I don't even see why we need to debate about this. If there are individuals in this community (which many people believe to be the one with least hate) who are verbally bullying others, then of course we have to do something about it...So is the debate about how we should approach it? Because if it were me, I'd give [those] people a first warning, second warning, third warning, followed by a banhammer (or in this case, banbar [crowbar] )

Sun, 05/04/2014 - 06:19
#43
Bopp's picture
Bopp
strategy: discuss only the game

I sympathize with the victims of bullying, and everyone who gets stressed out over their relationships in this game. But I've been posting on the forums nearly daily for almost three years, and I never get into emotional disputes. Why? I confine my comments to the game itself. I don't talk about the players. (A post like this is the closest I get to talking about players.)

If you want to have a big, angry argument with someone, then do it in real life. If you don't know the person in real life, then don't have a big, angry argument with them. There's no point in getting upset over a video game or its players. And if you don't get upset, it will be much harder for people to get upset with you.

Sun, 05/04/2014 - 06:22
#44
Arcknightdelta's picture
Arcknightdelta
@ Xxpapaya

The problem is the "haters" and the "non haters" have different opinions on freedom of speech. If you ask me it all boils down to that. "Don't tell me what to say, this is a public forum so I can say what I want, how I want". I won't lie though. I have seen some big change in attitudes, for the good way, of certain forumers since I've been here. So it it does prove that if people are aware of the consequences of saying something they should not be saying, to someone, they will eventually stop.

If we can get people on here who actually care about making this forum better by leaving a comment, those who are hated on can see people do care and they are not alone. I know you guys feel as if we don't need to tell people we care to actually care, but I personally feel reading something is very powerful and can help.

Sun, 05/04/2014 - 08:13
#45
Zaffy-Laffy's picture
Zaffy-Laffy

I think the problem is about what is being addressed. Freedom of speech is one thing, attacking a person is another. We can all criticize, complain, comment on each other, and it all comes down to how the recipient handles it, but when it comes down to shaming, humiliate or mentally harm with any intent, then there's your problem. That said, it's not that we don't care, it's just that not all of us are part of it.

I also want to mention that a problem with "being aware" is that victims of bullying tend not to tell anyone about their issues. How do you help victims if you can't even detect or find them. Is it more efficient to censor everyone then to treat those victims? What is the alternative to your proposal here? I'm not here to deny your suggestion, but it doesn't seem fair that everyone gets a slap if someone says something stupid or ridiculous.

My suggestion? Please educate those "victims" how to handle negativity and criticism, because knowing what's wrong with yourself helps to better yourself, make yourself a stronger person and it's overall beneficial to everyone that way.

Sun, 05/04/2014 - 14:06
#46
Arcknightdelta's picture
Arcknightdelta
@ Zaffy-Laffy

Wow it's been a long time mate. Nice to see you posting on one of my threads again :)

I also want to mention that a problem with "being aware" is that victims of bullying tend not to tell anyone about their issues. How do you help victims if you can't even detect or find them.

Well no not really. The way I see it, based on reading what has been said in, Ingame mail and comments on this forum, is that the victims feel as if they are hated by everyone. The title of this discussion is blatantly obvious what is going on here. As long as they see there are people on this forum who aren't like the people who are hating on them, we already achieved something.

My suggestion? Please educate those "victims" how to handle negativity and criticism, because knowing what's wrong with yourself helps to better yourself, make yourself a stronger person and it's overall beneficial to everyone that way.

Obviously your suggestion is a step on the ladder to greatness, but if we start from the bottom and "educate" (your word not mine) the people who dish out all the negativity and criticism there won't be any need to educate the "victims". It all starts somewhere, unfortunately in recent cases it leads to people wishing to do things to themselves that isn't very nice. Your suggestion also works both ways. People who can't control themselves from hurting others have something wrong with them, fixing themselves first will make them stronger and definitely a better person, resulting in a much more friendlier forum. Don't you agree?

It's like a tray of eggs. You get rid of the rotten ones and leave the good ones. But obviously in a public forum you need people to agree and disagree with each other, otherwise there would be no discussions, what we don't need is the hate that comes with the disagreeing. I don't want people banned, I want then to be aware of how others may take what they say offensively. It's not hard to control what you say and it definitely isn't hard to be nice all the time.

Sun, 05/04/2014 - 09:39
#47
Bopp's picture
Bopp
don't child-proof the world; world-proof the child

There's a saying: "Don't child-proof the world; world-proof the child." The world will never be totally safe and happy and comfortable. So train people with strategies and coping mechanisms, for dealing with angry and mean people. For example, help them recognize and ignore trolls on the Internet. This broad approach is what Zaffy-Laffy, Vishno, and I have been advocating in posts #45, #43, and (more abrasively) #26.

You can help victims to withstand/avoid bad situations, while also punishing/helping outright bullies. The two are not exclusive. When done well, both are preventative of future bullying.

Sun, 05/04/2014 - 11:03
#48
Arcknightdelta's picture
Arcknightdelta

Well yeah it's a solution. I guess we can help do both then :)

Edit: but that doesn't mean only a few of us do one thing and a few do another thing. If we want this to work, everyone has to do their bit as best as they can.

Sun, 05/04/2014 - 19:09
#49
Mystrian's picture
Mystrian

So this can be summed up as "if you have nothing nice to type, don't bother typing it"

Mon, 05/05/2014 - 01:46
#50
Arcknightdelta's picture
Arcknightdelta
@ Mystrian

There are quite a few ways this thread can be summed up if one was to read more into what I have said in the original post.

This could be seen as a motivational speech to the victims.
A thread where the victim can learn how to tolerate/ignore/deal with haters.
For the haters to realise they need to stop doing what they are doing.
Could also be seen as a thread where the victim can see that there are people here willing to make a difference.
The victim can see there are people here who don't hate them.
The haters can see there are people here who won't sit idly by when they start hating and saying hurtful comments.
A thread to make everyone aware of what wrong has been going on and needs to stop.

This thread is what ever you want to see it as for the better of this forum.

  • 1
  • 2
  • next ›
  • last »
Powered by Drupal, an open source content management system