Forums › English Language Forums › General › The Coliseum

Search

The reason behind ALL hate for auto-target

118 replies [Last post]
Sat, 06/29/2013 - 01:11
#51
Klipik-Forum's picture
Klipik-Forum
Also @Voza

Ever heard of a little game called Tribes?

Sat, 06/29/2013 - 05:42
#52
Shidara's picture
Shidara
@Klipik-Forum

Isn't that the point, though? If people become good enough at the game, they'll no longer need Auto Target to help them out, whilst those who do need it can keep improving until they as well no longer need it. If you remove Auto Target, you're only going to discourage newer players from trying out Lockdown and that's not a good thing.

If you want to go about and show off your skill by playing without Auto Target then by all means, just don't expect everybody else to follow suit only because you're at that point.

@Voza-Il
Putting an arbitrary limit only to hurt those who rely on Auto Target is not a solution and only serves to cause frustration when they can't play past a certain amount every week or else the feature gets turned off for no good reason. It isn't helping anybody as much as you might think it would.

Sat, 06/29/2013 - 06:45
#53
Bleyken's picture
Bleyken

AT is pro: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uLcLia5LnQg&feature=youtu.be

@Feller Mi 1k ce

Sat, 06/29/2013 - 07:27
#54
Klipik-Forum's picture
Klipik-Forum
The problem is that people

The problem is that people don't feel the need to improve their own skill, and in reality have little reason to do so. Once you've used AT for a long time and become dependend on it, getting rid of it and using only skill instead will result in a large amount of backward progress that isn't really worth it for the eventual chance that you might get better someday. It's a lot of work for a little, far away reward.

If removing AT would make it virtually impossible for new players to enter the scene, that is an inherent problem with LD itself that should be fixed instead of using AT to patch it up and create a whole host of its own problems.

Once again, it's a F. O. O. Strategy.

Sat, 06/29/2013 - 08:16
#55
Voza-Il's picture
Voza-Il
Coming from someone who

Coming from someone who doesn't get 20k dmg per game and has a fluctuating 1 to 4 bar connection, I think I can suggest that. Might help, might make people rage more, who knows...

Also, notice how I didn't call people with opposing opinions AA noobs? Thats cause I couldn't care less. Just trying to help the accused and to even the playing field. Though I must admit, this argument is rather pointless.

and @klipik haven't heard of that, don't really care to. Sorry.

@Shidara After having AA integrated in LD for so long, I guess you're right, taking it out now wouldn't benefit much. Seems like it was just a bad idea from the start.

To BATTLE!

Sat, 06/29/2013 - 10:52
#56
Our-Little-Ajo
Already pay my debt.

@Contri

I heard that after this video you recieve guild invites from Jemps, unity, clímax, eos and some friend invites from Red, ice, snAArk, ruby, drav, drAAg, and a bunch more !!!

That's 100% success !!!!!!!!

Sat, 06/29/2013 - 11:39
#57
Klipik-Forum's picture
Klipik-Forum
I will tell you anyway

Tribes: A sci-fi FPS. Includes jetpacks and a skiing mechanic that allows players to move at speeds exceeding 200mph. The majority of weapons are both projectile-based (meaning the bullets have travel time) and have falloff (the bullets do not travel in a straight line). No auto-target whatsoever, and yet players still manage to hit each other midair.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bcNnU3D5rHc

Sun, 06/30/2013 - 19:17
#58
Redblades's picture
Redblades
-

@feller
yeah I sent contri an invite to 4 of my alt guilds, my real guild, my friend list, my fsc party and my bedroom.

Mon, 07/01/2013 - 05:39
#59
Theirillusion's picture
Theirillusion

ALL players, with any level of skill, with any connection, that use autotarget, are noobs.

new subject: lets play "find dragneels post without the word connection in it". is too hard and time wasting for me so you can do it instead.

Mon, 07/01/2013 - 07:43
#60
Redblades's picture
Redblades
-

http://forums.spiralknights.com/en/node/83322

Mon, 07/01/2013 - 07:43
#61
Redblades's picture
Redblades
"ALL players, with any level

"ALL players, with any level of skill, with any connection, that use autotarget, are noobs."
LOL

Mon, 07/01/2013 - 07:46
#62
Bleyken's picture
Bleyken

+1 to Their

Mon, 07/01/2013 - 07:55
#63
Grugwasasailor
You're all wrong

The reason behind all the hate for AT is because theres too many laggy foreigners.

Mon, 07/01/2013 - 08:56
#64
Dragneel-Wiki's picture
Dragneel-Wiki

@Theirillusion:

Says the one who got 0 ping and plays on 4 bars all the time. If you don't know the feeling of having delays and getting hit by tiles away, shut up. Oh by the way, your joke is lame.

Mon, 07/01/2013 - 09:24
#65
Bleyken's picture
Bleyken

@DrAAgneel I have worse conection than you and I think the same than Their, if you have bad conection learn to play better, AT is for noobies.

Mon, 07/01/2013 - 09:37
#66
Our-Little-Ajo
Yo nooba

I have the worst lag in this game and I've never use it as an excuse to turn AIMBOT "on".

Besides, the ones who abuse more are the ones with the best latency.

Mon, 07/01/2013 - 12:02
#67
Dragneel-Wiki's picture
Dragneel-Wiki

@Contri:

No. Your videos proved to me that my lag is worse than yours. And about Their, go check his videos, all of them are played with 4bars. And learning here doesn't work, since you need to predict the future to not get hit from miles...

@Feller:

That's your problem. Don't moan about you, being pwned by others because of your connection. OOO made AT to help miserable people like you, and you aren't accepting it, because of your tiny pride. That's something up to you, think about it.

Mon, 07/01/2013 - 13:36
#68
Our-Little-Ajo
Being pwned????

I'm one of the no - AT champ, I've been AT the "top of the notch" from the begining of LD and I still HATE AT, I usually win/be on top of every game I play, and I don't even feel the NEED of use my million CE Skolver set.

I have a iPhone conection, 1 bar latency and I'm not an AT'homo like you.

I don't use AT because I have too much testosterone, and I simply don't need a noob feature to aim for me. And if some day I'm without hands, I'll use my .... To aim but NEVER AT.

Mon, 07/01/2013 - 17:53
#69
Canozo's picture
Canozo

I'm running out of popcorn gifs

Mon, 07/01/2013 - 18:21
#70
Ink-Incorporated's picture
Ink-Incorporated

If auto target is so bad and it makes you so overpowered, how come Three Rings IMPLEMENTED it in the game themselves for everyone to use for free?

It can't be so devilishly bad if it was actually implemented by the developers for everyone's free use.

I'm on the "I don't care whether people use auto target or not." side, but there's so many people on the "Auto target is for noobs." side.

If you're on my side then thank you.

Some people probably don't know that they have auto target on because it's on you at first glance without telling you.

I'm pretty sure everyone has used auto target at least once in their Spiral Knights history.

Mon, 07/01/2013 - 20:57
#71
Klipik-Forum's picture
Klipik-Forum
@Ink

Because OOO does not take LD seriously, so they don't care if it's imbalanced or competitively broken. Much to the dismay of a portion of the playerbase.

And for the record, I turned AT off as soon as I found out about it. :P

Mon, 07/01/2013 - 21:59
#72
Theirillusion's picture
Theirillusion
@Dragneel-Wiki

I started this game with 2 bars.

Now I have 4 bars. I don't use AT on EU server, and I don't use AT on US server where I have 3 bars.

I have an iPhone that can share internet. When I've used this I've had 2 very unsteady bars. Stop saying that I don't know when I clearly do.

Also, what joke are you talking about?

Edit: Watching my videos was agreat idea, give me views. (lol xD)

Tue, 07/02/2013 - 02:30
#73
Bleyken's picture
Bleyken

3 bars in US....... lucky noobie......

Tue, 07/02/2013 - 03:32
#74
Dragneel-Wiki's picture
Dragneel-Wiki

@Theirillusion:

Not sure if you are talking seriously, or just....

You just proved my point. You aren't lagging, therefore, you have no right to say that AT-People are all noobs. And how many times did you lag in your SK career? Once? Twice? Thrice? 10 times?! For God's sake stop talking and proving my point further.

@Feller:

Seriously, stop ego-pumping yourself. When I used to see your old posts, and your attacks on other people about how unskilled they are, I decided to spectate you in LD, and guess what, your fighting is lame. Gran Faust here, then Polaris there, and then your team loses because you were yawning the whole match. I am pretty sure that you have something called: Megalomania.

1. English link to your state.
2. Spanish link, just for you.

Tue, 07/02/2013 - 04:10
#75
Theirillusion's picture
Theirillusion
@Dragneel

Just because I have 4 bars doesn't mean I havn't got a clue about how it is to play with bad connection. That's not proving your point at all.

They (here: you) are noobs!

Tue, 07/02/2013 - 04:52
#76
Reto-Da-Liz's picture
Reto-Da-Liz
@Canozo

http://www.popcorngif.com/63/billy-walker-eating-popcorn/

Tue, 07/02/2013 - 04:55
#77
Dragneel-Wiki's picture
Dragneel-Wiki

@Theirillusion:

...

Tue, 07/02/2013 - 07:31
#78
Our-Little-Ajo
The one who /yawn is Country

I don't talk to NO ONE when I'm playing, even if I'm getting valiance/Brandish/FF/AT spamed.

After 2 years I just don't talk to noobs unless they start bothering me, and that usually end in /ignore.

AT is for noobs. Period.

Tue, 07/02/2013 - 12:37
#79
Feyi-Feyi's picture
Feyi-Feyi
So I come back to this.

So I decided to look at the fora again, it had been a month or so. Still making me want to eat popcorn, thanks for the GIF's.
This issue has long been decided. It has been ever since Thrillhaus made the lobbies thread..

You don't have to take AT out of the game, you just have to give people the choice. No people harmed, everyone happy.
Unless you're being difficult, in which case: go sit on some lava or something.

Now OOO has as Klipik says not given any reason for us to believe they care.. Until they made the very forum this thread is on.
We have a LD forum now, and it gives me a tiny bit of hope they'll do something about the current (very sad) state of LD.

So, if you want to get this over with: 1up the Thrillhaus thread. I believe it has been moved here.

Tue, 07/02/2013 - 15:36
#80
Our-Little-Ajo
I'll find that suggestion

So we can continue adding more replies until OOO gives us AT LEAST A DECENT ANSWER.

Just like Feyi said, I don't want it out of the game, I just want an option.

Tue, 07/02/2013 - 20:39
#81
Dfliyerz's picture
Dfliyerz
This thread is giving me so

This thread is giving me so many laughs.

Thu, 07/04/2013 - 04:51
#82
Krakob's picture
Krakob
@Feyi

Last time I checked, it was a PvP forum. Not specifically for LD. I'm with Dfliyerz. I gave up on this more than a while ago.

Fri, 07/05/2013 - 01:05
#83
Klipik-Forum's picture
Klipik-Forum

While Thrill's thread is a good solution, it's far from perfect. It does nothing to "fix" the spammability/percieved OPness of AT or problematic gear. It simply isolates the "elitist" players from the ones who don't care.

Ideally, the game would be correctly balanced so that spamming and AT dependency/toggling is only a viable strategy up to a certain point, and would gently nudge players in the direction of more skill-based strategies which would reward them with better performance. At the same time it would have a rank-weighted queuing system so that if enough players are playing, the lower-skill players would be kept separate from the high-skill ones until they were ready, which would further improve the experience of all players (except those who take sport in crushing noobs. For them, Alts.). And there would also be the option to create custom lobbies as detailed in Thrill's thread, for actual competitions like tourneys.

Fri, 07/05/2013 - 02:24
#84
Krakob's picture
Krakob

dis thred

Fri, 07/05/2013 - 16:16
#85
Zeddy's picture
Zeddy
Wait a goddamn second

Klipik, you're the one who keeps linking that Extra Credit video about perfect imbalance, why are you against auto-target? Auto-target is mostly just good for swords, right? AT swords are hilariously easily countered with literally any handgun or bomb. They're easily countered by at least 60% of the game's arsenal. AT swords is the slightly stronger tactic you think should exist, but it's pretty useless against bombs and guns.

Fri, 07/05/2013 - 17:34
#86
Klipik-Forum's picture
Klipik-Forum

Because of This other video I keep linking. Auto target, along with many swords and a few guns, is too effective for its ease of use. Not using auto target, or using certain weapons, might be more effective than these strategies, but the amount of improvement over these "spammable" strats is not even close to worth the amount of time and effort required to be even equal to a "clone" in terms of effectiveness.

Fri, 07/05/2013 - 19:03
#87
Zeddy's picture
Zeddy
@Klipik

Did you miss what I said? It's trivial to counter. An AT flourish has nothing on a Nitronome.

How is that too effective? Just counter it with any bomb, including freaking shard bombs, or any gun while keeping your distance.

For AT handguns, all you need to do is strafe.

Fri, 07/05/2013 - 21:02
#88
Klipik-Forum's picture
Klipik-Forum

You say "trivial". It might be trivial to you, an expert bomber, but what about someone picking the game up for the first time? AT Flourish or brandish comboing is going to be much more attractive than bombing or gunning, for a number of reasons.

It is easier. Simply clicking in the general direction of the target, and usually getting hits, is much simpler to grasp and execute than bombing or gunning. Bombing requires an awful lot of prediction and knowledge of timing, players' and classes' tendencies, while gunning requires leading the target as well as preserving ammo, and keeping the enemy at bay.

It is more effective at a low skill level. Because it is the easiest to pick up, a novice will have best results with the AT sword strategy than any other.

Everyone else does it. if they see the highest damage consistently being dealt by Dusker/Skolver clones, players new to LD will think that it's the best strat and follow in their footsteps.

That combination makes AT sword users the majority. What's left are playstyles that are both less effective to all but experts, and harder to learn. So the metagame doesn't shift, because not enough people are willing to go through a fairly steep learning curve to get on level ground with where they were maybe a month ago. And I say level ground... A team of AT-dependent, low-to-medium experience Wolver clones with flourishes, hammers, and pulsars will tear through a team of bombers or gunners at the same skill level. The same goes for 1v1.

Fri, 07/05/2013 - 21:19
#89
Zeddy's picture
Zeddy

Ehhh, PvP bombing is really just a matter of continously spamming the same bomb over and over while keeping the bomb between you and your opponent. You might be surprised how awful I actually am at this game.

You wanna fight a newbie? Lay some Voltaic Tempest and cover the CP as much as you can, they really won't stand a snowball's chance. It takes some serious skill to dash in and hit a Nitro-spammer between bombs, as well. You, as a bomber, don't even have to aim, I often literally just run around in a triangle spamming bombs and then die when someone who actually has a clue what they're doing shows up, but not before.

The bombs are there, and it's noone's fault but yours for not using them. I'm pretty convinced the bomber team in your example would win the match, and they wouldn't even have a very hard time doing it. The flourishes and hammers would be no help against the clouds of shock hazes, so all the team would have to do is dodge Polaris a bunch. If anyone on the team has a handgun, they could stay inside their team's hazes and fire at the Polaris users. None of this is hard to perform.

No matter who wins, auto-target is entirely out of the equation. What's AT going to help a Polaris spammer?

Sat, 07/06/2013 - 09:30
#90
Klipik-Forum's picture
Klipik-Forum

I think the reason no one uses bombs is because of PvE. Bombs are harder to use in PvE, and to get 5* gear purely for PvP is a luxury not too many players can afford. In T2, where gear is cheaper, bombs are smaller and nowhere near as effective. Plus, bomber gear doesn't give as much CTR, so you can't drop bombs as fast.

No matter the cause, AT swords are still the dominant strategy. Even if bombs might be better in some way, people are not switching and will not switch until something changes.

And also, clones are easier to beat with swords than bombs - with bombs, they kill you before you can get a bomb charged, down, and off, unless you had one prepared already. Swords don't require preparation.

Sat, 07/06/2013 - 14:54
#91
Zeddy's picture
Zeddy
@Klipik

That sounds about right.

Sat, 07/06/2013 - 20:40
#92
Coelydragon's picture
Coelydragon

I don't usually come around to the coliseum due to my preference of BN over LD but this was too funny to ignore. So I'll throw in my two crowns worth. Basically: if you want strategy, play Blast Network. If you wanting fighting with some strategy and some beat-em-up do PvE. If you want chaos, play LD. I have yet to hear someone say that there is a viable strategy in Lockdown. By this I don't include loadouts; I mean literal strategy. In Blast Network I won 10-2 when my teammate left early. I used a viable strategy. In PvE the strategy for compounds is to have someone bring up the rear then make a break for it in the last room. In Lockdown I have yet to discover a way to win. Striker U dashes are techniques. Spamming whatever is a technique (a simple one at that). AA is not a technique however. It's basically like a trinket. A uv. A buff. It's amoral. It's not evil. It's useful to an extent. It's not OP. it's just there, just like everything else that you can use in Lockdown. I think Feller, Contri, and Redblades just enjoy using the forums as another form of PvP. They're the reasons for all the hate against AA (at least in the forums).

Sat, 07/06/2013 - 22:19
#93
Klipik-Forum's picture
Klipik-Forum

You're right and wrong. The reason you see no strategy in LD is because you're playing RLD (random LD). Watch some gvgs. Even my T2-focused LD guild has some semblance of a group strategy when we go into a game, because we plan it out beforehand. These people use this loadout and parter with these people, get these points at the start, stay in this area, etc. Sure, sometimes it falls apart when the entire other team made up of players who could each 2v1 or 3v1 our players goes striker mob and runs in a circle capping all the points and destroying everything in their path, but in an evenly matched game or one where we have a slightly lower raw skill quotient, strategy and teamwork can make or break the game for us.

Still, you are right that LD is more reliant on twitch skill, mechanics, and technique than strategy. But it's that that makes AT so wrong. In a game reliant upon precision and mechanical skill, giving players a way to artificially augment their precision is one of the worst things you can do. The other worst thing you can do is take away the need for such precision - with spammy weapons like hammer and Polaris.

P.S: There's more than one kind of teamwork. <3

Sun, 07/07/2013 - 02:46
#94
Coelydragon's picture
Coelydragon

Interesting. The only GvG match I've seen involved Jempire and that was just a bunch of stuff that I saw in RLD. Ok, so there's some strategy possible. How would your team do against a bunch of hammer spammers, flourish spammers, nitronome spammers, polaris spammers, etc. all using AA (perhaps not the nitronome users). My guess is they'd be smashed pretty badly, no offense. Perhaps you have a strategy in which a nitronome (and I'm using T3 terms because it's easier) use blocks up the CP while a gunner hides in the blast and shoots at any opposition. All the opponent needs is a recon to sneak up and destroy the nitronome guy while he's charged (removed invincitinks). Then he can proceed to spam away on the gunner who is now vulnerable. Maybe your strategy is different. Either way, all it takes is one wrong move and chaos rules. The reason "spammy" weapons are allowed in lockdown are because they are already implemented in PvE and because the chaos is what makes Lockdown attractive. No new person wants to join an already-strategized game where the opponent knows everything and destroys them easily. They want an easy, simple game where they have a possibility to win with just a few techniques and powerful weaponry.

Sun, 07/07/2013 - 07:19
#95
Klipik-Forum's picture
Klipik-Forum

"They want an easy, simple game where they have a possibility to win with just a few techniques and powerful weaponry"... and letting the computer do the work for them.

As I've said before (I think, at least somewhere), AT is the wrong solution to the problem of attracting new players to LD. The better way to do it is a ranked system, so people who don't know what they're doing can get matched with other newbies. Then if all the weapons are mostly skill-based, you slowly learn to use them and climb up the ladder into the higher tiers, where you meet other players who know what to do just like you do.

Whether or not we beat a team of spammers depends on the map, our players, and our strategy that game. If we see the other team is striker mobbing with spammmmmm everywhere, we might take a few more gunners or guard bombers in a big group to stop the polaris spam and rampant capping, while others go for sword striker to deal with the hammers and flourishes. Once we killed a significant number of them, they'll be scattered and we can go back to just holding them off in small groups.

Sun, 07/07/2013 - 11:44
#96
Lecehboy's picture
Lecehboy
be an annoying bomber

be a bomber and nobody's gonna say youat/aa noob. they just wish you dont exist.

besides, as a bomber i never know whether people use aa or not... keep bombing till someone die and hurrah.. next person

Tue, 07/09/2013 - 09:26
#97
Redblades's picture
Redblades
-

I think Feller, Contri, and Redblades just enjoy using the forums as another form of PvP. They're the reasons for all the hate against AA (at least in the forums).

bingo except I usually have viable points while feller and contri just bash on people

Tue, 07/09/2013 - 10:07
#98
Our-Little-Ajo
Indeed

This is entertaining as LD itself. And I'm quite sure there's a lot of people who enjoy all this just watching... Like voyeur style...

I like when ppl who haven't fight against me says to me in randoms "So you're the Feller, I'm gonna kill you because you're annoying".. 10 mins later... Their B.... Is so R...ed they can't sit.

Tue, 07/09/2013 - 11:43
#99
Our-Little-Ajo
I also love

When AT one swing users complains against "comboers".. And both are the same garbage...

That happend a lot.. I usually don't talk at all.. And everytime I play I read this kind of crap from AT users themselves

"Nice AA"
"AT noob"
"Turn OFF AT noob"
"Nice Aimbot"

I always answer, don't complain if you're using it too... 3 secs later and I'm arguing with a noob, and getting banned for sexual comments

Tue, 07/09/2013 - 10:54
#100
Bleyken's picture
Bleyken

@RedblAAdes You don't have viable points!!! You are a noob spammer!!!

  • « first
  • ‹ previous
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • next ›
  • last »
Powered by Drupal, an open source content management system