OK first this is NOT a suggestion thread, it is discussion of what suggestions in the past were the best but not yet implemented.
This one wins for me: http://forums.spiralknights.com/en/node/38341
What it is is an idea of a Snarbolax Gun, with a short explanation and art by Incoherrant.
I see nothing more beautiful and perfect.
What do you think is the best suggestion that was never implemented? please leave a link to the original thread too.
Because this is not a suggestion thread we need to discuss, why do you think this should be implemented? I think that sounds like a good idea too.
Becuase the most detailed and intricate demo suit, mercrucial demo, has no bomberhead! Plus, the current knightbot helm that goes with it dosen't even tit into the neckpeice, and besides, all the other armor colors have a bombhead save for divine.
Psh, obviously buffing toothpicks in lockdown.
But really, I think this is. Because most people are annoyed by the grinding that happens at the end of the game, I think it is important that OOO adds more Colosseum games for end game people. And these two are well thought out, seem like a lot of fun, and one could use a lot of the programming from lockdown, and they both use a lot of the existing art, so it would be easy to implement.
Probably some pretty basic stuff like better lockdown matchmaking.
The ones I can think of off the top of my head that I like...
1) Gunslinger Shadow Lair Armor
2) Buff Shadowsun Set
3) Antigua fix
4) Bomber/Gunslinger love
5) More Beast-type enemies (There are Wolvers, Chromalisks and Snarby... Not that much variety beyond recolors)
6) Dragons (cough cough see #5)
7) King Trinkinzar Gremlin Boss
8) Faster Mist Energy Regen
9) Drift away from the "Hat Fortress 2" mindset
I am all for 2, 3, and 4!!!!!
Not so much number 1. we just need to get deadshot only guns to make it OUR armor.
Shadowsun buff, that's a given
Antigua fix definately, and add snarbolax gun idea link is in OP!!!!
Bomber love especially!
LMAO
-Rolling back the server 2-3 days after the Auction House update... that would have probably been the greatest.
In no order,
a Gunslinger Shadow Lair Set.
Buff the Shadowsun Set.
PvP dueling.
I don't know if this was a suggestion by nick or not, but the Antigua line changes.
Put tortodrone in the treasure vault. (Edited in via Iceeboy)
A Snarbolax gun, that is a piercing antigua line for when they change the split damage to full damage! (Edited in via suggestions)
Renpartycat to leave the forums.
The last one is probably the best though, all the others are good.
Gunslinger Shadow Lair set
Shadowsun buff
Antigua line changes (those are coming though)
Shadow and Elemental damage bombs
~Gwen
Option to mail people from friend/guild lists. It's so simple yet not implemented D:
What should be implemented? Something that will make gameplay better for ALL or MOST of players instead of making game better for certain group of players.
Like, Epson-Stylus suggestion, and some listed in Watermelon-Soda thread:
http://forums.spiralknights.com/en/node/37190
1) Full Inspect: Friends. Party Members. Guilds. No One. [Nicoya-Kitty]
4) Krogmo Alchemy Machine Recipe Placement Organisation [Watermelon-Soda]
5) Guild Notice [Watermelon-Soda]
7) Featured Auctions Not Set As Auction House Default [Dirge-Knight]
8) Closed Event Hub By Default When Logging On [Asukalanforum]
11) Tabbed Chat [Orangeo]
Those suggestions will improve gameplay for most of players, while buffs, new weapons/armors will incrase gameplay experience for only narrow group of players.
A snarby crossbow is probably my top pick in terms of specific suggestions. Single shot clip, long range, high damage, fast, piercing shot.
I think there needs to be an overhaul of guns and gunslinger gear, but I have yet to see a specific, actionable suggestion that seems appropriate.
Oh, agree.
Tabbed Chat, Guild Notice, and mass mail all would be fantastic.
~Gwen
i would love tabbed chat.
some actual new content would be nice too.
Do away with Shadow Keys. The shadow lairs are cool new content--that are way too expensive. It costs five dollars worth of CE to for a Shadow key--that's one attempt at one set of levels--ludicrously overpriced.
The Shadow Lairs were a great idea: they're challenging high-level content, interesting "plot" points, and added some interesting high level gear, but the implementation was lamentable.
A hundred CE might be a fair price (though, honestly, I don't see any good reason at all for them to cost any more than any other set of levels).
Or, you can split the cost between four players, go craft the armor, sell it, and make 2K ce profit.
Oh btw, you make money off of a shadow lair snarby run if you split the cost between four.
And that's without crafting the armor and selling it, that's a bonus.
Map creation. A lot of ideas are good and could be added with less effort, but in terms of the best possible idea, map creation... it would be amazing.
Sealed sword is already pretty flavorful bro.
"I think there needs to be an overhaul of guns and gunslinger gear, but I have yet to see a specific, actionable suggestion that seems appropriate."
Guns do not need anything durastic... just a few changes here and there. If you think they do need to have durastic changes, make sure you aren't judging guns in wolver armor / wrong trinkets.
Am I the onlyone imagining the so-called Snarbolax Gun as the Needler from Halo?
"Antigua fix"
They're making it pure elemental w/undead bonus.
Allot of the random gunslinger gear is just leftover beta crap, like the cautery sword. Deadshot is actualy ok seeming if your playing UFSC. Mix it with a volcanic peice and walah. Plus it rounds you out, adding damage (to zombies) instead of speed.
"Guns do not need anything durastic"
Drastic*
And it's not the guns, prese, but the gunslinger armor.
Nicoya's suggestion for charge timer changes.
Snarbolax Armor
Nuff said
Now give us the tail accessory Nick D:
Bombhead to match mercrucial demo/ironmight plate mail.