As much as it may pain me to admit it, I commend the original poster for finding old threads with decent content. Recent users lowered my opinion of necro spammers who bump a random old thread, especially the bad ones, and expect to be forgiven after the thirtieth time. The accumulative information would increase community interaction and keeping guild members close to each other.

I support the idea of giving guilds their own community, but keep in mind; there are many guilds which recruit anyone they see with the intent to recruit as many people as possible to brag about how many random people they can recruit. This is the majority of guilds. Guilds should be either a personal group of friends who know each other well enough to have their own small community or an army of people with a common cause and intent. Guilds which recruit anyone they see are, for lack of a formal term, what I refer to as "fodder farms". Fodder farms die and are born frequently and no one remembers them. Guilds which form communities are well worth participating in, though to join may be difficult depending on restrictions. I suppose the energy cost to make guilds benefits Three Rings seeing as people are willing to vomit their money into new guilds constantly.

Overall, yes; guilds should have more content to encourage players to participate in groups of people to increase interaction rather than isolation. As for the existence of this thread, consider it an index of threads with the same idea without necroing all the threads or reposting all of their content. Imagine if someone made one thread about dual wielding and linked a few good and bad threads relevant to the subject. I am not going to comment on the emoticons in this thread or post a silly video link.

Effort: 6/10
Creativity: 4/10
Detail: 8/10
Mechanical applicability: 9/10
Profits Three Rings: 7/10