Alternate normal dimension me comes, points Lamnoone to something and wrings the cookie out of his body like water to a sponge, the cookies juice solidifies into a normal cookie due to new dimension logic and i run back to self's dimension with it.
Edits have been made.
In that new dimension we look funny. We only have one eye. Scales cover our bodies like fish and everyone is bald. We speak a language none of us ever knew before. Rather than having mouths, we absorb food molecules through our skin. I quickly grab the cookie out of your hand before it disappears and squeeze it. It sinks into my body and gets eaten.