Bombs in Lockdown

So, more and more recently I've been getting complaints from the toothpick Skolver population that Bombs don't require skill in Lockdown. This hasn't really bothered me until someone recently was really harping on me for it... but, I disagree. i think bombs require a lot more skill than people give them credit for, because they have so many drawbacks, and not very many advantages over other weapon classes.
Personally, I think that the toothpickers can't stand not being able to blindly dash into an area and stab someone to death instantly, so they call shenanigans when they run headfirst into a mist cloud, and then get shot/stabbed/nitro'd to death.
So, I issue this challenge to all of those who still say Bombing requires no skill in LD:
Go bomb. Tell me how good you do. Tell me if you can still break that sweet 10k like you always do in your clone gear. Tell me if you find it effortless to always be able to plant a bomb, especially when faced with a toothpick striker, like you once were. I'll be waiting for your reply. :)

I suck at bombing in LD... you DO need skill to bomb in LD...

You really dont need much skills to run in circles with max ctr and drop mist bombs to be honest.
But same goes for running across the map spamming the attack button with a flourish or polaris.
Most random players just torture their mouse, so the clone army shouldnt complain much because they do the same thing.
Now using the other kind of bombs, like shards,etc is another story.

Time to start upgrading that static capacitor of mine, it seems. :D

@Fluffyfoxxie That someone is no doubt Blueberrymuffin, and he cries every time I rip his ankles off with my shards. Learn to love his anguished wailing. :D

That guy insulted me on being a bomber....
(STARTS GRINDING CR FOR 4*)

I want to see you kill someone in t3 lockdown with the big angry bomb.
come on. do it.
Bombing requires a different kind of skill. If you think I'm just running around in circles planting bombs, you're crazy. I'm more likely to take damage than any of you, because my gear doesn't protect me and charging my bomb leaves me completely vulnerable. I'm having to dodge guns, and with my latency? LAWL. That's crazy. Then RSS isn't about just planting and hoping it hits someone, no... it's about actually aiming and predicting where someone is going to go so when they go there you nail them in the face with a sun shard.
Bombing requires skill. I'm sick of people ragging on bombers.
Once again, I challenge you to craft a big angry bomb and successfully use it in lock down. go ahead. do it.

Do us knights have ankles? Or is it just feet that we're missing...

Bombing in lockdown relies on your enemies gun skills.

@Tennis Well, that depends on how often they've tripped over shankles in the clockworks...

@Nicoya That guy will rag on anyone who kills him more than once. He got super pissed when I kept gunning him to death, going on about how gunning requires no skill as if you don't have to AIM with them. Complaints about relying on gear are bull too, seeing as I gun in skolver/vog and the only gun UV I have is med ASI on an umbra driver - which was a lucky first time craft.
And I don't care if bombing takes skill or not, I still want a bomber on my side. Ignore the idiots and keep bombing them. It'll be even more annoying.

I REALLY don't like people who discriminate on another class. If someone and their attacks are lacking skill, then it's the PLAYER lacking skill.
An ability that doesn't require skill is calling in an Airstrike on the battlefield. Like a MOAB in CoD. Although it takes skill to get one, to a degree.
I've heard ol'Blueberry moaning before. It gets annoying.
IMO, bombers are great. Their mist bombs don't interfere with other teammates attacks, the other damage bombs are good traps for Strikers who don't watch where they're going, and they're really good at defending CPs.
My challenge to bombers: Dominantly use a Graviton/Electron Charge/Bomb/Vortex in Lockdown effectively.
Happy bombing!

lol bombing does take skill. U KNOW WHY????? cause look at everyone in LD Guess what they have in common? Polaris SPAM. if u can dodge and dish out bombs that means ur pro. Also people can just charge u even with in ur bomb radius if it means they will eliminate u so bombing does take skill. Take it from me a Ld bomber who EVERYONE HATES :D

I remember when Roarr got a triple kill with sun shards.
I was so mad.
Here I was, just moving slightly to avoid the pattern and everyone just runs into him like it's nothing. Moments later everyone dies, I kill Roarr and the rest of his team rushes me. Bombing takes skill, but unless you use other weapons you're going to get locked in charge animation since your only option is to charge your weapon. Foxxie isn't necessarily a pure bomber either, because he uses an Argent Peacemaker and a sword which I can't remember (Gran Faust probably).
I don't see why you would make such a thread since you yourself have already acknowledged the weakness of bombs by using countermeasures like AP. A successful lockdown bombing run takes some timing, and a great sense of positioning. It takes some skill, no doubt. However, I don't think it matters really, since you can't score anything decent as a bomber.
If you aren't averaging 5+ caps as a bomber then you are probably playing it wrong anyway.
edit: Skill doesn't win games anyway. You could score 40k damage and still lose. It's about being at the right place, at the right time, doing the right thing. I've probably clocked at least 400 hours into T3 lockdown, and I can safely say that nothing is more dangerous in a group skirmish than a bomber. A bomber can help the most during group skirmishes by planting ANY BOMB WHATSOEVER. It absolutely makes it hard to defend CPs, cap CPs and more or less defend your own spawn.

@ Neodasus
It's true, I don't run a full bomb set. So why is it that people complain about the bombs aspect of my loadout only?
My set:
Nitro
Voltaic Tempest
AP
FoV (Mainly because it's the only sword I own)
I don't think going pure any one weapon type is viable, but it's really dumb to complain when you die because you're fool enough to dash into a mist cloud, or because you get killed by a Nitro.
I still classify myself as a "Bomber" in LD because my armors are all geared towards bombing, and because I use bombs way more than I do my sword or gun.

People take Lockdown way too seriously. Every weapon requires some skill. You need to be able to use it effectively while dodging the attacks of your enemies. You can't accomplish much by just spamming bombs and hoping stuff dies. However, the skill cap on the game is just not that high. As long as you are properly geared, handy with a keyboard+mouse, and understand the basics of the game (cap + defend points), you can compete. You almost never find a game that's completely filled with people that know what they're doing; almost every game has a bunch of people on one bar connections, people in 4* gear, people who have no idea how to play and walk into fire, so it's really easy to get a false sense of being really good at the game when you're really nothing special. When I watch the professional gamers compete at games like Starcraft, Dota, CS, etc - I see players playing at a level that is scary. Even after playing hundreds of games of Starcraft and playing against many Diamond league players, I still can't even begin to compete with the real professionals. Compared to games like that, Lockdown requires no skill at all. Regardless of which class you play or which weapon you use. I don't claim to be the best at Lockdown, and I've certainly seen quite a few players that are better than me, but I have not yet seen anyone play at a level that really amazes me. And I don't think I will, because there are pretty strict limitations on what is possible in the game.

@Neodasus However, I don't think it matters really, since you can't score anything decent as a bomber.
*cough* http://steamcommunity.com/id/nicoya/screenshot/470861053756623577?tab=pu... *cough*
Sorry, I seem to have something caught in my throat.
*hack* http://steamcommunity.com/id/nicoya/screenshot/596958827128136330?tab=pu... *cough*
*ahem* http://steamcommunity.com/id/nicoya/screenshot/596958827128131538?tab=pu... *wheeze*
*hurk* http://steamcommunity.com/id/nicoya/screenshot/596957222593901631?tab=pu... *faint*

One of my favorite loadouts weapon-set to play is RSS with a FF as recon. Nothin else!
(Two bomb damage trinkets, skolver armor, and chaos cowl)
I've managed to get 12k damage with RSS and Vemon Veiler only.
The other damage bombs... I honestly haven't taken the time to craft them. I just like the RSS cause it can hit people off screen for a large amount.
..Or when your average toothpick swinger clicks his full combo and throws himself on top of the blast - priceless.

@Nicoya
Tier 2 players are too derp to know how to deal with bombers.
Nothing to really brag about. We're talking T3 lockdown here, the fastest and most competitive tier. Argue all you want, but T3 is the only real way to play. Foxxie racks up your stats and more in a higher tier.

Calling people derp because they use low * gear is rather mean. Sure, T3 has more competitive players. But who is to say that it is better? What if a player does not have access to the funds, p2p or not, to spend 800ce and 5kcr to upgrade into 5*? It is a big jump in crafting costs.
You could very well be right, but I don't think you are.

I'm just telling it like it is.
A new player will obviously not know how to deal with a bomber.
If you get 11 defends with sun shards then you are either very good, or your opponents are very bad.

Just because one person played against a bunch of really bad opponents does not make that tier itself, bad. I'm willing to bet that nicoya played many more games that he did not screenshot.

Even if they did have decent players in T2, it is likely that 3* loadouts cannot adequately deal with bombers.
Tell me when you're ready to play with the big boys Nicoya, we'll be waiting.

"Tell me when you're ready to play with the Very High ASI Final Flourish users, capable of 1-Hiting you, with Max Piercing Defence UVs on their Skolver Coats, Nicoya, we'll be waiting."
Fixed.

pretty much, it's endgame for a reason

@Neodasus I think you need to play some T2 lockdown before passing judgement like that. The only thing T3 lockdown has is a higher gear cost.
In fact, I'd honestly say that T1 lockdown is the most highly competitive tier. No credit card warriors buying their way to victory (Even Golza's insane UVs were lucky auction house finds) and doubly so now that everyone's been handed UV'ed 1* gear for free. T2 is a close second. Honestly, from what I've seen of T3 Lockdown, it's mostly half-geared players who think that they should just equip whatever the highest star equipment they have, mixed in with a few high rollers who have max shock skolver and VH ASI flourishes.
And if anyone doesn't want to get ripped to shreds by my shards, there's always options (never mind that the most common armor in T2 resists the piercing portion of the shards damage).

By the way Foxxie, never take Blueberrymuffin seriously. He gets mad at nearly everything.
http://imageshack.us/f/192/morelikeautolame.jpg/
@Nicoya
I did, the UVs are very strange there.
and if anyone doesn't want to get hit by your shards I suggest moving one inch to your right

Attempting to play Lockdown with "pure" loadouts of any weapon type will put you at an inherent disadvantage to an equally skilled player not choosing to play to the same limitations. That's not a matter of disputing the skill bombers, or gunners or even pure-swordsmen demonstrate, it's simply the nature of the way the game is designed. Neo had it right in his very first post in the thread, and this is coming from someone who chooses to play as a pure bomber most of the time.
That being said Spiral Knights is an immensely casual game and people getting mad over random Lockdown games where the barometer for skill is almost nonexistent is silly. I can't say I've ever encountered muffin but frankly (s)he sounds like they have some rather unfortunate anger managment issues and should be paid no mind. Stop worrying about childish scrubs on the internet getting upset over video games, laugh at them and continue to play however you wish to do so.

Bombers! Stand together! Ward off this assault on our dignity with flaming and general corruption!
@jen: Good point :)
Oh, and the "clone" combo consists of the following:
Polaris (ASI uv)
Gran Faust (ASI very high/<)
Final Flourish/Barbarous Thorn Blade (ASI very High/<)
Skolver Coat (Shock resistance >High)
Skolver Cap (Shock resistance >High)
Penta-Heart pendant/Tetra-Heart
Penta-Heart pendant/Tetra-Heart
Auto-Aim (Key Factour)
Did I forget anything???

Lol, you hit the bulls eye.
Tier 1 lockdown is the best imo. you don't die in half a second, or by a 2 hit combo. It is balanced in my opinion.
Im no clone in LD, sporting a chaos cowl, snarby coat, AP, flamberge, voltedge, gran-pa faust (im very fair using this. besides, its uv is CTR :3)
clones can be annoying, but what gets me more than anything is polaris spam.

IKR? I'm very radical in LD. I bomb and use a Winmillion.

I sometimes use Graviton Vortex in LD. I think it pisses the clones off even more than the haze bombs. Or maybe thats just me.

Bombs take a different kind of skill than swords. Strikers can attack then boost away from a counter attack, recons can go invisible after attacking, and Guardians can guard after attacking. When you're charging a bomb, you're helpless to walk around at a decreased speed with strikers boosting or shooting at you, if they manage to hit you, you're done for. You have to learn how to dodge shots and toothpicks then stop to drop a bomb. It's easy to tell good bombers from bad bombers, the good ones manage to put down a bomb. A good bomber is worth a lot more than another good swordie, it doesn't matter if it takes more skill to use the strongest and fastest class of weapons in the game. Bombers are very helpful for the rest of the team.
Oh, and Neo, I play T3, T2, and T1. Most T3ers I've fought can't do a darn thing to recons where as being recon in T2 is usually suicide. T1 is the land where skill matters most, UVs and Trinkets usually influencing T3 more than any other Tier. So T3 is only the best option for the richest players.

I love playing against bombers who think they can troll with graviton
I just jump in there while they bomb and 2hit with a Gran Faust
good stuff really

Bombing in LD made me sad. The most effective weapon I had overall was VT, which was very useful on non-rich strikers. Rich guys tended to have shock defense, which was usually enough for them to zip in and kill me with a couple pokes before shock set in, despite the dual pentas. Polaris spam wasn't too bad until my latency issues started catching up to me, then it would be "dodge around bull...OH WAIT get hit after all".
The last day I played I decided to not care about such things as dodging, protecting points, or generally doing anything but running forward with a nitro or FoV. I was actually pleasantly surprised with the usefulness of Nitro, although it could never put out enough to kill strikers before they killed me.
In all, LD favors lone wolves with pointies or guns, and support troops like bombers get the short end.
Now I just hope they don't add more recipes into Sullivan's menu.

Tier 3 random LD favors soloists
T3 GVG is completely different, and most winning teams have at least one bomber.
I just can't imagine T1/T2 GVG being that competitive.

T3 GvG is probably more balanced because the teams have experience with each other, probably have their strategies down better, and are probably overall better equipped than the average LD player, so the teams are a bit better balanced. Unfortunately, Bombers still don't have a good place in GvG LD because, like I mentioned, the teams tend to be much better geared, which means that mist bombs are wholly ineffective (The ones worth using for area denial, anyways.)
But in short, everything in GvG LD is rendered meaningless because some guilds out there only spam CE revives, and even if you outclass them in skill, just the fact that they come back so fast pretty much secures them a victory unless your team also wastes a bunch of CE on revives.

@fluffyfoxxie
my guild did pretty well in the 3 or 4 times we entered. We beat the #2 guild twice in a row :D
It always ends up with who's willing to spend more though, doesn't it. Same equipment? make better ones. Even level on equipment? buy UVs. Best UVs you can get for LD? Start spamming revs.
also, a lot of this is meaningless when you're on a slow/ connection with a laggy network fighting against a purpose-built rig on T1 hardlined. In full skolver/pentaheart trim, I was still able to be dispatched by a few mixed 4*/5* players who would just sort of show up on the screen corner, then be at the opposite corner when my "killed by" screen would come up.
also, gameplay is so irritatingly smooth-looking when I'm dead. "well, if my system was running like that, I probably wouldn't have died" >:(

The Polaris spam isn't so bad to me, as I tend to recon and go a different way to them and beat 'em up with a master blast. (almost to nitro :D. By the way have horrible lag when all I see is big blue columns of shockyness)

Stun bombs are invaluable in T3 GvG, just saying.

Apperantly if you don't think holding down a button for 2 (Maybe 1) seconds then releasing is "Mad Skills" that automatically make's you "Mad". @To all you bomber's who have claimed to have killed me multiple time's will remember it wasn't a 1 on 1 it was a 4 on 1..nothing wrong with that but just saying you can't take credit for killing me when it was a team-effort (Who's egotistic now?:). ANd for the last time, I DON'T HATE BOMBER'S!!!. to me clicking a button and holding it for 1 second and releasing isn't skill....Bombing is meant for support don't take your Team-mates for granted. And for the record I have bombed before (Clockworks/Lockdown) but sold my bomb stuff. @ as for the people who say they suck at bombing not to sound mean but maybe Lockdown isn't ur thing, 'Gnome sayin' homes?. And as for all the gunners who say I rage when they kill me same thing with the bombers, it wasn't a 1 on 1, the only gunners I remember killing me in a 1 on 1 is Blueflood (Obviously) and alot of people from Gunslinger priest and Echo of Sasuage and Grundal warriors. (ANd Tennis deserves his own title for spinning while gunning) And keep in mind I rarely use trinkets and have no UV's so I die in 3 shots and most gunners have HP trinkets which die in like 6 so if you kill me in 3 shots after I hit you 4 you don't really have much bragging rights *cough* Evilduck. THe whole point of Lockdown was to have fun (ANd make monies :D) And all people are different, don't expect us all to have the same opinions, alot of people say Striker/flourish takes no skill, I agree to an extent: Flourish ASI VH takes no skill, same with Flourish + Autoaim. but I use niether so really it's hard to hate on people who aim and didn't pay to have an advantage. guess the moral of the story here would be if everyone agreed on everything skill wouldn't exist. Don't get mad at me if I hurt ur Ego so big it can barely fit through the OSi layer when you log on. Sun shard spammers are easy enough if you took the time to learn the pattern, (Just like fighting vana when he gets decapatated) and I have an Argent peacemaker so I can pretty much skill any bomber who just sits in a field of bombs (Mad skills der foo') (Gonna be making Sentenza around the same time I build my new beast computer with 8 GB's of ram, so it's gonna be fun :). I guess my goal here was to make the biggest post on this thread, if you can beat it with a legit paragraph I'll give you 1 FREE scrap metal. Cheers.

I just can't imagine T1/T2 GVG being that competitive.
@Nicoya
We should have a shard duel. Although we'd have to miraculously get teammates that would allow us to do such sillyness and not toothpick/whack/bonk us to death midbattle. I.E. I tried it once with another bomber, we kept getting whacked by other players after they agreed not to :<

@ Blueberry
Wouldn't be a problem for anyone if people, like you, wouldn't rage and make fun of others because you did poorly in a round. You say LD is for fun, and I agree. So, stop trying to ruin that fun for others just to make yourself feel better.
Your oversimplification of bombing is appalling. "All you do is hold down mouse button for 1 second and release." I could turn around and say "All you do is spam click your opponent with flourish until they die." But, we both know neither is true.
You say that bombers never kill you one-on-one. I have a few times, though I'm not a pure bomber. You get angry at me because you are fool enough to dash into my Voltaic Tempest cloud. and then I stab or shoot you to death.
I don't even understand why you get angry. I'm pretty sure you've killed me more times than I've killed you. So, stop with the rage. Spread the love. :)

@Vescrit I've managed to have a few shard duels with fellow bombers. The key is to get enough shards going that no other players dare get close. :D

Bomber is the most vulnerable class out there as we can't do anything unless we get a complete charge. Skills isn't just dashing back and forth with a flourish, strategically planning a bomb is also skills too. Comeback to me if you can score 12k with a RSS.
Uh-Oh...