In the other plane of existence, everyone's social role is reversed. Instead of you stalking me and me avoiding you, it's me that stalks you and you're the one avoiding me.
IAAAAAAAMMMMM!!!!!! Glomps Iamnoone and hugs bone-crushingly tight. Easily breaks Iamnoone's tiny gremlin stature, and leaving the cookie for me. Takes the cookie and give Iamnoone a kiss on the nose before leaving him with it.
Smacks you in the face with an iron frying as you start to reappear in the present and grab the cookie out of your hand before you get knocked back into the past. I use my super mind powers and go to another plain of existence with the cookie.